- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Meaning and definitions of the State, and the social contract thinkers
Explain where the word State comes from, why the State is called a natural and necessary institution, compare the classic definitions, and contrast Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the origin of the term State and why the State is called natural and necessary.
- Compare the definitions of the State given by Aristotle, Holland, Burgess and Garner.
- Contrast the views of Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau on human nature, the state of nature and the social contract.
Botany studies plants and sociology studies society. Political Science, the Tamil Nadu textbook says, is the systematic study of the State. We all live in one, and the world is made up of many. When we use the word today we usually mean the modern State, a public order quite different from older ideas of a body of rulers and ruled. So before going further, a student needs to be clear about what the State is and what it is not.
The word and the idea
The idea of the State grew out of the political, cultural, religious and economic history of each region. The modern term state comes from the word status, and the textbook credits Niccolo Machiavelli (1469-1527) with first using the term State in his writings. The textbook calls the State the most universal and most powerful of all social institutions, and a natural institution. Aristotle held that a human being is a social animal and by nature a political being; for him, living in the State and being fully human were the same thing.
Why is the State necessary? Following Aristotle's line of thought, the textbook says it comes into existence to meet the basic needs of life and continues to exist for the sake of the good life. People's aims and hopes are turned into action through it. Yet no two writers agree on how to define it, which, the textbook says, makes its study more creative and interesting.
Why the State exists
- Basic needs of life Security, order, the means to live together.
- The State comes into being A natural institution for social beings.
- The good life The State continues so that people can live well and realise their aims.
Four classic definitions
| Thinker | Definition in brief | What it stresses |
|---|---|---|
| Aristotle | A union of families and villages aiming at a perfect, self-sufficient life, meaning a happy and honourable life | The purpose of the State: the good life |
| Holland | A large body of people, usually on a certain territory, among whom the will of the majority or of a class is made to prevail over those who oppose it | Will and force: someone's will is enforced |
| Burgess | A particular portion of mankind seen as an organised unit | Organisation |
| Garner | A community of people occupying a definite territory, free of external control, with an organised government that people habitually obey | The elements: people, territory, government, independence |
Garner's definition is the most often used in examinations because it contains all four elements of the State that the next lesson explains: population, territory, government and sovereignty (freedom from external control).
The social contract thinkers
One famous attempt to explain the State is the social contract theory, whose three main thinkers, the contractualists, are Thomas Hobbes, John Locke and Jean Jacques Rousseau. They imagined people living in a state of nature before any government, and then agreeing (contracting) to form political authority. All three agree that humans need to be controlled by the State; they disagree on how far that control should go. The textbook summarises them in a table, which we restate here:
Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau as the textbook summarises them
-
Hobbes
- Human nature: man is a wolf to his fellow man
- State of nature: a state of war
- Contract creates the Leviathan, an all-powerful sovereign
-
Locke
- Human nature: man has perfect freedom
- State of nature: property is not secure
- Contract creates a commonwealth to protect rights
-
Rousseau
- Human nature: free but, in the textbook's words, without morality
- State of nature: no security or morality
- Contract creates a State guided by the general will
Hobbes - war - Leviathan; Locke - insecure property - commonwealth; Rousseau - no security or morality - general will.
Worked example 1: identifying the thinker
Statement: 'People were free before government, but their possessions were never safe, so they agreed to set up a body that would protect them.' Reasoning: the key words are freedom and insecure property, and the result is a protective body, not an all-powerful ruler. That matches Locke's state of nature (property not secure) and his commonwealth. Answer: John Locke.
Worked example 2: testing a definition
A made-up island has 50,000 people and a council they obey, but its laws are written and enforced by a foreign power. Is it a State under Garner's definition? Reasoning: it has people, territory and an organised government, but Garner also requires the community to be free of external control. Here a foreign power controls it. Answer: No, it lacks independence, so it is not a State by Garner's test.
Key takeaways: the word state comes from status, and Machiavelli first used it; the State is natural and necessary, existing for life and continuing for the good life. Definitions differ: Aristotle stresses purpose, Holland will, Burgess organisation, Garner the four elements. Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau all agree the State must control people but differ on how much.
Check your understanding
-
1. The modern term 'state' is derived from the word:
- Status
- Statute
- Polis
- Superanus
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says the term state comes from status. Polis is the Greek word behind politics, and superanus is the Latin source of sovereignty.
-
2. Who, according to the textbook, first used the term State in his writings?
- Aristotle
- Jean Bodin
- Niccolo Machiavelli
- Thomas Hobbes
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook credits Niccolo Machiavelli (1469-1527) with first using the term State.
-
3. Which thinker's social contract leads to the Leviathan?
- John Locke
- Jean Jacques Rousseau
- Aristotle
- Thomas Hobbes
Show answer
Answer: D. Hobbes saw the state of nature as a state of war, which people escape by creating the Leviathan, an all-powerful sovereign.
-
4. Which definition of the State includes all four elements: people, territory, organised government and freedom from external control?
- Burgess's definition
- Garner's definition
- Aristotle's definition
- Holland's definition
Show answer
Answer: B. Garner speaks of a community of people on a definite territory, free of external control, with an organised government that people habitually obey.
-
5. On what do Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau agree, according to the textbook?
- Humans need to be controlled by the State, though they differ on how far
- The State should have no power at all
- Property was secure in the state of nature
- The general will should guide the State
Show answer
Answer: A. The three contractualists agree that humans need the State's control; they disagree on its extent. The general will is Rousseau's idea alone, and insecure property is Locke's description.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.