- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Wishes Come True: characters, humour, themes and strict parents
Describe Subal and Sushil with evidence, explain the irony and humour in Tagore's story, state its themes, and prepare the book's discussion: is it necessary to be strict with children?
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the father and the son with evidence from the story.
- Explain the irony and the humour of the role reversal.
- State the main themes and message.
- Answer whether Subal was happy with the change, and prepare the discussion topic.
Tagore's story is short and light, but it makes a serious point about growing up. This lesson looks at how the characters reveal that point, and at the gentle comedy that carries it.
The characters
| Character | Quality | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Sushil | Naughty and fun-loving | He annoys the neighbours with pranks and fakes illness to skip a test. |
| Sushil | Impatient to grow up | He wishes to be old so that no one can lock him up. |
| Sushil as an old man | Responsible, even strict | He sends his little father to school by force and hires a tutor. |
| Subal | Clever as a father | He sees through the fake tummy-ache and punishes it with the boy's own lie. |
| Subal | Full of regret | He blames his pampered childhood for his lack of education. |
| Subal as a boy | Just as playful as his son | He fakes a tummy-ache and wants to run about after school. |
Irony and humour
Irony is a gap between what we expect and what happens. Subal promised to study all day if he were a boy, yet as a boy he dodges school with his son's own excuse. Sushil dreamt of freedom as a grown-up, yet as a grown-up he spends his days worrying, aching and controlling a naughty child. Each becomes the very person he complained about. The humour comes from these reversals and from comic pictures: an old man falling out of an amra tree, a boy lecturing old men until they box his ears, a bald man picking up a comb. Tagore laughs with his characters, not at them.
What each expected and what happened
-
Sushil
- Expected: freedom, play, sweets
- Got: aches, worry and a naughty child to manage
- Became: as strict as his father
-
Subal
- Expected: to study hard all day
- Got: school by force, long sums, a tutor
- Became: as naughty as his son
Themes and message
- Every age has its place: childhood is for play and learning, old age for rest and wisdom; each age has its own pleasures and duties.
- The grass is greener on the other side: we envy others' lives, but they have troubles we do not see.
- Be careful what you wish for: getting a wish can bring problems we never imagined.
- Understanding between generations: each learns what the other goes through; a child learns why parents are strict, and a parent remembers how hard it is to be a child.
Worked example 1: was Subal happy with the change?
Question: Was Subalchandra happy with the change? Why? Working: compare what he hoped for with what he got. Answer: no. He had hoped to use his childhood to study, but as a boy he disliked school, was forced to attend, given long sums and kept busy by a tutor till late, and the old men boxed his ears when he spoke like an adult. Unhappy, he prayed to be old and free again.
Discussion: is it not necessary to be strict with children?
The book asks you to discuss this. Look at both sides. For strictness: children may not yet see the value of study, as Sushil does not, and even Subal-as-a-boy needs to be pushed; Subal blames his own pampered childhood for his poor education. For gentleness: too much strictness can make a child unhappy or rebellious; children also need play, and the story shows that playing is natural to their age. A balanced view is that firm rules with love and understanding work best.
Worked example 2: planning the discussion
Question: Plan a short speech on whether children need strictness. Working: view, two reasons, evidence from the story, a balance, a conclusion. Answer plan: (1) view: some strictness is needed, with love; (2) reason: children do not always see the long-term value of study; story: Subal regrets being pampered; (3) reason: rules build good habits; story: even boy-Subal studies only when made to; (4) balance: children need play too, as the story's humour shows; (5) conclusion: be firm about duties, gentle in manner.
A balanced discussion gives both sides with evidence, then a reasoned view of your own.
Key takeaways: each character becomes what he once complained about, which is the irony at the heart of the story. Its themes are that every age has its place, that others' lives have hidden troubles, and that the generations should understand each other. On strictness, give both sides and argue for balance.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is ironic about Subal's behaviour as a boy?
- He studies harder than ever.
- He becomes a famous scholar.
- He promised to study all day, but fakes a tummy-ache to avoid school.
- He refuses to eat toffees.
Show answer
Answer: C. Subal had said he would study hard if he were young again. As a boy he uses his son's tummy-ache trick to escape school, the opposite of what we expect.
-
2. Which theme does the story mainly bring out?
- Every age has its own place, pleasures and duties.
- Money brings happiness.
- Children should never play.
- Old people are always unhappy.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both characters find the other's age unsuitable for them and want to return to their own. The story shows that each age has its own pleasures and duties.
-
3. How does old Sushil treat his 'child-father'?
- He lets him do whatever he likes.
- He gives him all the toffees.
- He ignores him completely.
- He makes him go to school, do long sums and study with a tutor.
Show answer
Answer: D. Old Sushil sends Subal to school by force, gives him long sums and hires a tutor till ten at night, as strictly as a father would.
-
4. Which saying fits the story best?
- Practice makes perfect.
- The grass is always greener on the other side.
- Early to bed, early to rise.
- A stitch in time saves nine.
Show answer
Answer: B. Each envied the other's life, but on trying it found it full of troubles. That is the meaning of 'the grass is greener on the other side'.
-
5. Which is the most balanced view on the book's discussion topic?
- Children should be firmly guided in their duties, but with love and time to play.
- Children should never be told what to do.
- Children should be punished for every mistake.
- Children should study all day and never play.
Show answer
Answer: A. The story supports both sides: Subal regrets being pampered, but play is natural to children. A balanced view combines firm guidance with love and play.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.