- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
No Men are Foreign: the poet, the idea and the first part
Know who James Kirkup was, as the PSEB textbook introduces him, state the central idea of the poem, see how it is built, and explain its first five lines in your own words.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Say who wrote the poem and what the PSEB textbook tells us about him.
- State the central idea of the poem in one or two sentences.
- Describe how the poem is built: twenty lines, four parts, one repeated word.
- Explain the first part of the poem in your own words.
No Men are Foreign is the second poem in the 'Enjoying Poetry' section of the PSEB textbook, the English Main Course Book for Class IX of the Punjab School Education Board (PSEB). It is printed as Enjoying Poetry (II), after Lesson 4. It is a short poem, but it carries one of the biggest ideas a poem can carry: that every human being on earth belongs to one family, and that war and hatred are a crime against that family. Read it slowly, because almost every line gives a new reason why people of other countries are not really 'foreign' at all.
The poet
The poem is by James Kirkup, a British poet. The note in the PSEB textbook tells us that he won the Atlantic Award for Literature in 1950, that he also wrote plays, and that he worked as a Professor of English in Stockholm and at Tohoku University in Sendai, Japan. The book calls him a versatile writer, which means a writer who can work well in many different forms. Because he lived and taught in several countries, it is easy to see why he would write about people of other lands as brothers and sisters rather than strangers. (The textbook gives his year of birth as 1923; most reference works give 1918. Your teacher will tell you which to use.)
The central idea
The short introduction printed above the poem sums up its message: all people are equal, the differences between them are made by human beings and mean nothing, and we should turn the earth into a place of peace and joy built on love and trust. The poet makes his case by pointing to what all people share: the same body, the same earth, the same sun, air and water, the same work, the same need for food and sleep, and the same power to be won over by love. If all this is shared, then hating 'foreigners' really means hating ourselves.
Central idea in one line: beneath every difference of country and uniform we are one human family, so to hate or fight another people is to harm ourselves and our own earth.
How the poem is built
The poem has twenty lines, which fall into four parts of five lines each. It does not rhyme regularly; it is closer to thoughtful speech than to song. The word Remember keeps coming back, almost like a teacher tapping the desk, so that the reader cannot forget the point. The poem also begins and ends with nearly the same line, with two words swapped round. We will study that clever ending in lesson 3.
The poem in four parts
- Part 1: one body, one earth The same body under every uniform; the same earth to walk on and be buried in; the same sun, air and water.
- Part 2: one life The same hunger in war and food in peace; hands that do the same kind of work.
- Part 3: one heart The same eyes that wake and sleep; strength that love can win; a common life in every land.
- Part 4: one warning Hating others harms ourselves; war dirties the shared earth and air.
Part 1 explained (lines 1-5)
The poem opens with a reminder: no people are strange to us and no country is foreign. The poet then gives his first proof. Soldiers of different nations wear different uniforms, but under the cloth there is the same kind of body, breathing just as ours does. Here 'uniforms' stands for everything that marks people as different: army dress, national costume, even flags and badges.
Next he looks at the ground. The land on which our 'brothers' in other countries walk is the same earth as ours, and it is the earth in which all of us will one day be buried. In death no one is foreign: everyone returns to the same soil. Finally, he says that people everywhere know the same sun, air and water. These are not owned by any nation; they are the common gifts of nature on which every life depends.
| What the poet points to | What it proves |
|---|---|
| The body under every uniform | Our bodies are alike; uniforms are only on the outside. |
| The earth others walk on | We all live on, and are buried in, the same earth. |
| Sun, air and water | We all depend on the same gifts of nature. |
Worked example 1: why 'uniforms'?
Question: Why does the poet speak of uniforms in the opening lines? Working: a uniform is worn by a soldier or a member of a group, and it shows which side the person is on. In war, uniforms are what make us see an enemy. The poet asks us to look underneath. Answer: uniforms stand for the outer marks that divide people into nations and armies; underneath them every person has the same breathing body, so the division is only on the surface.
Worked example 2: the earth in which we all shall lie
Question: What does the poet mean when he says the earth is the one in which we shall all lie? Working: 'lie' in the earth means to be buried after death. Every person, whatever the country, ends in the same soil. Answer: he means that death makes everyone equal; we all go back to the same earth, so no one is truly a stranger.
Key takeaways: James Kirkup's poem, as the PSEB textbook presents it, argues that all people are one family. It has twenty lines in four parts, with the word 'Remember' repeated. Part 1 proves our oneness through the same body under every uniform, the same earth and the same sun, air and water.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the note in the PSEB textbook, which award did James Kirkup win in 1950?
- The Nobel Prize for Literature
- The Atlantic Award for Literature
- The Sahitya Akademi Award
- The Booker Prize
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook's note on the poet says he won the Atlantic Award for Literature in 1950. The other awards are not mentioned for him.
-
2. What does the word 'uniforms' stand for in the opening part of the poem?
- The school dress of children
- Clothes that are all of one colour
- Expensive clothes worn by rich people
- The outer marks that divide people into nations and armies
Show answer
Answer: D. Uniforms are what soldiers of different countries wear, so they mark who is on which side. The poet says that beneath them the same kind of body breathes, so they stand for outer, man-made divisions.
-
3. Why does the poet mention sun, air and water?
- They are shared by all people and belong to no single nation.
- They are found only in some countries.
- They are the reasons for wars.
- They are things the poet is afraid of.
Show answer
Answer: A. Every person everywhere knows and depends on sun, air and water. Since these common gifts of nature belong to everyone, they show that all people share one life.
-
4. How many lines does the poem have, and how do they fall?
- Fourteen lines in one block
- Sixteen lines in four rhyming stanzas
- Twenty lines in four parts of five lines each
- Twenty-four lines in six parts
Show answer
Answer: C. The poem has twenty lines, which divide naturally into four parts of five lines each, with no regular rhyme scheme.
-
5. Which word keeps returning in the poem to fix its message in the reader's mind?
- Brother
- Remember
- Foreign
- Love
Show answer
Answer: B. The poet repeats 'Remember' at the start of several sentences, like a teacher's reminder, so that the reader keeps the message in mind. 'Foreign' appears only in the first and last lines.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.