- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Land revenue: Permanent Settlement, Ryotwari and Mahalwari
Compare Cornwallis's Permanent Settlement, the Madras experiments with mittahs and village leases, Munro's Ryotwari system and the Mahalwari system, and explain their effects on cultivators.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain what 'settlement' means and how the Permanent Settlement of 1793 created zamindars with hereditary rights.
- Describe the failed Madras experiments and the Ryotwari system framed by Thomas Munro.
- Assess, as the book does, whether these systems protected cultivators.
Land revenue was the main source of the Company's income, so how it was fixed and collected shaped the lives of most Indians. The book uses the word settlement for the assessment and fixing of the amount of land revenue that a holder had to pay to the government. The British tried several kinds.
The Permanent Settlement (1793)
Cornwallis, himself a large landlord in England, wanted to create landlords on the British model. In 1793, following the Directors' instructions, he made a settlement with the revenue farmers of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa. The revenue each zamindar had to pay was fixed permanently. Zamindars, who had been tax collectors, gained hereditary rights over the land and kept whatever they collected above the fixed sum. Cultivators were reduced to mere tenants under these new middlemen.
Experiments in the Madras Presidency
The book calls the first quarter of the nineteenth century a formative period for Madras land revenue. First the Permanent Settlement was tried: Chengalpattu, Salem and Dindigul were divided into mittahs and sold to the highest bidders. Most buyers squeezed the peasants and then failed within a year or two, so the experiment was dropped. Next came village leases: each village's revenue was fixed for three years from past collections, with the mirasdar responsible where mirasi rights existed and the village headman elsewhere. Bad monsoons, low grain prices and short leases ruined this too; when crops failed, whole villages defaulted and fled, and collectors had to bring peasants back.
The Ryotwari system and Thomas Munro
By 1814 the Directors had chosen the ryotwari system, framed by Thomas Munro. 'Ryot' comes, through English, from the Arabic ra'iyah, a peasant or cultivator. The ryot was the proprietor and taxpayer, and the government dealt with him directly, with no middlemen. He kept the land as long as he paid; default could mean eviction and seizure of livestock and property. Each cultivated field was assessed, and the assessment was to be reviewed once in thirty years, considering grain prices, markets and irrigation. Holders were registered and given pattas, and could sell, lease, mortgage or transfer the land: this introduced private property in land.
Munro reached Madras in 1780, fought in the Mysore wars, worked in the Baramahal (Salem) from 1792 to 1799, then in Kanara, and as collector of the Ceded Districts (Kadapa, Kurnool, Chittoor, Anantapur) worked out the ryotwari idea. He became Governor of Madras in 1820; the book says he enforced the system officially in 1822. He saw spending on education as an investment and urged Indianisation of the services. He died of cholera at Pattikonda in July 1827, and a statue was raised to him in Madras in 1839 by public subscription.
The Mahalwari system
A third pattern, Mahalwari, was introduced in 1833 under William Bentinck (in north India). The settlement was made with the proprietor of the estate (mahal), but revenue was collected from the individual cultivators.
| System | Who the state settled with | Revenue fixed | Where (as in the book) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Permanent Settlement (1793) | Zamindar | Permanently | Bengal, Bihar, Orissa |
| Ryotwari | Ryot (cultivator) directly | Field by field, reviewed every 30 years | Madras Presidency |
| Mahalwari (1833) | Proprietor of the estate (mahal) | For the estate; collected from cultivators | Introduced under Bentinck |
What actually happened
The book's verdict is critical. Ryotwari was meant to create independent peasants free from the 'corrupt and faithless zamindar', but in practice it strengthened big landlords, and the government did little to protect tenants. Because land was the main source of revenue, collection was rigorous. The Torture Commission in Madras reported in 1855 on atrocities by Indian revenue and police officials collecting land tax; the book says the law that justified forcible collection was abolished only after 1858.
Land revenue systems under Company rule
-
Through intermediaries
- Permanent Settlement: zamindars (1793)
- Madras mittahs sold to bidders (abandoned)
- Village leases via mirasdars or headmen (failed)
-
Direct with cultivators
- Ryotwari: Munro, Madras
- Pattas and private property in land
-
Mixed
- Mahalwari (1833): settled with the estate, collected from cultivators
Worked example 1: the zamindar's margin (made-up figures)
Question: a zamindar's fixed revenue under the Permanent Settlement is ₹5,000 a year. He collects ₹6,200 from tenants this year and ₹7,000 next year. What does he keep? Working: year 1: 6,200 − 5,000 = ₹1,200; year 2: 7,000 − 5,000 = ₹2,000. The state's share never rises, so every increase goes to the zamindar. Answer: ₹1,200 and ₹2,000, which shows why fixed revenue favoured zamindars and gave the state nothing from rising collections.
Worked example 2: why village leases failed
Question: list the causes the book gives and link them. Working: (1) bad monsoons reduced harvests; (2) low grain prices reduced the value of what was harvested; (3) a three-year lease gave no time to recover from a bad year. So in a bad year whole villages could not pay and fled. Answer: the fixed demand did not bend with nature or prices.
Permanent Settlement 1793 (Cornwallis): zamindars, fixed for ever. Ryotwari (Munro): state deals directly with the ryot; pattas; review every 30 years. Mahalwari 1833: settled with the estate, collected from cultivators.
Key takeaways: the Permanent Settlement made zamindars hereditary owners paying a fixed revenue. In Madras, mittah sales and village leases failed before Munro's ryotwari system dealt directly with cultivators and created private property in land. Mahalwari came in 1833. The book concludes that rigorous collection and weak protection of tenants left cultivators worse off, as the Torture Commission of 1855 revealed.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under the Permanent Settlement of 1793, the revenue to be paid was fixed permanently for:
- the ryots of Madras
- the zamindars of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa
- the mirasdars of Thanjavur
- the proprietors of mahals
Show answer
Answer: B. Cornwallis settled with the zamindars of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa and fixed their revenue permanently; the zamindars gained hereditary rights.
-
2. In the Madras districts of Chengalpattu, Salem and Dindigul, the first experiment was to:
- introduce ryotwari at once
- lease villages for thirty years
- divide the land into mittahs and sell them to the highest bidders
- give the land to the mirasdars free
Show answer
Answer: C. The book says these districts were divided into mittahs and sold to the highest bidders; most buyers failed within a year or two and the experiment was abandoned.
-
3. Which feature belongs to the Ryotwari system?
- The state dealt directly with the cultivator, who received a patta
- Revenue was fixed permanently
- The settlement was made with the village headman for three years
- Zamindars kept any surplus over the fixed sum
Show answer
Answer: A. Under ryotwari the ryot was proprietor and taxpayer, the government dealt with him directly, and registered holders were issued pattas.
-
4. The ryotwari assessment, as the textbook describes it, was to be reviewed:
- every year
- every three years
- never
- once in thirty years
Show answer
Answer: D. Each field's assessment was to be reviewed once in thirty years, taking into account grain prices, markets and irrigation. The three-year period belonged to the village lease system.
-
5. What did the Torture Commission's report of 1855 expose?
- Cruelty by Indian revenue and police officials collecting land tax in Madras
- Corruption among Company servants in the rice trade
- Ill treatment of indentured labourers in Ceylon
- Thuggee on the roads between Delhi and Agra
Show answer
Answer: A. The Commission, appointed by the Company government in Madras, exposed atrocities by Indian revenue and police officials in collecting land tax from cultivators.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.