- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Wishes Come True: an old man's body for a boy's mind
Retell the morning of the change and Sushil's first day as an old man: why he no longer wants to climb, swim, eat toffees or play kabaddi, and what this shows.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the changes in the father and the son on the morning after the wish.
- Retell what happens when old Sushil tries the things he once dreamt of.
- Explain why his old pleasures no longer please him.
- Answer the book's question on the changes in Sushil.
The wishes come true overnight, and Tagore has great fun describing how strange it is. The real joke, though, is not in the changed bodies but in the changed minds: with an old body, Sushil begins to feel and think like an old man.
The morning of the change
Old Subal usually slept badly and dozed off only towards morning. But that day he leapt out of bed at the crack of dawn. He found that he had become very small: all his teeth had come back, his beard and moustache had gone, and his clothes were far too big for him. Sushil, on the other hand, could not get up at all. When his father's shouts finally woke him, he found that he had grown so much in the night that his clothes had burst at the seams. His face was covered with grey stubble and he had gone bald. He yawned again and again and did not feel like getting up.
| What changed | Subal (now a boy) | Sushil (now an old man) |
|---|---|---|
| Waking | Leaps up at dawn, full of energy | Cannot get up; yawns again and again |
| Body | Small, all his teeth back, no beard or moustache | Huge, bald, grey stubble |
| Clothes | Far too big | Burst at the seams |
Dreams that do not come true
Sushil had always imagined that once he was grown up and free he would climb trees, dive into the pool, eat green mangoes, raid birds' nests, roam about all day and eat whatever he liked whenever he liked. But that morning he did not want to climb a tree or swim. He was afraid he would catch cold and get a fever. He spread a mat and sat quietly, thinking.
Then he felt he should not give up games so suddenly; he should at least try. He tried to climb an amra tree nearby, but the thin branch he pulled on broke under his weight and he fell to the ground. Passers-by laughed to see an old man playing childish pranks. Embarrassed, he went back to his mat on the porch.
Next he sent the servant to buy a whole rupee's worth of toffees. As a boy he had dreamt of stuffing his pockets with sweets if he ever had money. Now he had a heap of them, but after one piece he found that an old man does not care for children's sweets. He thought of giving them to his 'child-father', but decided they would make the boy sick, just as a real father would.
His kabaddi friends came as usual, saw the old man and ran off. Sushil had always thought he would play kabaddi all day if he were free; now the very sight of the boys irritated him, and he grumbled that they came to bother him when he was sitting in peace.
Old Sushil's first day
- No climbing or swimming He fears a cold and fever.
- The amra tree The branch breaks; passers-by laugh.
- Toffees A rupee's worth, but he no longer likes them.
- Kabaddi friends They run away, and they irritate him.
Worked example 1: what changes took place in Sushil?
Question: What changes took place in Sushil? Working: list the changes in his body, then in his likes and feelings. Answer: overnight Sushil grew into an old man; his clothes burst, he became bald and his face was covered with grey stubble. His mind changed too: he no longer wanted to climb trees or swim for fear of illness, toffees no longer tasted good to him, and his old playmates only irritated him.
Worked example 2: why did the toffees not please him?
Question: Why did Sushil not enjoy the toffees he had always wanted? Working: think about what had changed: not the toffees, but Sushil. Answer: he was now an old man, and an old man does not care for children's sweets. His wish had changed his body and tastes, so the pleasure he had dreamt of was no longer a pleasure.
Each age has its own pleasures: what delights a child may mean nothing to an old person.
Key takeaways: Subal wakes up a lively boy and Sushil a bald, tired old man. Sushil's dreams of freedom fall flat: he fears illness, falls from the amra tree, finds toffees tasteless and is irritated by his friends. With an old body he has an old man's tastes.
Check your understanding
-
1. What happened to Sushil's clothes when he woke up as an old man?
- They had turned grey.
- They were too big for him.
- They had burst at the seams because he had grown so much.
- They had disappeared.
Show answer
Answer: C. He had grown so much overnight that his clothes burst their seams. It was Subal's clothes that became too big.
-
2. Why did old Sushil not want to swim?
- The pool was dry.
- He was afraid he would catch cold and have fever.
- His father had forbidden it.
- He had forgotten how to swim.
Show answer
Answer: B. The story says he thought he would catch cold and have fever, a typical worry of an old man.
-
3. What happened when Sushil tried to climb the amra tree?
- He reached the top easily.
- A snake frightened him.
- His father pulled him down.
- The thin branch broke under his weight and passers-by laughed.
Show answer
Answer: D. The branch broke and he fell. People laughed to see an old man playing childish pranks.
-
4. Why did Sushil decide not to give the toffees to his 'child-father'?
- He thought they would make the boy sick.
- He wanted to eat them all himself.
- His father did not like toffees.
- The servant had eaten them.
Show answer
Answer: A. He thought of giving them to the boy but decided they would make him sick, thinking just as a parent would.
-
5. How did Sushil feel when his kabaddi friends came?
- Overjoyed
- Irritated; he felt they came to bother him
- Sad that he could not join
- Afraid of them
Show answer
Answer: B. The sight of the boys only irritated him. He thought he was sitting in peace and they had come to bother him, which is how an old man might feel.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.