• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

No Men are Foreign: parts 2 and 3 - one life, one heart

Explain the middle of the poem in your own words: how peace feeds and war starves every people alike, how hands and eyes show our likeness, and how love can win any heart.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain lines 5-12 of the poem in your own words.
  • Show how peace and war affect people of every country in the same way.
  • Explain what the poet means by reading the lines on people's hands.
  • Explain the idea that strength can be won by love.

In lesson 1 we saw that all people share the same body, the same earth and the same gifts of nature. In the middle of the poem Kirkup moves from nature to daily life. He looks at what feeds us, what we do with our hands, how we sleep and wake, and what wins us over. Each picture is a small piece of evidence in his argument that no one is foreign.

Peaceful harvests and war's long winter

The poet says that the people of other lands, like us, are fed by peaceful harvests and starved by war. In peace, farmers sow and reap, and there is food for everyone. In war, fields are burnt or left unsown, roads are cut, and people go hungry. The poet calls war a 'long winter': winter is the season when nothing grows, when it is cold and dark, and when food runs short. So war is pictured as a season of death and hunger that falls on every country in the same way. The phrase war's long winter is a metaphor: it compares war to winter without using 'like' or 'as'.

Peace and war in the poem

  • Peace
    • Fields are sown and harvested
    • People are fed
    • Life grows, like spring and summer
  • War
    • Crops are destroyed or not sown
    • People starve
    • Life freezes, like a long winter
Both sides of the comparison happen to every people alike.

Their hands are ours

Next the poet looks at hands. He says the hands of other people are just like ours, and in the lines on their palms we can read work that is no different from our own. Hands that are used for hard work become rough and marked. A farmer in another country, a mason, a weaver or a fisherman has the same kind of tired, lined hands as workers here. So the hands are evidence: everyone labours to live, and labour is the same everywhere. Notice that the poet does not say the hands are 'like' ours; he says they are ours, which makes the bond even closer.

Eyes that wake or sleep

The third part begins with another 'Remember'. Other people have eyes like ours that open in the morning and close at night. This is the simplest possible fact about a human being, and that is the point: in the basic rhythm of life, waking and sleeping, all people are the same. Their dreams, tiredness and hopes are human, not 'foreign'.

Strength that can be won by love

The poet then says that other people have strength that can be won by love. This is an important idea. Strength usually suggests armies and weapons, which nations fear in each other. Kirkup turns the idea round: the strength of other peoples is not something to fear or defeat by force; it can be gained as friendship, by love. A friend's strength is on your side. Finally, he says that in every land there is a common life that everyone can recognise and understand: families, work, meals, festivals, grief and joy. Wherever we travel, we can understand how people live, because we live the same way.

Parts 2 and 3: the evidence and what it shows.
Picture in the poemWhat it shows
Fed by peaceful harvestsEveryone needs food, and peace brings it.
Starved by war's long winterWar brings hunger to every people alike.
Lines on the handsEveryone works hard in the same way.
Eyes that wake or sleepEveryone shares the daily rhythm of life.
Strength won by loveOthers can become friends, not enemies.
Common life in every landHuman life is understandable everywhere.

Worked example 1: why winter?

Question: Why does the poet compare war to a long winter? Working: think of what winter does to plants and food. In a hard winter nothing grows, stores run out, and people suffer from cold and hunger. War does the same: it stops farming and brings starvation. The word 'long' adds that war's suffering seems endless. Answer: like winter, war stops all growth and brings hunger and death, and its suffering seems to last forever.

Worked example 2: reading the hands

Question: What does the poet mean by reading labour in the lines of people's hands? Working: lines and marks on hands come from years of work. If the hands of people in other countries show the same marks, their work must be like ours. Answer: the hands of workers everywhere show the same hard work, so all working people share the same life and are equals.

Parts 2 and 3: same food, same hunger, same work, same sleep, same heart. Strength is to be won by love, not beaten by force.

Key takeaways: the middle of the poem moves from nature to daily life. Peace feeds and war starves everyone alike; workers' hands show the same labour; all people wake and sleep; and the strength of others can be won by love. In every land there is a common life that all can understand.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the poem, what feeds the people of every land?

    1. Trade with rich countries
    2. Help from their armies
    3. Peaceful harvests
    4. Gifts from foreigners
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The poet says people everywhere are fed by peaceful harvests. Peace lets farmers grow food, while war brings starvation.

  2. 2. What figure of speech is 'war's long winter'?

    1. Metaphor
    2. Simile
    3. Alliteration
    4. Rhyme
    Show answer

    Answer: A. War is compared to winter directly, without 'like' or 'as', so it is a metaphor. A simile would need 'like' or 'as'.

  3. 3. What do the lines on people's hands show, according to the poet?

    1. Their future and their luck
    2. That they are richer than us
    3. That they do no work
    4. That their labour is no different from ours
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The poet says that in the lines of their hands we read a labour like our own. Hard work marks hands in the same way everywhere, so the hands prove that all workers are alike.

  4. 4. What does the poet suggest about the strength of other peoples?

    1. It must be destroyed in war.
    2. It can be won by love.
    3. It is greater than ours, so we should fear it.
    4. It does not exist.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The poet says others have strength that can be won by love. Instead of fearing their strength or fighting it, we can gain it as friendship.

  5. 5. Why does the poet mention eyes that wake or sleep?

    1. To show that all people share the same basic rhythm of daily life
    2. To show that foreigners sleep more than we do
    3. To describe soldiers on guard at night
    4. To say that people are blind to the truth
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Waking and sleeping is the simplest fact of every human life. By pointing to it, the poet shows that people everywhere share the same daily rhythm, so they are not strange to us.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery