• Practice
  • About 25 min
  • 5 practice questions

From Aristotle to Newton: inertia, frames and the three laws

Contrast Aristotle's and Galileo's ideas of force, state Newton's three laws, explain the three kinds of inertia and inertial frames, and use F = dp/dt and F = ma as vector laws.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how Galileo's inclined-plane experiment overturned the idea that force is needed to keep a body moving.
  • State Newton's first law and give examples of inertia of rest, motion and direction.
  • Distinguish inertial from non-inertial frames and say when the Earth can be treated as inertial.
  • State the second law as F = dp/dt, reduce it to F = ma, and define the newton.
  • State the third law and explain why action and reaction never cancel each other.

Why do things move, and why do they stop? For centuries the common-sense answer was Aristotle's: a force is needed to keep anything moving. This unit of the Tamil Nadu textbook follows how Galileo and then Newton replaced that idea with three laws that explain motion from a falling mango to an orbiting satellite.

Aristotle and Galileo

Aristotle, more than two thousand years ago, taught that force causes motion, so that a body stops when the force stops. Galileo tested this with experiments. A ball rolled down one smooth inclined plane and up a second facing plane rises to almost the height from which it started. If the second plane is made less steep, the ball travels farther to reach that height. If the second plane is made horizontal, the ball should, in the absence of friction, roll on for ever. So no force is needed to maintain motion: Aristotle coupled force with motion, Galileo decoupled them. A real ball stops because friction, a force opposite to its velocity, acts on it.

Two views of force

  • Aristotle
    • Force is needed to keep a body moving
    • Constant velocity needs a constant push
    • Friction was not considered
  • Galileo and Newton
    • Force is needed only to change motion
    • Constant velocity means zero net force
    • The push balances friction

Newton's first law and inertia

First law: every object continues in its state of rest or of uniform motion (constant velocity) unless an external force acts on it.

Inertia is the inability of a body to change its state by itself. Mass is the measure of inertia. The textbook describes three kinds:

  • Inertia of rest: when a stationary bus starts suddenly, passengers fall backwards, because their bodies tend to stay at rest.
  • Inertia of motion: when a moving bus brakes suddenly, passengers lurch forward, because their bodies tend to keep moving.
  • Inertia of direction: when the string of a whirling stone breaks, the stone flies off along the tangent, because it cannot change direction by itself.

Inertial and non-inertial frames

The first law holds only in special frames called inertial frames: frames in which a body free from all forces stays at rest or moves with constant velocity. In fact the first law defines them. Any frame moving with constant velocity relative to an inertial frame is also inertial. A frame that accelerates is non-inertial: in a train that suddenly speeds up, a ball on a smooth table appears to roll backwards with no force acting on it, which breaks the first law. A rotating frame is also non-inertial. Strictly the Earth is non-inertial (it spins and orbits the Sun), but for everyday motions and laboratory experiments these effects are negligible and the Earth is treated as inertial. For wind patterns and satellite motion the Earth's rotation cannot be ignored.

Newton's second law

Second law: the force on an object equals the rate of change of its momentum, F = dp/dt. For constant mass, F = d(mv)/dt = m dv/dt = ma.

So a force is needed not for motion but for a change in motion. Force and acceleration point the same way. One newton is the force that gives a mass of 1 kg an acceleration of 1 m s⁻² in the direction of the force. The second law, like the first, holds only in inertial frames.

Points the textbook stresses: (1) F = ma is a vector law, equivalent to Fₓ = maₓ, F_y = ma_y, F_z = ma_z, so a force along y cannot change the acceleration along x. (2) The acceleration at an instant depends on the force at that instant, not on earlier forces: once a ball leaves a bowler's hand only gravity and air resistance act, however it was bowled. (3) Force and motion need not be in the same direction: same for a falling apple, different for the Moon in orbit, opposite for a ball thrown upwards; a raindrop falling at terminal velocity has zero net force yet moves. (4) With several forces, the net force F_net = F₁ + F₂ + ... gives the acceleration. (5) F = m d²r/dt²: the second law is a second-order differential equation. (6) If F = 0 the second law gives constant velocity, consistent with the first law, but the two laws are independent. (7) Force is the cause and acceleration the effect, so it is properly written ma = F.

