- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Answering questions and discussing The Last Leaf
Write clear answers to the comprehension questions on the story, and argue the two discussion topics: 'Doctor cures but God saves' and whether Behrman was right to sacrifice his life.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Answer comprehension questions completely, in your own words.
- Discuss the saying 'Doctor cures but God saves' with reasons.
- Give a reasoned opinion on Behrman's sacrifice.
- Plan a short discussion paragraph.
The book's exercises ask nine comprehension questions about the story and two discussion questions. This lesson models both kinds of answer. The model answers are written for this lesson; write your own in your own words.
Comprehension answers
Worked example 1: model answers
- Who were Sue and Johnsy, and what happened to Johnsy? Working: two parts, identity and event. Answer: They were two young artists who shared a small third-floor flat. In November Johnsy fell seriously ill with pneumonia and lost the will to live.
- Why did Johnsy look at the ivy leaves carefully? Working: what was she waiting for? Answer: She was counting them as they fell, because she believed she would die when the last one fell.
- How was Johnsy saved? Working: what changed her mind? Answer: The last leaf seemed to survive two storms, which gave her hope and the will to live; in fact Behrman had painted it on the wall. With hope, she began eating and recovered.
- What happened to Behrman and why? Answer: He died of pneumonia, which he caught by working outside in the cold rain at night to paint the leaf.
Discussion 1: 'Doctor cures but God saves'
The saying means that a doctor can treat an illness, but whether a patient lives depends on something beyond medicine, which many people call God or fate. Use the story as evidence on both sides.
Weighing the saying
-
Supports the saying
- The doctor's daily visits did not help at first
- Something beyond medicine changed Johnsy
- The doctor himself said medicine fails without the will to live
- Johnsy calls wanting to die a sin, a moral and spiritual idea
-
Adds another view
- The 'miracle' was made by a human being, Behrman
- Hope, a state of mind, did the saving
- Love and friendship (Sue) kept Johnsy going
- The doctor still treated her body
Model conclusion: 'The story agrees that medicine alone is not enough: Johnsy's cure began only when she found hope. But in this story, that hope came from human love: Sue's care and Behrman's sacrifice. So we may say: the doctor treats the body, but hope saves the patient, and hope can be given by people who care.'
Discussion 2: Was Behrman right to sacrifice his life?
| He was right | Questions we might ask |
|---|---|
| He saved a young life that was being lost to despair. | He was old and ill-protected; did he know the risk was so high? |
| He finally created his masterpiece, fulfilling his dream. | Could he have found a safer way, such as painting the leaf on a board indoors? |
| His act shows the highest form of love: giving without asking. | His death caused Sue and Johnsy new grief. |
| He turned a superstition into real hope. | Is risking one life to save another always wise? |
Worked example 2: a model opinion paragraph
'I think Behrman was right, though his death is sad. Johnsy was dying of despair, and nothing anyone said could change her mind. Behrman understood that only something she could see would give her hope, and he gave it at the cost of his own life. He probably did not plan to die, but he accepted the danger for her sake. By doing so he saved a young artist and created the masterpiece he had dreamed of all his life. A life given to save another is never wasted.' Working: the paragraph states an opinion, admits the sadness, gives two or three reasons from the story, and ends with a strong closing line.
Opinion paragraph: state your view, give reasons from the story, admit the other side, end with a strong line.
Common mistakes: saying Johnsy knew the leaf was painted (she learns it only at the end); saying Behrman died of a fall (he died of pneumonia); and answering a discussion with only 'yes' or 'no'. Key takeaways: answer every part of a question in a full sentence, and in a discussion give reasons on both sides before reaching your view.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which is the best answer to 'Why did Sue call Behrman to her room?'
- Because.
- To paint a leaf.
- She first wanted him to model for her painting of an old miner, and after hearing about Johnsy he came up to see her.
- He was a doctor.
Show answer
Answer: C. Sue went to fetch him as a model; when she shared her worry, he came up to see Johnsy. That answer is complete and accurate; the leaf was his own secret idea.
-
2. What does the saying 'Doctor cures but God saves' mean?
- Doctors are not needed
- Doctors treat illness, but survival depends on something beyond medicine
- God works in hospitals
- Only prayer cures illness
Show answer
Answer: B. It means medicine treats the disease, but whether a patient lives depends on more than medicine. It does not say doctors are useless.
-
3. Which point from the story best supports the idea that hope helps healing?
- Sue painted an old miner
- Behrman lived on the ground floor
- The ivy grew on a brick wall
- Johnsy recovered once she decided she wanted to live
Show answer
Answer: D. Her medicine did not change, but her recovery began when she found hope. That shows hope's role in healing.
-
4. Which is a fair point AGAINST Behrman's choice?
- His death brought fresh grief to Sue and Johnsy
- He saved Johnsy
- He painted a masterpiece
- He showed great love
Show answer
Answer: A. The new grief is a cost of his sacrifice. The other three are points in favour.
-
5. Which statement would be a MISTAKE in an answer?
- Behrman died of pneumonia.
- Johnsy knew all along that the leaf was painted.
- The doctor had little hope for Behrman.
- Sue gave Johnsy a mirror.
Show answer
Answer: B. Johnsy believed the leaf was real; Sue reveals the truth only at the end. The other statements are true.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.