- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
From Buxar to the Regulating Act: dual government and its failure
Explain how Buxar and the treaties of Allahabad gave the Company the Diwani, how Clive's dual government worked and failed in the famine of 1770, and what the Regulating Act of 1773 changed.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why the textbook calls Buxar the real foundation battle of British dominion.
- Describe the dual system (Diwani and Nizamat) and why it is called power without responsibility.
- Trace the titles from Governor of Fort William to Viceroy and Governor-General.
The Tamil textbook opens this chapter with a simple idea: as Mughal central authority broke down, a trading company ended up ruling India. At first the English East India Company cared about smooth trade, not government. The book says that only after the terrible Bengal famine of 1770 did it begin to use its power with some responsibility, and that, whatever it claimed about protecting people and doing justice, its farming and trade policies harmed the economy. This lesson covers the first step: how the Company took power in Bengal and how badly that first arrangement worked.
Buxar and the treaties of Allahabad
At Buxar (1764) the Company defeated not only the Nawabs of Bengal and Oudh but also the Mughal emperor Shah Alam II. That is why the book calls Buxar, rather than Plassey, the real foundation battle of British dominion: the Company ceased to be merely a body of merchants and became a formidable political force. Clive returned as Governor of Fort William, disliked his predecessor Vansittart's plan to hand Oudh to Shah Alam, and negotiated afresh. The result was two treaties of Allahabad (1765).
| Party | What the treaties of Allahabad gave or required |
|---|---|
| The Company | The Diwani (revenue administration) of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa |
| Shah Alam II | The districts of Allahabad and Kora, and an annual allowance of 26 lakh rupees from Bengal's revenues |
| Shuja-ud-daula | Oudh restored to him on payment of a war indemnity |
| Nawab of Bengal | Remained formally responsible for governing Bengal, Bihar and Orissa |
The dual system
Even before the emperor granted the Diwani, the Nawab of Bengal (Mir Jafar's successor) had practically handed the Nizamat to the Company. So the Company held both offices. The Diwan collected revenue and controlled civil justice; the Nizam held military power and dispensed criminal justice. But the Company kept the real power while the formal responsibility of government stayed with the Nawab. This arrangement is called the Dual System, Double Government or Dyarchy.
Who did what under Clive's dual government
-
The Company (real power)
- Held the Diwani: revenue and civil justice
- Controlled the Nizamat in practice: army and criminal justice
- Collected the money
- Answered to no one in Bengal for results
-
The Nawab (formal responsibility)
- Named as responsible for governing
- No army or revenue of his own to govern with
- Blamed for failures
- A powerless and dependent prince
Breakdown: the famine of 1770
Government without responsibility soon broke down. In the famine of 1770, according to the textbook, nearly one third of Bengal's population died, and the misery was made worse by Company servants who monopolised the sale of rice and made large profits. Shaken, the British Parliament passed the Regulating Act of 1773. Warren Hastings, Governor of Fort William, became Governor-General of Bengal. The Act also required the Directors to report the revenue dealings of Company servants to the British Treasury, and the Governor and Council sat as a Board of Revenue. The Pitt's India Act of 1784 followed with further changes in how India was governed.
How the head of British India's title changed
- Until 1772 Governor of Fort William or of Fort St. George.
- 1773 Regulating Act: Warren Hastings becomes Governor-General of Bengal.
- 1833 Charter Act: Governor-General of India; William Bentinck is the first.
- 1858 Crown takes over after the great rebellion; Canning first Viceroy and Governor-General.
Note who controlled the Governor-General: until 1858 he was chosen by, and answerable to, the Court of Directors of the Company. After the Queen's Proclamation of 1858 the Viceroy and Governor-General was accountable to the British Parliament.
Worked example 1: why Buxar and not Plassey?
Question: give two reasons the book treats Buxar as more decisive than Plassey. Working: (1) at Plassey the Company defeated one Nawab and installed another; at Buxar it defeated a combined force that included the Mughal emperor himself; (2) Buxar led directly to the treaties of Allahabad, which gave the Company the legal right to collect the revenue of three provinces. Answer: wider victory and a legal grant of revenue made Buxar the foundation of dominion.
Worked example 2: reading 'power without responsibility'
Question: a rice merchant in 1770 finds that Company servants control the grain trade, while petitions to the Nawab achieve nothing. Explain this using the dual system. Working: (1) the Company held revenue and, in practice, force, so it could control trade; (2) the Nawab was formally responsible but had no means to act; (3) no single authority both held power and answered for welfare. Answer: this is exactly the gap the book calls governance without responsibility, which deepened the famine.
Dual government (1765-1772): the Company held the Diwani (revenue and civil justice) and in effect the Nizamat (army and criminal justice); the Nawab carried the responsibility. It failed in the famine of 1770 and was followed by the Regulating Act of 1773.
Key takeaways: Buxar (1764) and the treaties of Allahabad (1765) gave the Company the Diwani of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa, while Shah Alam received Allahabad, Kora and an allowance and Oudh went back to Shuja-ud-daula. Clive's dual system split power from responsibility; the 1770 famine exposed it, and the Regulating Act of 1773 made Warren Hastings Governor-General of Bengal. The title became Governor-General of India in 1833 and Viceroy and Governor-General in 1858.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under the treaties of Allahabad, the Mughal emperor Shah Alam II received:
- the Diwani of Bengal
- the districts of Allahabad and Kora and an annual allowance
- the province of Oudh
- the right to appoint the Governor of Fort William
Show answer
Answer: B. The Company received the Diwani; Shah Alam got Allahabad and Kora and an allowance of 26 lakh rupees a year; Oudh was restored to Shuja-ud-daula on payment of an indemnity.
-
2. Under the dual system, which function belonged to the Diwan?
- Military command
- Criminal justice
- Collection of revenue and civil justice
- Foreign relations
Show answer
Answer: C. The Diwan collected revenue and controlled civil justice; the Nizam exercised military power and dispensed criminal justice.
-
3. Which event, according to the textbook, exposed the failure of the dual system?
- The Bengal famine of 1770
- The Battle of Buxar
- The Charter Act of 1833
- The Queen's Proclamation
Show answer
Answer: A. Governance without responsibility led to the terrible famine of 1770, made worse by Company servants who monopolised the rice trade; the Regulating Act of 1773 followed.
-
4. Who was the first Governor-General of India under the Charter Act of 1833?
- Warren Hastings
- Cornwallis
- Canning
- William Bentinck
Show answer
Answer: D. Warren Hastings was the first Governor-General of Bengal (1773). The 1833 Charter Act made the post Governor-General of India, with Bentinck the first; Canning was the first Viceroy (1858).
-
5. Assertion (A): The textbook calls Buxar the real foundation battle of British dominion in India. Reason (R): At Buxar the Company defeated the Nawabs of Bengal and Oudh and the Mughal emperor, and became a political force.
- Both A and R are true and R explains A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are false
Show answer
Answer: A. The book says that because the Nawabs of Bengal and Oudh and the emperor were all opposed and defeated at Buxar, the Company ceased to be a company of merchants and became a formidable political force. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.