Revision notes

Chapter 9 Government Organisation: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Public enterprise and the departmental undertaking

Line of control in a departmental undertaking

  1. Parliament or State Legislature Grants the budget and questions the minister
  2. Minister Bears ultimate responsibility
  3. Department officials Civil servants who receive delegated authority
  4. Undertaking's operations Revenues go back to the treasury

A departmental undertaking is a part of the Government itself: run by a ministry, financed by the budget, staffed by civil servants.

Key takeaways: governments entered business to protect the public from exploitation; they start new units or take over private ones; the departmental undertaking, the oldest form, is run by a ministry, financed by the budget, audited like a department, staffed by civil servants and cannot be sued without the Government's consent.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Departmental undertaking: advantages and disadvantages

Departmental undertaking at a glance

  • Strengths
    • Easy to form
    • Direct legislative control
    • Secrecy for strategic work
    • Earnings go to the treasury
    • Tool for social justice
    • Low risk of misuse of money
  • Weaknesses
    • Red-tapism and delay
    • Losses mean extra taxes
    • Consumers ignored
    • Casual approach due to transfers
    • No freedom on policy
    • No professional managers, no innovation
    • Depends on the budget

The same rules that protect public money (budget, audit, ministry control) also make the departmental undertaking slow and inflexible.

Key takeaways: the departmental undertaking is easy to form, secret, answerable and safe with public money, but suffers from red-tapism, interference, casual work, lack of professional managers and financial dependence; it suits strategic activities better than fast-moving commercial ones.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Public corporation: meaning, features, merits and demerits

Public corporation

  • Created by
    • Special Act of Parliament or State Legislature
  • Freedom
    • Separate legal entity
    • Own budget and earnings
    • Own staff
  • Control
    • Board nominated by Government
    • Audit by the Comptroller and Auditor General
    • Annual report to the legislature

Public corporation = public ownership + statutory creation + business-like autonomy + accountability to the legislature.

Key takeaways: a public corporation is created by a special Act, is a separate legal entity with financial autonomy and its own staff, aims at service, and is audited by the CAG and reported to the legislature; it gains bold management and continuity but can suffer interference, monopoly abuse and rigidity.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Government company: meaning and features

Reading the definition
Who holds at least 51% of paid-up share capitalGovernment company?
The Central Government aloneYes
One State Government, or several togetherYes
The Central Government and one or more State Governments togetherYes
A company that is a subsidiary of a Government companyYes, it is included
Governments together hold less than 51%No

Public corporation and Government company

  • Public corporation
    • Created by a special Act
    • Needs the legislature to change its powers
    • Audit by the CAG
  • Government company
    • Registered under the Companies Act
    • Created by executive decision
    • Changes made by altering its Memorandum
    • At least 51% of paid-up capital with Government

Government company: at least 51% of paid-up share capital held by the Central and/or State Governments, including its subsidiaries.

Key takeaways: a Government company has at least 51% of its paid-up share capital held by the Central and/or State Governments; it is registered under the Companies Act by executive decision; it is a separate legal entity with its own staff, free from departmental procedures, with most directors named by the Government and its annual report placed before the legislature.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Government company: advantages, disadvantages and comparing the three forms

BasisDepartmental undertakingPublic corporationGovernment company
Created byAdministrative decisionSpecial Act of the legislatureExecutive decision and registration under the Companies Act
Legal statusPart of the GovernmentSeparate legal entitySeparate legal entity
FinanceAnnual budget; revenue to treasuryCapital from Government; keeps its earningsAt least 51% capital from Government; revenue not to treasury
StaffCivil servantsIts own staffIts own staff, plus deputed officials
Can be sued?Only with Government's consentYes, in its own nameYes, in its own name
Changing its powersGovernment orderAmend the ActAlter the Memorandum of Association
Example from the bookIndian RailwaysLife Insurance Corporation of IndiaSteel Authority of India Ltd

From most government control to most autonomy

  1. Departmental undertaking Run as part of a ministry
  2. Public corporation Autonomous body made by statute
  3. Government company Company form, changed by its Memorandum
A study aid: each form gives more freedom from day-to-day procedure.

Departmental = part of Government; public corporation = made by statute; Government company = registered company with at least 51% Government holding.

Key takeaways: a Government company is easy to form and change, can use private and foreign expertise and professional managers, and is accountable to the legislature, but faces criticism of yes-men boards, nominal autonomy, exemptions from company law, fear of exposure and weak deputationists. Each form suits different work.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery