- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Public enterprise and the departmental undertaking
Explain why governments entered business, the two ways they do so, and the meaning, examples and five features of a departmental undertaking.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why government intervention in business became necessary.
- Name the two ways a government can own and control business.
- Define a departmental undertaking and explain its features.
A train ticket, a letter delivered by the post office, a programme on All India Radio: all of these are services supplied by the Government itself. When the State owns and runs a business activity, it is called a public enterprise. This chapter studies the three forms such enterprises take: the departmental undertaking, the public corporation and the Government company.
Why governments entered business
The Tamil Nadu textbook explains that earlier the role of government was limited to maintaining law and order. The Industrial Revolution brought all-round growth of industry, but private entrepreneurs worked only for profit, and the exploitation of consumers and workers was common. Leaving industrial development wholly to private judgement did not protect the public, so during the twentieth century governments, even in developed countries such as the USA and the UK, began to take part in industrial and commercial activity.
A government can own and control business in two ways: (i) by starting a new unit, or (ii) by taking over an existing unit owned by private persons. Taking over private units is known as nationalisation.
Meaning of a departmental undertaking
The departmental form is the oldest form of organising state enterprises. In early days no distinction was made between the routine work of government and the running of its enterprises, so most early state enterprises were departmental. Under this form, the enterprise is run as a full-fledged ministry or as a major sub-division of a government department.
The textbook's examples: the Indian Railways, managed by the Ministry of Railways; Post and Telegraph services, run as a department under the Ministry of Communication; the Delhi Milk Scheme, All India Radio and Doordarshan. Its list also includes the Department of Food and Public Distribution and the Tamil Nadu Police Department.
Features of a departmental undertaking
- Ultimate responsibility with the minister: the minister concerned is answerable to Parliament or the State Legislature for the undertaking and delegates authority down the levels of management.
- Government financing: money comes through annual budget appropriations by Parliament or the State Legislature, and the undertaking's revenues are paid into the government treasury.
- Accounting and audit: it follows the same budgeting, accounting and audit procedures as any government department.
- Managed by civil servants: its staff are government servants with the same service conditions as other civil servants.
- Sovereign immunity: it cannot be sued without the consent of the Government.
Line of control in a departmental undertaking
- Parliament or State Legislature Grants the budget and questions the minister
- Minister Bears ultimate responsibility
- Department officials Civil servants who receive delegated authority
- Undertaking's operations Revenues go back to the treasury
A departmental undertaking is a part of the Government itself: run by a ministry, financed by the budget, staffed by civil servants.
Worked example 1: which way did the Government enter?
Made-up cases: (a) a State Government sets up a brand-new seed-testing laboratory; (b) the Government buys out a private bus company and runs it. Answers: (a) starting a new unit; (b) taking over an existing private unit, that is, nationalisation.
Worked example 2: spotting the features
Made-up case: a State's 'Department of Handloom Sales' runs showrooms. Its income is deposited in the treasury, its money comes from the State budget, its staff are transferred like other government employees, and a minister answers questions about it in the Assembly. Analysis: budget financing and treasury deposits = government financing; transferable government staff = managed by civil servants; minister answering the Assembly = ultimate responsibility. It is a departmental undertaking.
Key takeaways: governments entered business to protect the public from exploitation; they start new units or take over private ones; the departmental undertaking, the oldest form, is run by a ministry, financed by the budget, audited like a department, staffed by civil servants and cannot be sued without the Government's consent.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the textbook, which is the oldest form of organising public enterprises?
- Public corporation
- Government company
- Departmental undertaking
- Multinational corporation
Show answer
Answer: C. The departmental form is the oldest; early state enterprises were not separated from the routine work of government.
-
2. Taking over an existing privately owned unit by the Government is known as:
- nationalisation
- privatisation
- incorporation
- decentralisation
Show answer
Answer: A. The Government can start a new unit or take over a private one. Taking over a private unit is nationalisation.
-
3. Which of these is given in the textbook as an example of a departmental undertaking?
- Life Insurance Corporation of India
- Coal India Ltd
- Steel Authority of India Ltd
- Indian Railways
Show answer
Answer: D. Indian Railways is managed by the Ministry of Railways. LIC is a public corporation; Coal India and SAIL are Government companies.
-
4. How is a departmental undertaking financed?
- By selling shares on the stock exchange
- Through annual budget appropriations by Parliament or the State Legislature
- By loans from foreign MNCs only
- By keeping all its own earnings
Show answer
Answer: B. It is financed from the budget, and its revenues are paid into the government treasury.
-
5. 'Sovereign immunity' of a departmental undertaking means that:
- it cannot be sued without the consent of the Government
- it pays no salaries
- it can never make a loss
- it is free from audit
Show answer
Answer: A. As part of the Government, a departmental undertaking cannot be sued by anybody without the Government's consent.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.