Worked example 1: second law in numbers

(a) A force of 12 N acts on a 3 kg trolley and on a 6 kg trolley. a = F/m gives 4 m s⁻² and 2 m s⁻²: for the same force, acceleration is inversely proportional to mass. (b) A body's momentum rises steadily from 20 kg m s⁻¹ to 50 kg m s⁻¹ in 5 s. F = Δp/Δt = 30/5 = 6 N. (c) A 0.5 kg particle has r = (4t² î + 2t ĵ + k̂) m. Then v = 8t î + 2ĵ and a = 8î m s⁻², so F = ma = 4î N: the net force is along +x only; there is constant velocity along y and no motion along z.

Worked example 2: two forces at once

A 4 kg body is acted on by F₁ = (6î + 2ĵ) N and F₂ = (2î − 8ĵ) N. F_net = 8î − 6ĵ N, of magnitude √(64 + 36) = 10 N. a = F_net/m = 2î − 1.5ĵ m s⁻², of magnitude 2.5 m s⁻², in the direction of the net force.

Newton's third law

Third law: for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. If body 1 exerts F₂₁ on body 2, body 2 exerts F₁₂ = −F₂₁ on body 1, along the line joining them.

Forces always come in pairs; an isolated single force does not exist. The two forces act on different bodies, so they never cancel each other. They act at the same instant (neither is the cause of the other), and the third law holds in inertial and non-inertial frames alike. Examples: a hammer and a nail, a ball bouncing off a wall, and walking, where the foot pushes the ground backwards and the ground pushes the foot forwards. Two spring balances hooked together and pulled show the same reading. A falling apple pulls the Earth with the same force with which the Earth pulls it, but the Earth's enormous mass makes its acceleration negligible.

Key takeaways

  • Galileo showed that force is needed to change motion, not to maintain it.
  • First law: no external force, no change in velocity; inertia is the resistance to that change.
  • The first and second laws hold only in inertial frames; the Earth is nearly inertial for everyday motion.
  • Second law: F = dp/dt = ma, a vector law that acts at each instant.
  • Third law: action and reaction are equal, opposite, simultaneous and act on different bodies.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. When a moving bus stops suddenly, the passengers fall forward. This is due to:

    1. inertia of rest
    2. inertia of direction
    3. inertia of motion
    4. the third law
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The passengers' bodies tend to continue moving forward when the bus stops: inertia of motion. Falling backwards when a bus starts is inertia of rest.

  2. 2. Newton's first law is valid in:

    1. all frames of reference
    2. inertial frames only
    3. rotating frames only
    4. accelerating frames only
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The first law defines inertial frames: frames in which a force-free body moves with constant velocity. In accelerating or rotating frames bodies appear to accelerate without any force.

  3. 3. A force of 15 N acts on a body of mass 2.5 kg. Its acceleration is:

    1. 6 m s⁻²
    2. 37.5 m s⁻²
    3. 0.17 m s⁻²
    4. 12.5 m s⁻²
    Show answer

    Answer: A. a = F/m = 15/2.5 = 6 m s⁻², in the direction of the force.

  4. 4. A book rests on a table. The reaction to the gravitational force of the Earth on the book is:

    1. the normal force of the table on the book
    2. the force of the book on the table
    3. the weight of the table
    4. the gravitational force of the book on the Earth
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Action and reaction act on different bodies and are of the same kind. The Earth pulls the book down; the book pulls the Earth up. The table's normal force acts on the same body (the book), so it is not the reaction to the book's weight.

  5. 5. A raindrop falls at a constant (terminal) velocity. The net force on it is:

    1. equal to its weight, downwards
    2. zero
    3. equal to the air drag, upwards
    4. increasing with time
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Constant velocity means zero acceleration, so by the second law the net force is zero: the upward air drag balances the downward gravity. Motion without net force is allowed.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery