• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Wishes Come True: the boy-father, the old son and the return

Retell how young Subal behaves at school and at home, how old Sushil suffers in body and mind, why both pray to change back, and the funny last lines of the story.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain what happened to Subalchandra after his wish was granted.
  • Explain why young Subal was kept busy in the evenings.
  • Describe old Sushil's troubles with his body.
  • Retell the return to normal and explain the joke in the ending.

Subal had promised himself that, given a second childhood, he would shut himself in his room and study all day. Now he has that chance. Tagore shows, with gentle humour, how quickly the promise is forgotten.

Subal the schoolboy

Once he was a boy again, Subal did not like going to school any more than Sushil had. In the morning his son asked whether he was going to school, and Subal scratched his head, lowered his eyes and said he had a tummy-ache, the very excuse Sushil had used. Sushil grew angry and said he knew all about such tummy-aches, having had plenty himself. From then on he sent his little father to school by force.

After school young Subal wanted to run about and play, but old Sushil wanted to put on his glasses and read aloud from the Ramayana in a sing-song voice. The boy's noisy games disturbed him, so he made Subal sit with his slate and do sums, sums so long that one took him a whole hour. In the evenings a group of old men gathered in Sushil's room to play chess; to keep the boy quiet then, Sushil hired a tutor who kept Subal busy until ten at night. Now the father was being treated exactly as he had once treated his son.

Sushil's aches and pains

Old Sushil was no happier. Nothing he had enjoyed as a child agreed with him any longer, that is, it made him feel ill. He took a dip in the pond as before, and his joints grew stiff and swollen; he got rheumatism that took six months to cure. After that he bathed only every other day, in warm water, and would not let Subal bathe in the pond either. If he jumped out of bed as he used to, all his bones ached. When he put a paan in his mouth he found he had no teeth to chew it, and when he picked up a comb he remembered he had no hair to comb.

Subal forgets he is a boy

Sometimes Subal forgot how young he now was. Thinking himself as old as before, he would join the old men playing cards or dice and start talking like a grown-up. They would box his ears and send him off to play.

Enough of wishes

At last both began to pray. Subal prayed to be as old as his son and free to do what he liked. Sushil prayed to be young again so he could play as much as he wanted; he could no longer control his father, who had become very naughty and gave him constant worry. The Lady of Wishes came again and asked whether they had had enough. Both bowed low and begged to be turned back. She agreed, and the next morning Subal was the same old man and Sushil the same little boy. Both thought they had been dreaming.

The story ends with a smile. Subal asked his son whether he was going to start learning his grammar. Sushil scratched his head and said he had lost his book. Nothing has changed: the boy is still the boy, making excuses, and the father is still the father, telling him to study.

The story goes round in a circle

  1. Envy Each wishes for the other's life.
  2. Wish granted Father becomes a boy, son an old man.
  3. Trouble Each finds the new life hard and unpleasant.
  4. Prayer Both beg to return to what they were.
  5. Back again The boy makes excuses; the father says study.

Then back to step 1: Envy

Everyone ends where they started, a little wiser for a dream.

Worked example 1: what happened to Subalchandra?

Question: What happened to Subalchandra after his wish was granted? Working: describe his body, then how he behaved and was treated. Answer: Subal became a small boy with all his teeth and no beard. Instead of studying as he had planned, he pretended to have a tummy-ache to avoid school. His son sent him to school by force, made him do long sums and hired a tutor to keep him busy till ten at night, and the old men boxed his ears when he tried to talk like a grown-up.

Worked example 2: why was the boy kept busy in the evenings?

Question: Why was the boy kept busy in the evening? Working: the book's question names Sushil, but in the story it is young Subal, the father turned boy, who is kept busy. Answer: in the evenings old Sushil's friends came to play chess in his room, and young Subal's noisy games disturbed them, so Sushil hired a tutor who kept Subal busy with lessons until ten at night.

The ending repeats the beginning: the father says study, the son finds an excuse. The circle shows that each age is right for its own time.

Key takeaways: young Subal fakes tummy-aches just as his son did, and is made to study by force. Old Sushil suffers rheumatism, aching bones, no teeth and no hair. Both pray to change back, the Lady of Wishes restores them, and the last lines show them exactly as they began.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What excuse did young Subal use to avoid going to school?

    1. He had lost his book.
    2. It was a holiday.
    3. His teacher was ill.
    4. He had a tummy-ache.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Subal scratched his head, lowered his eyes and said he had a tummy-ache, the same excuse Sushil had used on that Saturday.

  2. 2. What did old Sushil get after taking a dip in the pond?

    1. Rheumatism that took six months to cure
    2. A small cold that passed in a day
    3. A bad cut on his foot
    4. Nothing; he enjoyed it
    Show answer

    Answer: A. His joints grew stiff and swollen and he got rheumatism that took six months to cure, so he began bathing only every other day in warm water.

  3. 3. Why did the old men box young Subal's ears?

    1. He stole their cards.
    2. He came to their gatherings and talked like a grown-up.
    3. He broke their chessboard.
    4. He refused to fetch water.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Forgetting he was now a boy, Subal joined the old men's card and dice games and spoke like an adult, so they boxed his ears and told him to run away and play.

  4. 4. Why did Sushil pray to become young again?

    1. He wanted to marry.
    2. He wanted to go to the fireworks.
    3. He wanted to play again, and could not control his naughty father.
    4. The Lady of Wishes ordered him to.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Sushil prayed to be young so he might play as much as he liked, saying he could no longer control his father, who had become very naughty.

  5. 5. What is the joke in the last lines of the story?

    1. The father has become a teacher.
    2. Sushil has become a good student.
    3. The Lady of Wishes appears once more.
    4. Sushil at once makes an excuse, saying he has lost his book, so nothing has changed.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. When his father asks him to start his grammar, Sushil says he has lost his book. The boy is back to his old excuses, so the story ends where it began.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery