• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

Railways, forests, deindustrialisation, famines and the drain of wealth

Explain how railways, telegraph, irrigation and forest policy served colonial ends, how British imports deindustrialised India, why famines and indentured emigration grew, and Dadabhai Naoroji's drain of wealth theory.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the first railways, the telegraph and the Company's record on irrigation and forests.
  • Explain deindustrialisation and its effect on weavers.
  • Explain famine, the indentured labour system and the Home Charges in Naoroji's drain theory.

The book ends the chapter with the economic effects of British rule, which it judges harshly: railways and telegraph helped control as well as connect, irrigation was neglected, forests were cut, India's crafts were ruined, famines grew more frequent, and wealth flowed out to England.

Railways and telegraph

European businessmen first proposed railways; Dalhousie persuaded the doubtful Directors that they would bring economic advantage. The first line ran from Bombay to Thane (1853), then Howrah to Raniganj (1854-55); in the south the first line ran from Royapuram to Arcot (Wallajah Road) in 1856. Before 1857, less than 300 miles had been laid. The telegraph began in 1854; its value was seen during the rebellion of 1857. With the Suez Canal (1869), the journey from Europe to India became some 4,000 miles shorter, and London could direct the government of India much more closely.

Irrigation and forests

The book says the British neglected irrigation: tanks and channels of earlier rulers fell into disuse. In Madras, the engineer Arthur Cotton built a dam across the Kollidam (Coleroon) in 1836, and work on a dam across the Krishna began in 1853. In the north the Jumna canal (1830), the Ganges canal and the Bari Doab canal were built, but canal water also caused salinity and waterlogging. Cotton urged that irrigation should come before railways; the government in England refused.

Because land revenue was the state's mainstay, forests were cleared for cultivation. Zamins were carved out of the Jungle Mahal forests and auctioned, and the Santhals were evicted, which the book says made them the first tribal group to resist British rule. Plantations and slope cultivation destroyed more forest, and railways consumed huge numbers of sleepers of sal, deodar and teak. The state then created a Forest Department and the Indian Forest Act of 1865, which restricted the forest rights of indigenous groups; to contain protest it passed the Criminal Tribes Act of 1871.

Deindustrialisation

For centuries Europe had bought more from the East than it sold. The Industrial Revolution in English textiles reversed this. India, once the world's leading exporter of cloth, became a market for Lancashire cottons. Machine-made British goods entered India with little or no import duty, while Indian goods faced high protective duties in Britain. Weavers lost work and turned to agriculture, crowding the land further. The book quotes witnesses: Charles Trevelyan told a Commons committee in 1840 that Dacca, once 'the Manchester of India', had shrunk drastically; the missionary Abbé Dubois described weavers starving in the Madras Presidency; and Bentinck is quoted on the bones of cotton weavers whitening the plains of India.

How deindustrialisation worked

  1. Industrial Revolution in Britain Cheap, durable machine-made cloth.
  2. Duty-free entry into India British goods cheaper than Indian ones.
  3. High duties in Britain Indian cloth shut out of the British market.
  4. Weavers ruined Crafts decline; towns such as Dacca shrink.
  5. Pressure on land Former artisans crowd into agriculture.

Famines and indentured labour

According to the textbook, famines became more frequent and deadly: four between 1800 and 1825, but 22 in the last quarter of the century. It cites R. C. Dutt on the great famines after the 1860s. The colonial state applied laissez-faire (non-intervention) to famines; the Orissa famine of the 1860s, in which the book says one third of the population died, led Dadabhai Naoroji to begin his lifelong study of Indian poverty, and in the Madras famine of 1876-78, after two monsoons failed, Viceroy Lytton took a similar hands-off approach.

Plantations in Ceylon, Mauritius, Fiji, Malaya, the Caribbean, Natal and South Africa needed labour. After slavery was abolished in India in 1843, the indentured system was used: a contract, usually for five years, with a passage home at the end. Agents called kanganis tricked or kidnapped the poor. The book describes it as a penal contract: labourers could lose wages or be jailed for 'negligence', 'insolence' or leaving early, and could not form associations. It records the first group taken from Thanjavur in 1828 to Ceylon's coffee estates, and famines in 1833 and 1843 that drove people to emigrate; Subramania Bharati's song 'Karumbu thottathile' mourns the women on the plantations.

