• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

No Men are Foreign: part 4, the warning and the clever ending

Explain the last part of the poem: why hating others harms ourselves, how war dirties the shared earth and air, and why the first line returns with two words swapped. Answer the book's questions on the theme.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain lines 13-20 of the poem in your own words.
  • Say what, according to the poet, happens if we hate our fellow human beings.
  • Explain how war harms the earth and air that belong to everyone.
  • Explain the effect of the last line, which repeats the first with two words swapped.
  • State the theme and the inspiration we can draw from the poem.

The first three parts of the poem have collected evidence: one body, one earth, one life, one heart. The last part draws the conclusion and gives a warning. It is the part that answers the book's question: what will happen if we hate our fellow beings?

When we are told to hate

The poet asks us to remember something whenever we are told to hate our 'brothers' in another land. Notice the word 'told': hatred of other nations is usually taught to people, by propaganda, by leaders who want war, or by prejudice passed down. It is not natural. The poet says that if we obey and hate, it is really ourselves that we shall dispossess, betray and condemn. Since all people are one family, hurting them means hurting our own family. We take away what is ours (dispossess), we are disloyal to our own kind (betray), and we pass judgement on our own nature (condemn).

The three verbs of the warning.
VerbMeaningHow hatred does this to ourselves
dispossessto take away what someone ownsWe rob ourselves of friendship and of a shared world.
betrayto be disloyalWe turn against our own human family.
condemnto declare guilty, to strongly disapproveWe pass sentence on ourselves, because they are like us.

Taking up arms defiles the earth

Next the poet speaks to all of us who take up arms, that is, pick up weapons, against each other. He says that in doing so we defile, or make dirty, the human earth. The earth belongs to all humanity, so war spoils our own home. He then describes the fire and dust of battle, bombs, burning cities and smoke, as 'hells' that we ourselves create. These hells outrage, that is, violate and insult, the innocence of the air, which is our own everywhere. Air is innocent: it has done nothing wrong and it belongs to no side. Yet war fills it with smoke and poison, and everyone has to breathe it.

The word hells is a metaphor: the battlefield, with its fire and dust, is compared to hell, a place of endless suffering. The air is given a human quality, innocence, which is a kind of personification.

The clever ending

The poem ends by coming back to its first line, with one small change. At the start the poet said that no men are strange and no countries foreign. At the end he says that no men are foreign and no countries strange. The two describing words have changed places. This crossing-over of words is a pattern called chiasmus. Its effect is to close the poem like a circle, so the message is the first and the last thing we hear. The swap also shows that 'strange' and 'foreign' are equally false labels: whichever way round you put them, they do not fit any person or any country.

Warning of the poem: hatred and war do not harm only 'them'; they harm us and the earth and air we all share.

Theme and inspiration

  • Universal brotherhood: all human beings form one family; national and other differences are made by people and are only on the surface.
  • Against war and hatred: war starves people, dirties the earth and poisons the air, and hatred of others is really self-harm.
  • Love as strength: we win others over by love, not by force.
  • Inspiration: the poem inspires us to treat every person as an equal, to refuse to hate people because of their country, and to work for peace.

Worked example 1: the book's true-or-false task

The PSEB textbook asks you to mark statements true or false. Here is the method with sentences of our own. 'The poet thinks soldiers of other armies are our enemies by nature.' Working: the poem says a single body breathes beneath all uniforms and that strength can be won by love. Answer: false. 'The poet believes war harms the earth that belongs to everyone.' Working: he says taking up arms defiles the human earth. Answer: true. Always check a statement against what the poem actually says, not against what you feel.

Worked example 2: what if we hate?

Question: What will happen if we hate our fellow beings? Working: find the lines about being told to hate. The poet says that then we dispossess, betray and condemn ourselves, and the next lines add that war dirties the earth and air. Answer: if we hate others, we really harm ourselves, because they are our own people; and hatred that leads to war destroys the shared earth and air on which we all depend.

Key takeaways: part 4 warns that hating others is hating ourselves and that war defiles the human earth and the innocent air. The last line repeats the first with 'strange' and 'foreign' swapped, closing the poem in a circle. The theme is universal brotherhood and peace.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the poem, whom do we really harm when we hate our 'brothers' in other lands?

    1. Only our enemies
    2. Only the leaders of other countries
    3. Nobody at all
    4. Ourselves
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The poet says that when we are told to hate others, it is ourselves that we dispossess, betray and condemn, because all people are one family.

  2. 2. What does 'defile' mean in the poem?

    1. To defend
    2. To make dirty or impure
    3. To divide into parts
    4. To march in a line
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The glossary gives 'defile' as to make foul or dirty. The poet says that taking up arms defiles the human earth.

  3. 3. Why is the air called innocent?

    1. Because it is invisible
    2. Because children breathe it
    3. Because it has done no wrong and belongs to no side, yet war pollutes it
    4. Because it is very cold
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Air takes no part in quarrels and is shared by everyone. War's fire and dust insult this innocence by filling the air with smoke, so the poet gives the air a human quality, innocence.

  4. 4. How is the last line of the poem related to the first?

    1. It repeats the first line with 'strange' and 'foreign' swapped.
    2. It says the opposite of the first line.
    3. It is exactly the same, word for word.
    4. It has no link with the first line.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The first line says no men are strange and no countries foreign; the last says no men are foreign and no countries strange. The two describing words have changed places, a pattern called chiasmus, which closes the poem in a circle.

  5. 5. Which statement best gives the theme of the poem?

    1. Every country should build a strong army.
    2. Travel to foreign countries is dangerous.
    3. People of different countries are too different to understand each other.
    4. All human beings are one family, so hatred and war are wrong.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The whole poem gives evidence that all people share one body, earth, life and heart, and warns that hatred and war harm us all. So its theme is universal brotherhood and peace.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery