- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Subsidiary Alliance, Doctrine of Lapse and British paramountcy
Explain the terms and results of Wellesley's Subsidiary Alliance, Dalhousie's Doctrine of Lapse and the states it annexed, and how the Company asserted paramountcy over the Mughal emperor and the princes.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the main terms of a subsidiary treaty and its effects on Indian states.
- Explain the Doctrine of Lapse and name the states annexed under it.
- Describe how the Company moved from acting in the emperor's name to claiming paramountcy.
Wars won territory, but the Company also expanded without war. The book highlights two methods: Wellesley's Subsidiary Alliance and Dalhousie's Doctrine of Lapse. Both turned Indian rulers into dependants, and the book notes that they added large areas to the British domain.
Before Wellesley
Earlier, the Company had made alliances in which rulers such as the Nizam and the Nawab of Oudh paid cash subsidies for British troops, who were usually stationed outside the state. Trouble came when payments were late. Wellesley (1798-1805), pursuing a forward policy, widened this into a system.
Terms of the subsidiary treaty
- The ruler disbanded his own army and accepted British forces and a British Resident in his territory.
- He paid for the British army; if he failed, part of his territory was ceded to the Company.
- He cut all links with other European powers, especially the French.
- He employed no European without British permission.
- He negotiated with no other Indian power without the Company's permission.
- In return, the Company protected him: no other power would interfere in his internal affairs.
States brought in, as the book lists them, included Hyderabad, Mysore, Oudh (Lucknow), the Maratha Peshwa, the Bhonsle and Sindhia (Gwalior). (The book writes 'Bhonsle (Kolhapur)'; the Bhonsle ruling house in these treaties was that of Nagpur.) Rulers gave up their sovereignty in political and military matters.
Effects of the Subsidiary Alliance (as the book describes them)
-
For the Company
- Larger, cheaper army paid by the princes
- Control of the states' foreign relations
- Territory gained when payments failed
-
For the princes
- Loss of sovereignty in political and military matters
- Secure on the throne, whatever the people felt
- Little reason to govern well, which invited annexation
-
For society
- Thousands of soldiers disbanded
- Many joined the Pindari marauders
The Company's troops also helped protected rulers put down disorder. In Hyderabad they brought uncontrolled Arab troops to obedience. In Mysore, after a rising in 1830 caused by the raja's finances, Bentinck removed the raja's powers and appointed Mark Cubbon to govern. In Gwalior, quarrels at court and an army out of control led Ellenborough to march in; the state army was beaten at Maharajpur and new limits on its forces were imposed in 1843.
The Doctrine of Lapse
Hindu custom allowed a ruler without a male heir to adopt a son, who could inherit. The question was whether an adopted son could succeed to a dependent state without the consent of the paramount power. Earlier, the practice was to obtain the Company's sanction before or after adoption. Dalhousie held that the paramount power could refuse that sanction, so the state would lapse to the Company.
| State | Event (as in the book) | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Satara | Ruler died in 1848; son adopted just before his death not recognised | First state to be annexed |
| Jhansi | Raja Gangadhar Rao died in November 1853 | Annexed; his widow Rani Lakshmi Bai later led in the rebellion of 1857 |
| Nagpur | Raghuji Bhonsle III died in 1853 without a child | Annexed |
| The Peshwa's pension | Last Peshwa died in 1851 after 33 years as a pensioner | Pension refused to his adopted son, Nana Sahib |
When the Crown took over India in 1858, the Doctrine of Lapse was withdrawn.
Native states and paramountcy
After Plassey the Company at first acted in the name of powerless princes: in theory only the Diwan, in practice the ruler. Step by step it dropped the pretence. It stopped paying the tribute Clive had promised to Shah Alam II; Cornwallis stopped professing obedience in letters to the emperor; Wellesley made subsidiary alliances with Hyderabad, Poona and Mysore. Lord Hastings (Moira), Governor-General from 1813, removed from his seal the phrase acknowledging imperial supremacy and refused to meet Akbar II unless the emperor gave up all authority over Company lands. Yet the book notes that he still held the Company not responsible for how Indian states were run, while close supervision became necessary in areas of many petty chiefs, such as Kathiawar and Central India.
From the emperor's servant to paramount power
- 1765 Company acts as Diwan in the emperor's name.
- Tribute stopped Payment promised by Clive to Shah Alam II discontinued.
- Cornwallis No longer affirms obedience in letters to the emperor.
- Wellesley (1798-1805) Subsidiary alliances with major states.
- Hastings (from 1813) Imperial phrase removed from the seal.
- Dalhousie (1848-1856) Doctrine of Lapse annexes dependent states.
Worked example 1: reading a treaty clause
Question: a ruler under a subsidiary treaty wants to hire a French artillery officer and to sign a friendship pact with a neighbouring raja. Can he? Working: clause (d) forbids employing any European without British permission; clause (e) forbids negotiating with another Indian power without the Company's permission. Answer: neither, unless the Company agrees, which shows how the alliance took away his foreign policy.
Worked example 2: lapse or not?
Question: why could Dalhousie annex Satara but leave a ruler with a natural son alone? Working: the doctrine applied only when a ruler of a dependent state died without a natural male heir and the paramount power refused to recognise an adopted son. A ruler with a natural son gave no opening. Answer: the doctrine worked through the refusal to sanction adoption, not through war.
Subsidiary Alliance (Wellesley): British troops and Resident, paid for by the ruler, no foreign links without consent. Doctrine of Lapse (Dalhousie): no recognition of an adopted heir, so the dependent state lapses; Satara first (1848); withdrawn 1858.
Key takeaways: Wellesley's Subsidiary Alliance made Indian rulers pay for British troops and give up their foreign policy, which strengthened the Company, disbanded armies and fed the Pindaris. Dalhousie's Doctrine of Lapse annexed Satara, Jhansi and Nagpur and ended the Peshwa's pension. Meanwhile the Company stopped acting in the emperor's name and claimed paramountcy over the princes.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under a subsidiary treaty, what happened if the ruler failed to pay for the British troops?
- The troops were withdrawn
- The Mughal emperor paid instead
- A portion of his territory was ceded to the Company
- The ruler was sent to England
Show answer
Answer: C. The ruler had to pay for the British army's maintenance; if he failed, part of his territory was taken and ceded to the British.
-
2. Which result of the Subsidiary Alliance does the textbook link to the growth of the Pindaris?
- The disbanding of thousands of professional soldiers
- The ending of the cartaz
- The abolition of sati
- The building of railways
Show answer
Answer: A. Rulers had to dissolve their armies; the disbanded soldiers turned to freebooting, swelling the Pindari bands.
-
3. Which was the first state annexed under the Doctrine of Lapse?
- Jhansi
- Nagpur
- Mysore
- Satara
Show answer
Answer: D. The book says Satara fell first after its ruler died in 1848 and Dalhousie refused to recognise the son he had adopted on the eve of his death.
-
4. Nana Sahib's grievance arose because Dalhousie:
- annexed Jhansi
- refused to continue the last Peshwa's pension to him
- deposed the raja of Mysore
- defeated the Gwalior army at Maharajpur
Show answer
Answer: B. The last Peshwa had been a Company pensioner for 33 years; when he died in 1851, Dalhousie refused to pay the pension to his son, Nana Sahib.
-
5. Which Governor-General removed from his seal the phrase acknowledging Mughal imperial supremacy?
- Cornwallis
- Wellesley
- Hastings (Moira)
- Dalhousie
Show answer
Answer: C. Hastings (Moira), who became Governor-General in 1813, ordered the phrase removed and refused to meet Akbar II unless he waived authority over Company lands.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.