Drain of wealth

In Poverty and Un-British Rule in India, Dadabhai Naoroji contrasted earlier invaders, who plundered and left or settled and spent their wealth in India, with the British, who kept draining it continuously. The main channel was the Home Charges:

  • Dividends to the Company's shareholders.
  • Savings and salaries of European officials, traders and planters sent to England.
  • Pensions of retired civil and military officers.
  • Salaries of the India Office staff in London.
  • Costs of wars, and interest on loans raised for wars and for railways (railway capital carried a guaranteed interest, paid in sterling).

Naoroji argued that if this money had stayed with Indians, India would have progressed economically.

Worked example 1: guaranteed interest (made-up figures)

Question: suppose a railway company raised £2,000,000 in England with the state guaranteeing 5% interest a year, paid in sterling whether or not the line made a profit. What leaves India each year, and over 20 years? Working: 5% of 2,000,000 = 0.05 × 2,000,000 = £100,000 a year; over 20 years, 100,000 × 20 = £2,000,000, the whole original sum. Answer: £100,000 a year; this is the kind of outflow Naoroji counted in the drain.

Worked example 2: linking causes

Question: trace a weaver's path from loom to plantation. Working: (1) cheap British cloth takes his market; (2) he turns to farming on crowded land; (3) heavy revenue demands and a failed monsoon bring famine; (4) a kangani offers a contract in Ceylon. Answer: deindustrialisation, revenue pressure and famine together pushed people into indentured emigration, as the book describes for the 1830s and after.

Drain of wealth (Naoroji): Home Charges - dividends, remitted salaries and savings, pensions, India Office costs, war costs and interest on loans, including guaranteed railway interest - flowed to England without return.

Key takeaways: railways (Bombay-Thane 1853; Royapuram-Arcot 1856) and the telegraph (1854) tightened control; irrigation was neglected except for efforts such as Arthur Cotton's, and forest laws (1865) and the Criminal Tribes Act (1871) hit tribal people. Free entry of British goods ruined Indian weavers. Famines multiplied under a hands-off policy, indentured emigration grew after 1843, and Naoroji's drain theory explained Indian poverty through the Home Charges.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The first railway line in south India, according to the textbook, ran from:

    1. Bombay to Thane
    2. Howrah to Raniganj
    3. Royapuram to Arcot (Wallajah Road)
    4. Madras to Thanjavur
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Bombay-Thane (1853) was the first line in India; in the south the first ran from Royapuram to Arcot (Wallajah Road) in 1856.

  2. 2. Arthur Cotton built a dam across which river in 1836?

    1. Kollidam (Coleroon)
    2. Krishna
    3. Godavari
    4. Vaigai
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The book says Cotton, against much opposition, built a dam across the Kollidam in 1836; work on the Krishna dam began in 1853.

  3. 3. Which pair of laws does the textbook link to colonial forest policy and the control of tribal protest?

    1. Regulating Act, 1773 and Pitt's India Act, 1784
    2. Charter Act, 1813 and Charter Act, 1833
    3. Sati Abolition Act, 1829 and Slavery Act, 1843
    4. Indian Forest Act, 1865 and Criminal Tribes Act, 1871
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Forest Act of 1865 restricted indigenous people's use of forests; to contain their protests the British passed the Criminal Tribes Act of 1871.

  4. 4. Why does the book call indentured labour a penal contract?

    1. Labourers could be fined or jailed for negligence, insolence or leaving before the contract ended
    2. Only convicts were sent abroad
    3. Labourers were paid more than free workers
    4. The contract lasted for life
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Under the system, coolies could forfeit wages or be imprisoned for neglect, disobedience or quitting early, and could not form associations.

  5. 5. Which of these was NOT one of the Home Charges named in the drain theory?

    1. Pensions of retired officers
    2. Interest on loans for wars and railways
    3. Salaries of the India Office staff in London
    4. Grants-in-aid to Indian schools
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Grants-in-aid were spent in India on education. The Home Charges were payments to England: dividends, remitted salaries and savings, pensions, India Office salaries, and war costs and interest.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery