• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

No Men are Foreign: poetic devices, tone and form

Identify and explain the poem's devices - repetition, chiasmus, metaphor, personification, symbol and imagery - and describe its free verse form and its gentle but urgent tone.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Name and explain the main poetic devices in the poem.
  • Describe the form of the poem: free verse, no regular rhyme.
  • Describe the tone and the voice of the speaker.
  • Answer device questions in the 'name it, quote or point to it, explain its effect' pattern.

A board answer on a poem often asks you to pick out a figure of speech and say what it does. In this poem the devices are not decoration; each one helps the argument that all people are one. This lesson collects them in one place.

The main devices

Devices in No Men are Foreign (described in our own words).
DeviceWhere in the poemEffect
Repetition'Remember' begins several sentencesDrives the message home like a repeated reminder.
Chiasmus (crossing of words)First and last lines, with 'strange' and 'foreign' swappedCloses the poem in a circle; both labels are shown to be false.
MetaphorWar as a long winter; battle as hells of fire and dustMakes the suffering of war vivid and frightening.
PersonificationThe air is given innocenceThe air seems a blameless victim of war.
Symbol / synecdocheUniforms, hands, eyesA part or a sign stands for the whole person or group.
ImagerySun, air, water, harvests, fire, dustPictures from nature and war that we can see and feel.
ContrastPeaceful harvests against war's starvationShows clearly what peace gives and war takes away.

Repetition and the speaker's voice

The repeated 'Remember' tells us something about the speaker. He does not shout or give orders; he reminds. 'Remember' suggests that we already know these truths deep down but have forgotten them, perhaps because we have been taught to hate. Notice also the words 'we', 'our' and 'ours'. The speaker includes himself with the reader. He does not say 'you must love foreigners'; he says 'let us remember'. This makes the poem feel like a friend's appeal rather than a lecture.

Symbols: uniforms, hands and eyes

Kirkup uses small, concrete things to stand for big ideas. Uniforms stand for all the outer divisions of nation and army. Hands stand for work, and for the working life of ordinary people. Eyes stand for the simple life of waking and sleeping, and perhaps for seeing one another truly. When a part, like 'hands', stands for the whole person, the device is called synecdoche; you may simply call these symbols in your answer if your teacher prefers.

Form and tone

The poem is written in free verse: the lines are of different lengths and there is no regular rhyme scheme. Many sentences run on from one line into the next (this is called enjambment), so the poem sounds like a serious person thinking aloud. The tone is calm and gentle in the first three parts, where the poet lists what we share, and becomes more urgent and stern in the last part, where he speaks of hatred, weapons and hells of fire. The ending returns to calm, with the opening line restated.

How the tone changes

  1. Calm reminder Parts 1-3 list what all people share.
  2. Stern warning Part 4 speaks of hatred, arms and the defiled earth.
  3. Calm close The first line returns, with two words swapped.

Worked example 1: a device answer

Question: Name the figure of speech in the phrase about hells of fire and dust, and explain it. Working: the battlefield is called 'hells' directly, without 'like' or 'as', so it is a metaphor. What quality is shared? Hell is a place of fire and endless suffering. Answer: it is a metaphor; the poet compares the burning, smoking battlefields of war to hell to show how terrible the suffering is, and that human beings create these hells themselves.

Worked example 2: spotting devices in a new line

Practise on a line written for this lesson (not from the poem): 'The tired river carried our quarrels to the sea.' Working: a river cannot feel tired, so a human feeling is given to a thing, which is personification. Quarrels cannot be carried by water, so this is also a metaphor for letting quarrels go. Answer: personification (the tired river) and metaphor (quarrels carried away).

Device answer pattern: name the device, point to where it is, and explain the effect it has on the meaning.

Key takeaways: the poem uses repetition ('Remember'), chiasmus in its first and last lines, metaphors of winter and hell, personification of the air, and symbols such as uniforms, hands and eyes. It is free verse with no regular rhyme. The tone moves from gentle reminder to stern warning and back.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is the effect of repeating the word 'Remember' in the poem?

    1. It reminds the reader again and again of truths we tend to forget.
    2. It makes the poem rhyme.
    3. It shows that the poet has a poor memory.
    4. It tells the story of a soldier.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 'Remember' suggests we already know these truths but have forgotten them. Repeating it fixes the message in the reader's mind like a gentle reminder.

  2. 2. The poem is written in free verse. What does this mean?

    1. It was given away free of cost.
    2. It has fourteen lines and a fixed rhyme scheme.
    3. It has lines of different lengths and no regular rhyme scheme.
    4. Every line begins with the same word.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Free verse does not follow a fixed rhyme or line length. Kirkup's lines vary and do not rhyme regularly, so the poem sounds like serious speech.

  3. 3. In the poem, the air is said to have innocence. Which device is this?

    1. Simile
    2. Personification
    3. Alliteration
    4. Rhyme
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Innocence is a human quality. Giving it to the air, which is a thing, is personification. There is no 'like' or 'as', so it is not a simile.

  4. 4. How does the tone of the poem change in its last part?

    1. It becomes funny and playful.
    2. It becomes sad and hopeless.
    3. It stays exactly the same throughout.
    4. It becomes more urgent and stern as the poet warns against hatred and war.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The first three parts calmly list what people share. The last part speaks of being told to hate, taking up arms and hells of fire, so the tone becomes urgent and stern before the calm closing line.

  5. 5. Which word does the poet use as a symbol of the outer divisions between nations?

    1. Water
    2. Harvests
    3. Uniforms
    4. Eyes
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Uniforms mark soldiers of different nations and sides. The poet says a single body breathes beneath them all, so uniforms stand for man-made outer divisions.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery