• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Last Leaf, part 2: the stormy night and Behrman's masterpiece

Retell the second half of the story: Sue's talk with Behrman, the stormy night, the leaf that does not fall, Johnsy's recovery, and the surprise ending that reveals Behrman's masterpiece.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe Behrman and his lifelong dream.
  • Explain how the leaf that does not fall changes Johnsy.
  • Retell the clues that reveal what Behrman did.
  • Explain why the painted leaf is called his masterpiece.

The second half of the story introduces a new character, keeps one secret from Johnsy and the reader, and reveals it only in the last lines. Look out for the clues as you read.

Behrman

Behrman lives on the ground floor. He is a sixty-year-old painter whose lifelong dream has been to paint a masterpiece, but that dream has never come true. Sue pours out her worries to him: Johnsy is convinced she will die when the last leaf falls. Behrman reacts gruffly, calling the idea foolish. Sue explains that Johnsy has a high fever and refuses to eat or drink. Behrman says he will come up and see her.

They tiptoe into the room. Johnsy is asleep. Sue draws the curtains and they go into the next room. Peeping out, Sue sees only one leaf left on the creeper. Heavy rain is falling and an icy wind is blowing; it looks as if the leaf must fall at any moment. Behrman says nothing at all, and goes back to his room. His silence is the first clue.

The leaf that stays

Next morning Johnsy weakly asks Sue to open the curtains. Sue does so unwillingly, afraid of what they will see. But one leaf is still there, green and healthy-looking, after the storm and the fierce winds. Johnsy says she heard the wind and is sure it will fall that day. Sue pleads with her to live for her friends. All day Johnsy checks the leaf every hour or so, and it is still there. That evening another storm blows, and still the leaf does not fall.

Johnsy's change of heart

After looking at the leaf for a long time, Johnsy calls Sue. She says she has behaved badly: Sue has cared for her lovingly while she has refused to help herself, sunk in gloom. The leaf, she says, has shown her that it is wrong to wish to die. Sue hugs her and gives her hot soup and a mirror; Johnsy combs her hair and smiles. That afternoon the doctor says Johnsy now has the will to live and will soon recover. But he must go downstairs to Behrman, who also has pneumonia, and for him the doctor has no hope.

The surprise ending

The next morning Sue sits on Johnsy's bed and tells her that Behrman died of pneumonia, after only two days of illness. The caretaker had found him shivering in wet clothes and shoes after being out on the stormy night. Near his bed lay a ladder, a lantern still burning, brushes and green and yellow paints. Sue asks Johnsy to look at the leaf again: has she not wondered why it never moves in the wind? Behrman painted it on the wall on the night the last real leaf fell. It is his masterpiece.

Clues to the secret

  1. Behrman's silence He sees the last leaf in the storm and says nothing.
  2. The leaf survives Two storms, yet it stays green.
  3. Behrman falls ill Pneumonia, after a night out in the storm.
  4. Things by his bed Ladder, lit lantern, brushes, green and yellow paint.
  5. The leaf never flutters It is painted on the wall: his masterpiece.
O. Henry plants clues before revealing the truth.

Worked example 1: reading the clues

Question: What do the ladder, lantern and paints prove? Working: a ladder reaches high on a wall; a lantern gives light at night; green and yellow are the colours of an ivy leaf. Together with his wet clothes, they show he climbed up the wall in the storm at night and painted. Answer: they prove that Behrman painted the last leaf on the wall that stormy night.

Worked example 2: why a 'masterpiece'?

Question: Behrman never painted a famous picture. Why is the leaf his masterpiece? Working: a masterpiece is an excellent work of art. The leaf was so real that it fooled Johnsy, and it gave her the will to live. Answer: it was so lifelike that it saved a life; no painting could achieve more, so it was his greatest work.

The leaf that never fluttered was not nature's: it was an old painter's gift of life.

Key takeaways: Behrman learns of Johnsy's belief and, in silence, paints a leaf on the wall in a stormy night. The leaf's survival gives Johnsy the will to live. Behrman catches pneumonia and dies, and his painted leaf is revealed as his masterpiece.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What was Behrman's lifelong dream?

    1. To become rich
    2. To paint a masterpiece
    3. To become a doctor
    4. To leave the city
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The story says Behrman, a sixty-year-old painter, had always dreamed of painting a masterpiece, but it had remained only a dream.

  2. 2. Why did Sue go down to Behrman at first?

    1. To ask him to be the model for her painting of an old miner
    2. To borrow money
    3. To call the doctor
    4. To ask him to paint a leaf
    Show answer

    Answer: A. She wanted him to model for her picture of an old miner, and while there she poured out her worries about Johnsy.

  3. 3. What did Johnsy realise after watching the leaf survive a second storm?

    1. That the leaf was painted
    2. That Sue had lied
    3. That it is wrong to wish to die
    4. That she should move house
    Show answer

    Answer: C. She told Sue she had been gloomy and uncooperative, and that the leaf had shown her that wanting to die is a sin.

  4. 4. How did Behrman fall ill?

    1. He caught Johnsy's illness by visiting her
    2. He worked too long in his studio
    3. He fell from the ladder
    4. He spent the stormy night outside, getting soaked
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The caretaker found him shivering in wet clothes and shoes; he had been out on the stormy night and caught pneumonia.

  5. 5. What clue tells Sue the leaf is painted?

    1. It never flutters when the wind blows
    2. It is bigger than the others
    3. It is brown
    4. It shines at night
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Sue asks Johnsy whether she has not wondered why the leaf does not move in the wind. A painted leaf cannot flutter.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Characters and themes in The Last Leaf

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery