• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Last Leaf, part 1: Johnsy's illness and the counting of leaves

Retell the first half of O. Henry's story: Johnsy's pneumonia, the doctor's warning about her will to live, Sue's efforts to cheer her, and Johnsy's belief that she will die when the last ivy leaf falls.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Say who wrote the story and who Sue and Johnsy are.
  • Explain what the doctor tells Sue and why it matters.
  • Describe how Sue tries to help Johnsy.
  • Explain the link Johnsy makes between the ivy leaves and her life.

The Last Leaf is Lesson 5 of the PSEB Class 9 English Literature Book (Supplementary Reader). It is a story by O. Henry, the pen name of an American short-story writer famous for endings that take the reader by surprise. The story is about illness, friendship and an old painter's secret act of love. This lesson covers the first half, up to Johnsy's strange decision.

Two friends in a small flat

Sue and Johnsy are two young artists who share a small flat on the third floor of an old house. In November, Johnsy falls seriously ill with pneumonia, a lung infection. She lies in bed without moving, staring out of the window. Sue, deeply worried, calls the doctor. He visits every day, but Johnsy does not improve.

The doctor's warning

One day the doctor takes Sue aside and asks whether anything is troubling Johnsy. Sue says no. The doctor explains his worry: Johnsy seems to have decided that she will not get well, and if a patient does not want to live, medicines cannot help. This is the key idea of the whole story: the will to live matters as much as medicine.

Sue's efforts

Sue tries hard to wake Johnsy's interest in life. She chats about clothes and fashions, but Johnsy does not answer. Then Sue brings her drawing board into the room and paints there, whistling as she works, to take Johnsy's mind off her illness.

Counting backwards

Suddenly Sue hears Johnsy whispering numbers backwards: twelve, then eleven, ten, and on down. Looking out, Sue sees an old ivy creeper climbing halfway up the brick wall opposite, losing its leaves in the strong wind. Johnsy explains that three days ago there were almost a hundred leaves; now only a handful remain, and they are falling faster. She says, with complete certainty, that when the last leaf falls she will die. Sue calls this nonsense and reminds her that the doctor expects her to recover, but Johnsy will not even take the soup Sue brings. She wants to see the last leaf fall before dark and then, she says, she will sleep forever.

Sue begs her not to look out of the window while she finishes a painting, which she needs to sell to earn money for them both; she cannot close the curtain because she needs the light. Johnsy agrees, but says she is tired of waiting and wants to go peacefully, like one of the tired leaves. Sue tells her to sleep, and goes downstairs to fetch an old painter named Behrman to be her model for a picture of an old miner.

Part 1 in order

  1. Illness Johnsy has pneumonia in November.
  2. Warning The doctor: without the will to live, medicine will fail.
  3. Sue tries Talk of fashion, painting, whistling.
  4. Counting Johnsy counts the ivy leaves as they fall.
  5. The belief When the last leaf falls, she will die.
  6. Sue goes down She fetches Behrman to model for her painting.

Worked example 1: the doctor's question

Question: Why does the doctor ask whether anything is worrying Johnsy? Working: he visits every day and his treatment is not working. A doctor who sees no improvement looks for a cause beyond the disease. Answer: he senses that Johnsy has lost the wish to live, and he knows that without it his medicines cannot cure her.

Worked example 2: why the leaves?

Question: Why does Johnsy link her life to the ivy leaves? Working: she is weak, sad and staring at the creeper all day. The leaves fall one by one, just as she feels her strength going. Answer: in her hopeless mood she sees the dying creeper as a sign of her own fate; each falling leaf seems to count down her life.

If a patient does not want to live, medicine alone cannot save her: the will to live is part of the cure.

Key takeaways: Johnsy, ill with pneumonia, has lost hope. The doctor warns that her will to live is the real problem. Sue tries to cheer her, but Johnsy is convinced she will die when the last ivy leaf falls.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What illness did Johnsy have?

    1. Malaria
    2. Pneumonia
    3. Typhoid
    4. A broken leg
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The story says Johnsy fell seriously ill with pneumonia in November.

  2. 2. What did the doctor fear about Johnsy?

    1. She was not taking her medicines
    2. She needed an operation
    3. She had decided she would not get well
    4. She was eating too much
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He told Sue that Johnsy seemed to have made up her mind not to get well, and that medicines would not help someone who did not want to live.

  3. 3. What was Johnsy counting?

    1. The ivy leaves left on the creeper
    2. The days until Christmas
    3. The bricks on the wall
    4. Her paintings
    Show answer

    Answer: A. She was counting backwards the leaves remaining on the old ivy creeper on the wall opposite her window.

  4. 4. What did Johnsy believe would happen when the last leaf fell?

    1. The winter would end
    2. Sue would sell her painting
    3. The doctor would stop coming
    4. She would die
    Show answer

    Answer: D. She said firmly that when the last leaf fell she would die, and that she had known this for three days.

  5. 5. Why could Sue not draw the curtain while she painted?

    1. The curtain was torn
    2. She needed the light to paint
    3. Johnsy wanted fresh air
    4. The doctor had forbidden it
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Sue explained that she needed the light to finish her painting, which she wanted to sell to earn money for them.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery