- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Wishes Come True: a naughty son, a regretful father and two wishes
Retell the opening of Tagore's story in your own words: the meanings of the two names, Sushil's pretend tummy-ache on a Saturday, his father's lesson, and the two wishes the Lady of Wishes grants.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Say who wrote the story and explain the joke in the two names.
- Retell the events of the Saturday in order.
- State the wishes of the son and the father, and why each made his wish.
- Answer the book's first three comprehension questions.
Wishes Come True is the second lesson of the English Literature Book for Class IX of the Punjab School Education Board (PSEB). It is by Rabindranath Tagore, the great Bengali poet and storyteller. It is a funny story with a fairy-tale twist: a boy wants to be grown up, his father wants to be a boy again, and a magical lady decides to give them what they ask for. The fun lies in watching both of them discover that the life they envied is not what they imagined.
Names that do not fit
The father is Subalchandra (Subal Babu) and the son is Sushilchandra (Sushil). The story begins with a joke about names. 'Subal' means strong, but the father is rather frail and suffers from rheumatism, a painful disease of the joints. 'Sushil' means well-behaved, but the son is anything but. So the story warns us from the first lines that a name does not always match the person.
The pranks and the Saturday
Sushil was always annoying the neighbours with his pranks, tricks played as jokes. His father often ran after him to punish him, but the father's joints were stiff while the boy ran like a deer, so the blows seldom landed. One Saturday, when school closed early at two, Sushil did not want to go at all. He had two reasons: there was a Geography test, and there was to be a fireworks show at the Boses' house in the evening, for which preparations would go on all day. He wanted to spend the whole day there.
So when it was time for school he went back to bed and told his father he had a tummy-ache. Subal saw at once that the boy was making it up and decided to teach him a lesson. He said that a boy with a tummy-ache must stay at home all day: his friend Hari would go to the fireworks alone, there would be no toffees, and he would mix some bitter medicine. He locked Sushil in and went to prepare it. Sushil was in a fix: he loved toffees, hated bitter medicine and longed to go to the Boses'. When his father returned with a huge bowl of medicine, Sushil jumped up, said his tummy was fine and offered to go to school. Too late: his father made him swallow the medicine, locked the door again and left.
Two wishes
Sushil cried all day and wished he were as old as his father, so that he could do as he pleased and no one could lock him up. Outside, his father sat thinking that his own parents had pampered him, so he had never studied properly; if only he could have his childhood back, he would study hard and not waste a moment. The Lady of Wishes happened to pass by and heard both of them. Curious to see what would happen, she decided to grant their wishes for a while. She told the father he would be his son's age the next day, and the son that he would be as old as his father. Both were delighted.
Two wishes
-
Sushil (the son)
- Wishes to be as old as his father
- Reason: to do as he likes
- No one could lock him up or punish him
-
Subal (the father)
- Wishes to be a boy again
- Reason: he was pampered and did not study
- This time he would study properly
Worked example 1: why were the neighbours angry?
Question: Why did Sushilchandra's neighbours get angry with him? Working: find what Sushil did to the neighbours. Answer: Sushil was a naughty boy who was always annoying the neighbours with his pranks, so they were often angry with him, and his father would chase him to punish him.
Worked example 2: why did the Lady grant both wishes?
Question: Why did the Lady of Wishes grant wishes to both the father and the son? Working: what did she hear, and what did she want to find out? Answer: passing the house, she heard the son wish to be as old as his father and the father wish to be young again. She decided to make both wishes come true for some time just to see what would happen, perhaps to show them the truth about their wishes.
The story's starting point: each person thinks the other's life is easier. The rest of the story tests that belief.
Key takeaways: in Tagore's story the frail Subal and the naughty Sushil do not fit their names. Sushil fakes a tummy-ache to skip school, and his father cleverly punishes him. The son wishes to be old and free; the father wishes to be young and studious. The Lady of Wishes grants both wishes.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why do the names Subal and Sushil not suit the father and son?
- Subal means strong but he is frail; Sushil means well-behaved but he is naughty.
- Both names mean clever, but they are foolish.
- The names are from another language.
- They have swapped names.
Show answer
Answer: A. The story explains that 'Subal' means strong, yet the father is frail, and 'Sushil' means well-behaved, yet the son is full of pranks.
-
2. Which were Sushil's two reasons for not wanting to go to school that Saturday?
- He was ill and it was raining.
- A Geography test, and a fireworks show at the Boses' house.
- His friend Hari was ill and his books were lost.
- The school was closed and he was tired.
Show answer
Answer: B. There was a Geography test that day, and preparations for evening fireworks at the Boses', where Sushil wanted to spend the whole day.
-
3. How did Subal know his son's tummy-ache was false?
- The doctor told him.
- Sushil confessed at once.
- He could easily see the boy was making it up.
- Hari told him.
Show answer
Answer: C. The story says Subal could easily see that the boy was making it up, so he decided to teach him a lesson.
-
4. Why was Sushil 'in a fix'?
- He had broken a window.
- He had lost his toffees in the market.
- He could not find his school bag.
- He loved toffees, hated the bitter medicine and wanted to go to the Boses', but his own lie stood in the way.
Show answer
Answer: D. His pretend illness meant no toffees, bitter medicine and no fireworks. To be 'in a fix' is to be in a difficult situation of one's own making.
-
5. Why did Subal wish to have his childhood back?
- He had been pampered as a child and had not studied properly.
- He wanted to play kabaddi.
- He wanted to see the fireworks.
- He was tired of his job.
Show answer
Answer: A. Subal thought his parents had pampered him, so he never got a proper education. With his childhood back, he planned to study hard.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.