- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Soft State, over-developed State and post-colonial State
Explain Myrdal's idea of the soft State, Hamza Alavi's idea of the over-developed State, and the features and problems of post-colonial States.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain Gunnar Myrdal's concept of the soft State and its main features.
- Explain Hamza Alavi's concept of the over-developed State and why it arises after colonial rule.
- Describe the post-colonial State and the reasons the textbook gives for its problems.
Many countries of South Asia have parliaments, courts, a civil service and elections, institutions very like those of Western States. Yet development has often been slow. Why should similar institutions produce different results? The textbook offers three concepts that scholars have used to answer this question.
The soft State
The Swedish economist Karl Gunnar Myrdal, a Nobel laureate, compared Asian States with Western countries and identified what he called societal indiscipline. He treated this as the mark of a soft State. Its main features are social indiscipline, corruption and weak enforcement of law. The textbook says post-colonial developing States, whose institutions of governance are not fully developed, are generally put in this category, and that a failure to keep standards, enforce laws and maintain discipline makes a country a soft State. Its judgement is that a soft State cannot advance further in refining its democratic values.
Features of a soft State (Myrdal)
-
Social indiscipline
- Rules widely ignored
-
Corruption
- Public power used for private gain
-
Weak law enforcement
- Laws exist but are not applied
The over-developed State
Hamza Alavi (spelled Alawi in the textbook) used the idea of the over-developed State to explain the governance crisis in Pakistan and Bangladesh. The concept explains why post-colonial States work poorly when they keep the same bureaucratic structure before and after independence. Political freedom came, but change did not reach down into administration.
The argument runs like this. The colonial powers of Western Europe kept double standards: at home their States respected citizens' political life, liberty and economic freedom, but in the colonies they built over-centralised States with unquestionable power, which suited the draining of wealth from the colonies. The bureaucracy carried out this exploitation, and after independence it continued the colonial legacy with little change in attitude. When the State machinery becomes highly modernised while society and the economy lag behind, State and society are badly mismatched; a gap opens between people and the State, and decisions are taken by an influential few rather than by the people's representatives. For Pakistan and Bangladesh, Alavi used the term military-bureaucratic oligarchy. The textbook compares the problem of over-centralisation with India's 'licence raj' and says the Government of India has been working on it.
How an over-developed State arises (Alavi's argument)
- Colonial rule Over-centralised State with unquestionable power, built to extract wealth.
- Bureaucracy as instrument Administration carries out colonial control.
- Independence Political liberation, but the same administrative structure continues.
- Mismatch Modernised State machinery, lagging society and economy.
- Rule by a few Decisions by an influential few, such as a military-bureaucratic oligarchy.
The post-colonial State
A post-colonial State is a new nation State that emerged through decolonisation after the Second World War. The term is used as a synonym for a developmental State. It keeps the political institutions of the colonial State, but their objective has shifted: from serving the colonial power to developing the nation. In general, the textbook says, such States show a high degree of poverty, political instability and crisis of governance, largely because a society with traditional power structures overlaps with a modern State. Colonial powers also destroyed many native traditions and cultures and replaced them with their own; after independence this led to conflicts as the new States faced the task of building a national identity and self-confidence. This, the textbook says, is one reason a sharp divide between ruler and ruled remained, with State officials tending to act with an upper hand.
| Concept | Scholar | Core idea |
|---|---|---|
| Soft State | Gunnar Myrdal | Social indiscipline, corruption and weak law enforcement |
| Over-developed State | Hamza Alavi | A colonial, over-centralised administrative structure continues after independence and outgrows society |
| Post-colonial State | General concept in the textbook | New States after decolonisation, with colonial institutions given new developmental goals |
Soft State: rules are not enforced. Over-developed State: the State apparatus is too strong for its society. Post-colonial State: old colonial institutions with new goals.
Worked example 1: diagnosing the concept
In a made-up country, traffic laws, building codes and tax rules all exist on paper, but most people ignore them and officials take bribes to look away. Which concept fits? Reasoning: the laws exist, the problem is indiscipline, corruption and weak enforcement. Answer: Myrdal's soft State.
Worked example 2: diagnosing the concept
In another made-up country, a powerful civil service and army, unchanged since colonial times, take the main decisions, while elected bodies have little say and the economy remains largely rural and traditional. Which concept fits? Reasoning: the State apparatus is highly developed compared with society, inherited from colonial rule, and decisions are taken by a few. Answer: Alavi's over-developed State, with a military-bureaucratic oligarchy.
Key takeaways: Myrdal's soft State is marked by social indiscipline, corruption and weak law enforcement. Alavi's over-developed State arises when an over-centralised colonial administration continues after independence and outgrows society. Post-colonial States, born of decolonisation after the Second World War, keep colonial institutions with new developmental aims and often face poverty, instability and governance crises.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who identified 'societal indiscipline' in Asian States as the mark of a soft State?
- Hamza Alavi
- Gunnar Myrdal
- Immanuel Kant
- John Austin
Show answer
Answer: B. Karl Gunnar Myrdal, a Nobel laureate, described societal indiscipline, corruption and weak law enforcement as features of a soft State.
-
2. Hamza Alavi used the concept of the over-developed State mainly to explain the governance crisis in:
- Scandinavian countries
- Ancient Greece
- Pakistan and Bangladesh
- Western Europe
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says Alavi explained the governability crisis of Pakistan and Bangladesh through this concept, using the term military-bureaucratic oligarchy.
-
3. According to the over-developed State argument, what continued unchanged after independence?
- The colonial bureaucratic structure of governance
- The colonial power's flag
- The traditional village economy only
- The League of Nations
Show answer
Answer: A. The concept explains the poor working of post-colonial States that keep the same bureaucratic structure before and after independence.
-
4. The post-colonial State is used as a synonym for which kind of State?
- Soft State
- City-state
- Totalitarian State
- Developmental State
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says the post-colonial State is used synonymously with the developmental State; its institutions remain but their objective shifts to development.
-
5. Which is NOT listed in the textbook as a general feature of post-colonial States?
- High degree of poverty
- Political instability
- Abundant resources with a small population
- Crisis of governance
Show answer
Answer: C. Poverty, political instability and governance crises are listed. Abundant resources with a small population is what the textbook links with successful welfare States such as those of Scandinavia.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.