- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Departmental undertaking: advantages and disadvantages
Explain the seven advantages and seven disadvantages of the departmental undertaking given in the Tamil Nadu textbook, including red-tapism and financial dependence.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List and explain the advantages of a departmental undertaking.
- List and explain its disadvantages, including red-tapism.
- Judge which kinds of activity suit the departmental form.
Being part of the Government gives a departmental undertaking firm control and secrecy, but it also ties it to slow procedures. Knowing both sides helps you see why governments later created other forms.
Advantages
- Easy formation: it is created by an administrative decision of the Government, with no legal formalities.
- Direct control of Parliament or the State Legislature: it is answerable to the legislature through its minister.
- Secrecy maintained: strategic industries such as defence and atomic power are best managed by government departments, which can keep their working secret.
- Lesser burden of tax on the public: all its earnings go into the treasury, so less needs to be raised by taxes.
- Instrument of social change: the Government can use it to promote economic and social justice.
- Lesser risk of misuse of public money: government budgeting, accounting and audit procedures apply to it.
- Guided by the ministry's rules: its officers work under the ministry's direct control and rules framed for public welfare.
Disadvantages
- Red-tapism: too many procedures cause delay, which a commercial organisation cannot afford.
- Additional taxation: losses are met from the treasury, which often needs extra taxes that fall on the common man.
- Lack of competition and consumer focus: civil servants without a business outlook may run it in their own way, ignoring the sovereignty of consumers.
- Casual approach to work: frequent transfers of officers lead to a casual attitude, and efficiency suffers.
- Government interference: it has no freedom to decide its own policies; centralised control causes delay.
- Lack of professional management and fear of criticism: civil servants may lack management skills and avoid innovation for fear of criticism by the minister or Parliament.
- Financial dependence: it depends on budget allocations and cannot take independent long-range investment decisions.
Red-tapism is a key term: it means excessive official formality and paperwork, with files passing through many hands before a decision is taken, so that action is delayed.
Departmental undertaking at a glance
-
Strengths
- Easy to form
- Direct legislative control
- Secrecy for strategic work
- Earnings go to the treasury
- Tool for social justice
- Low risk of misuse of money
-
Weaknesses
- Red-tapism and delay
- Losses mean extra taxes
- Consumers ignored
- Casual approach due to transfers
- No freedom on policy
- No professional managers, no innovation
- Depends on the budget
The same rules that protect public money (budget, audit, ministry control) also make the departmental undertaking slow and inflexible.
Worked example 1: is the departmental form suitable?
Question: which of these suits the departmental form better: (a) manufacturing defence equipment, (b) a fashion clothing business that must respond to changing tastes every season? Reasoning: (a) needs secrecy and direct government control, which the departmental form provides. (b) needs quick decisions and commercial flexibility, which red-tapism and centralised control would block. So (a) suits the departmental form; (b) does not.
Worked example 2: losses and the taxpayer
Made-up figures: a departmental undertaking has expenses of ₹540 crore and revenue of ₹460 crore in a year. Working: loss = ₹540 − ₹460 = ₹80 crore. This is met from the treasury. If the Government raises it from 4 crore taxpayers equally, each pays ₹80 crore ÷ 4 crore = ₹20 more. This shows the 'incidence of additional taxation'. If, instead, the undertaking had earned a surplus, that surplus would go into the treasury and reduce the tax burden, the advantage on the other side.
Key takeaways: the departmental undertaking is easy to form, secret, answerable and safe with public money, but suffers from red-tapism, interference, casual work, lack of professional managers and financial dependence; it suits strategic activities better than fast-moving commercial ones.
Check your understanding
-
1. What does 'red-tapism' mean?
- A special tax on government companies
- Delay caused by too many official procedures
- The use of red ink in government accounts
- A strike by public employees
Show answer
Answer: B. Red-tapism is excess of procedure and paperwork, which delays decisions. Commercial organisations cannot afford such delay.
-
2. Why does the textbook say a departmental undertaking is suitable for defence and atomic power?
- It can maintain secrecy in its working
- It has no minister in charge
- It raises money from the share market
- It has no audit
Show answer
Answer: A. Strategic industries need secrecy and direct control, which a government department provides.
-
3. A departmental undertaking makes a loss. How is it usually met?
- By the minister personally
- By issuing shares to the public
- By the employees' salaries
- From the treasury, often requiring additional taxation
Show answer
Answer: D. Losses are met out of the treasury, which often needs extra taxes whose burden falls on the common man.
-
4. Frequent transfers of officers in a departmental undertaking lead to:
- more professional management
- greater financial autonomy
- a casual approach to work and lower efficiency
- a fall in red-tapism
Show answer
Answer: C. Officers who expect to be transferred soon develop a casual attitude, so operational efficiency suffers.
-
5. Made-up figures: revenue ₹300 crore, expenses ₹345 crore. The loss to be met from the treasury is:
- ₹45 crore
- ₹645 crore
- ₹55 crore
- ₹35 crore
Show answer
Answer: A. Loss = expenses − revenue = ₹345 − ₹300 = ₹45 crore.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.