• Practice
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Public corporation: meaning, features, merits and demerits

Define a public (statutory) corporation, explain its eight features, and weigh its advantages, such as operational autonomy, against its disadvantages, such as rigid constitution.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define a public corporation and explain why it is called a statutory corporation.
  • Explain its features, including financial autonomy and public accountability.
  • Weigh its advantages and disadvantages.

Governments found that the departmental form was too slow for commercial work, yet they still wanted public ownership and public accountability. The answer was the public corporation, a body owned by the State but free to run like a business.

Meaning

The textbook describes a public corporation as a public enterprise created as an autonomous unit by a special Act of Parliament or the State Legislature. Because it is created by a statute, it is also called a statutory corporation. The Act lays down its objectives, powers and functions. The textbook's examples include the Life Insurance Corporation of India and the Food Corporation of India, and it also lists Indian Airlines, Air India International and the Oil and Natural Gas Commission.

Features

  1. Special statute: created by a special Act that defines its powers, objectives, functions and relations with the ministry and the legislature.
  2. Separate legal entity: it has perpetual succession and a common seal; it can own property, make contracts and sue or be sued in its own name.
  3. Capital from the Government: capital comes from the Government or agencies it controls, though many corporations now also raise money from the capital market.
  4. Financial autonomy: it prepares its own budget and can keep and use its earnings.
  5. Board of Directors: management is vested in a board appointed or nominated by the Government, with no government interference in day-to-day work.
  6. Own staff: it decides its own staff's appointment, pay and service conditions.
  7. Service motive: service is the main aim, though it should be self-supporting and earn reasonable profits.
  8. Public accountability: it submits an annual report; its accounts are audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General of India, and both are placed before the legislature.

Advantages

  • Bold management: operational autonomy lets it run in a businesslike way and experiment.
  • Legislative control: committees of the legislature and the press keep watch, checking unhealthy practices.
  • Qualified and contented staff: attractive service conditions bring able staff and fewer industrial relations problems.
  • Tailor-made statute: the Act can be designed for its specific needs.
  • Not affected by political changes: as a distinct legal entity it keeps continuity of policy.
  • Lesser likelihood of exploitation: the board includes representatives of labour, consumers and others.
  • Reasonable pricing: prices are based on cost-benefit analysis.

Disadvantages

  • Autonomy only in theory: in practice ministers, officials and politicians interfere.
  • Misuse of monopoly power: many corporations are monopolies and may ignore or exploit consumers.
  • Rigid constitution: it cannot change without amending its statute.
  • Low managerial efficiency: civil servants without management skills may be put on the board.
  • Problem of passing a special Act: this is slow and difficult, which limits their number.
  • Clash of divergent interests: board members representing different groups may quarrel.

Public corporation

  • Created by
    • Special Act of Parliament or State Legislature
  • Freedom
    • Separate legal entity
    • Own budget and earnings
    • Own staff
  • Control
    • Board nominated by Government
    • Audit by the Comptroller and Auditor General
    • Annual report to the legislature

Public corporation = public ownership + statutory creation + business-like autonomy + accountability to the legislature.

Worked example 1: departmental or public corporation?

Made-up case: a State creates a 'Coastal Ferries Corporation' by passing a special Act. It keeps its fare income to buy new boats and recruits its own engineers. Analysis: a special Act = statutory creation; keeping earnings = financial autonomy; own recruitment = own staff. It is a public corporation, not a departmental undertaking, whose revenue would go to the treasury and whose staff would be civil servants.

Worked example 2: why a rigid constitution matters

Suppose the same ferry corporation wants to start running tourist buses, which its Act does not allow. Reasoning: its powers come from the statute, so it must wait until the legislature amends the Act. This shows both the 'rigid constitution' disadvantage and the 'problem of passing a special Act'.

Key takeaways: a public corporation is created by a special Act, is a separate legal entity with financial autonomy and its own staff, aims at service, and is audited by the CAG and reported to the legislature; it gains bold management and continuity but can suffer interference, monopoly abuse and rigidity.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why is a public corporation also called a statutory corporation?

    1. It is registered under the Companies Act
    2. It is run by a ministry
    3. It is owned by private shareholders
    4. It is created by a special Act (statute) of the legislature
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A public corporation comes into existence through a special statute, so it is called a statutory corporation.

  2. 2. Who audits the accounts of a public corporation, according to the textbook?

    1. The minister concerned
    2. The Comptroller and Auditor General of India
    3. A private shareholder
    4. The Board of Directors itself
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Its accounts are audited by the CAG, and the annual report and audited accounts are placed before the legislature.

  3. 3. Which feature lets a public corporation keep and use its own earnings?

    1. Financial autonomy
    2. Sovereign immunity
    3. Red-tapism
    4. Rigid constitution
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Financial autonomy means it prepares its own budget and can retain and use its earnings.

  4. 4. 'Autonomy and flexibility only in theory' means that in practice:

    1. it has no Board of Directors
    2. it is free from all audit
    3. ministers, officials and politicians interfere in its working
    4. it can change its Act by itself
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook says autonomy exists only on paper; in practice there is a lot of interference.

  5. 5. Why does the textbook say the scope for setting up public corporations is restricted?

    1. Each needs a special Act, which is time-consuming and difficult to pass
    2. They cannot own property
    3. They must earn huge profits
    4. They can only be formed by MNCs
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A public corporation cannot be formed without passing a special Act, a slow and difficult process.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery