- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Government company: advantages, disadvantages and comparing the three forms
Explain the advantages and disadvantages of a Government company as the textbook gives them, and compare departmental undertakings, public corporations and Government companies.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the advantages of a Government company.
- Explain the criticisms of it, including 'a fraud on the Companies Act'.
- Compare the three forms of public enterprise.
The Government company became a popular form because it is quick to set up and easy to change. But critics say its independence is often more apparent than real. This lesson weighs both sides and then puts all three forms side by side.
Advantages
- Easy formation: an executive decision and registration under the Companies Act are enough.
- Internal autonomy: it manages its affairs relatively free of ministerial control in day-to-day working.
- Private participation: the Government can use management skills, technical know-how and expertise of the private sector and foreign countries. The textbook's example: Hindustan Steel Limited obtained technical and financial help from the U.S.S.R., West Germany and the U.K. for its plants at Bhilai, Rourkela and Durgapur.
- Easy to alter: objectives and powers change by altering the Memorandum of Association, without Parliament's approval.
- Discipline: the Companies Act keeps the management active, alert and disciplined.
- Professional management: with its own personnel policies it can hire qualified managers.
- Public accountability: its annual report is presented to and debated in the legislature.
Disadvantages
- Board packed with 'yes-men': directors appointed by the Government may simply agree with it and fail to run the company in a businesslike way.
- Autonomy only in name: politicians, ministers and officials may interfere heavily.
- 'A fraud on the Companies Act and the Constitution': the Government can exempt it from many provisions of the Act, and Parliament is not consulted when it is created.
- Fear of exposure: criticism in the legislature and the press can demoralise managers and discourage innovation.
- Lack of expertise in deputationists: officials deputed from departments may lack expertise and commitment.
- Selfish functioning: critics say it may serve neither the Government nor the public but the personal interests of those who run it.
The three forms compared
| Basis | Departmental undertaking | Public corporation | Government company |
|---|---|---|---|
| Created by | Administrative decision | Special Act of the legislature | Executive decision and registration under the Companies Act |
| Legal status | Part of the Government | Separate legal entity | Separate legal entity |
| Finance | Annual budget; revenue to treasury | Capital from Government; keeps its earnings | At least 51% capital from Government; revenue not to treasury |
| Staff | Civil servants | Its own staff | Its own staff, plus deputed officials |
| Can be sued? | Only with Government's consent | Yes, in its own name | Yes, in its own name |
| Changing its powers | Government order | Amend the Act | Alter the Memorandum of Association |
| Example from the book | Indian Railways | Life Insurance Corporation of India | Steel Authority of India Ltd |
From most government control to most autonomy
- Departmental undertaking Run as part of a ministry
- Public corporation Autonomous body made by statute
- Government company Company form, changed by its Memorandum
Departmental = part of Government; public corporation = made by statute; Government company = registered company with at least 51% Government holding.
Worked example 1: choose the form
Question: a State wants to start a tourism hotel chain quickly, with expert managers and possibly a private technology partner, and expects to change its line of business as markets change. Reasoning: a special Act would take time (rules out a public corporation); civil servants and red-tapism do not suit a hotel business (rules out the departmental form). A Government company can be formed by executive decision, hire professionals, involve private partners and change by altering its Memorandum. Answer: a Government company.
Worked example 2: identify the form
Made-up descriptions: (a) 'Its staff are transferred like other government employees and its income is deposited in the treasury'; (b) 'It was established by an Act and its accounts are audited by the CAG'; (c) 'The State holds 74% of its paid-up capital and it was registered with the Registrar of Companies.' Answers: (a) departmental undertaking; (b) public corporation; (c) Government company, since 74% is more than 51%.
Key takeaways: a Government company is easy to form and change, can use private and foreign expertise and professional managers, and is accountable to the legislature, but faces criticism of yes-men boards, nominal autonomy, exemptions from company law, fear of exposure and weak deputationists. Each form suits different work.
Check your understanding
-
1. Objectives and powers of a Government company can be changed by:
- amending a special Act of Parliament
- altering its Memorandum of Association
- a vote of the State Legislature only
- an order of the Comptroller and Auditor General
Show answer
Answer: B. Being a registered company, it changes its objectives by altering its Memorandum, without seeking Parliament's approval.
-
2. The textbook's example of 'private participation' through a Government company is:
- Indian Railways buying new engines
- LIC selling policies
- Hindustan Steel Limited obtaining technical and financial help from abroad for its steel plants
- All India Radio starting a channel
Show answer
Answer: C. Hindustan Steel Limited got help from the U.S.S.R., West Germany and the U.K. for its plants at Bhilai, Rourkela and Durgapur.
-
3. Why is a Government company criticised as 'a fraud on the Companies Act and the Constitution'?
- It can be exempted from many provisions of the Act and is created without consulting Parliament
- It pays more tax than private companies
- It has no Board of Directors
- It is run by a foreign MNC
Show answer
Answer: A. The Government may exempt it from several provisions of the Act, and Parliament is not taken into confidence when it is created.
-
4. Which form can be sued only with the consent of the Government?
- Public corporation
- Government company
- All three equally
- Departmental undertaking
Show answer
Answer: D. A departmental undertaking has sovereign immunity. A public corporation and a Government company are separate legal entities and can be sued in their own names.
-
5. Made-up figures: a State holds ₹74 crore of a company's paid-up capital of ₹100 crore. Which form is it, and why?
- A public corporation, because it is owned by the State
- A Government company, because 74% is more than 51%
- A departmental undertaking, because the State owns it
- Not a public enterprise, because 26% is private
Show answer
Answer: B. Share = 74 ÷ 100 × 100 = 74%, which is not less than 51%. A company registered with this holding is a Government company.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.