- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Characters and themes in The Last Leaf
Describe Sue, Johnsy, Behrman and the doctor with evidence, and explain the story's themes: hope and the will to live, friendship, sacrifice and true art, plus the leaf as a symbol and the surprise ending.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Give qualities of each character with evidence.
- Explain the main themes of the story.
- Explain what the leaf stands for.
- Describe how the surprise ending works.
The Last Leaf is short, but every character has a clear role, and the ending changes how we see everything before it. This lesson gives you the material for character and theme questions.
The characters
| Character | Qualities | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Johnsy | Hopeless at first, then grateful and changed | She waits to die with the last leaf; later she admits she was wrong and asks for soup and a mirror. |
| Sue | Loving, patient, hard-working friend | She nurses Johnsy, tries to cheer her, and paints to earn money for both. |
| Behrman | Gruff on the outside, kind and self-sacrificing inside | He calls Johnsy's idea foolish, yet risks his life to paint the leaf in a storm. |
| The doctor | Wise and caring | He sees that Johnsy's mind is blocking her cure, and later says she now has the will to live. |
Themes
- Hope and the will to live: Johnsy's body begins to heal only when her mind wants to live. Hope is a kind of medicine.
- Friendship: Sue never gives up on Johnsy, even when Johnsy refuses to help herself.
- Sacrifice: Behrman gives his own life for a young woman who is not his relative, and never asks for thanks.
- The meaning of art: Behrman's greatest painting is not in a gallery; it is a leaf on a wall that saves a life. Art's true value can lie in what it does for people.
The leaf as a symbol
A symbol is an object that stands for an idea. For Johnsy, the real leaves stand for her failing life: each fall brings death closer. The painted leaf turns this symbol round. It stands for hope and endurance: something that holds on through the storm. Johnsy reads it as a lesson that she, too, can hold on.
The real leaves and the painted leaf
-
The real leaves
- Fall in the wind
- Count down Johnsy's days
- Stand for death and giving up
- Belong to nature
-
The painted leaf
- Never falls or flutters
- Gives Johnsy the will to live
- Stands for hope and courage
- Made by human love and skill
The surprise ending
O. Henry hides the truth until the last lines. Like Johnsy, the reader first believes the leaf is real. Only when Sue lists the ladder, lantern and paints, and points out that the leaf never moves, do we understand. A surprise ending works only when it is fair: the clues were there (Behrman's silence, the leaf surviving two storms), but we did not read them. The ending also brings irony: the man who called Johnsy foolish is the one who dies, and the night that seemed sure to kill the last leaf is the night it was 'born'.
Worked example 1: a character sketch of Behrman
Question: Write a short character sketch of Behrman. Working: pick contrasting qualities, add evidence, end with a judgement. Answer: Behrman is a sixty-year-old painter who has never achieved his dream of a masterpiece. He seems rough, calling Johnsy's fancy foolish, but he has a tender heart. Without a word to anyone, he climbs a ladder on a stormy night and paints a leaf on the wall so that Johnsy will not lose hope. The effort costs him his life. His painted leaf saves Johnsy and becomes the masterpiece he always wanted. He shows that true greatness lies in selfless love.
Worked example 2: identifying a theme
Question: Which theme does the doctor's second visit show? Working: on the first visits nothing improved; now he says Johnsy has the will to live and will recover. Her medicine has not changed; her mind has. Answer: the power of hope and the will to live in healing.
The real leaves meant giving up; the painted leaf meant holding on.
Key takeaways: Johnsy changes from hopeless to hopeful; Sue is a devoted friend; Behrman is gruff but selfless; the doctor understands the mind's role in healing. The themes are hope, friendship, sacrifice and the purpose of art, and the surprise ending reveals the painted leaf as Behrman's masterpiece.
Check your understanding
-
1. What does the painted leaf stand for?
- Death and decay
- The coming of spring
- Hope and holding on through hardship
- Behrman's wealth
Show answer
Answer: C. It survives storms and gives Johnsy the will to live, so it stands for hope and endurance.
-
2. Which quality of Behrman is shown by his painting the leaf in the storm?
- Laziness
- Selfless love and courage
- Pride in his fame
- Greed for money
Show answer
Answer: B. He risks and finally gives his life for Johnsy, without telling anyone, which shows selfless love and courage.
-
3. Which theme is shown when Johnsy recovers after deciding to live?
- The power of hope and the will to live
- The beauty of autumn
- The value of money
- The danger of painting
Show answer
Answer: A. Her treatment did not change; her attitude did. The story shows that hope and the will to live help healing.
-
4. Why is the story's ending called a surprise ending?
- Johnsy dies
- The doctor turns out to be Behrman
- Sue moves away
- The truth that the leaf was painted is revealed only at the very end
Show answer
Answer: D. The reader, like Johnsy, believes the leaf is real until Sue reveals in the last lines that Behrman painted it.
-
5. What is ironic about Behrman's fate?
- He becomes rich
- The man who called Johnsy's idea foolish dies saving her
- He paints a picture of a miner
- He never meets Johnsy
Show answer
Answer: B. He mocked her belief as foolish, yet he took it seriously enough to give his life to defeat it. The reversal is ironic.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.