- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Society, State and Government: how they are linked and how they differ
Explain how families, communities and society led to the State, describe the three organs of government, and distinguish the State from society and from government.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe how society grew from families and communities and why the State was needed.
- State the roles of the legislature, executive and judiciary in a democracy.
- Distinguish the State from society on purpose, organisation and method.
- Distinguish the State from government on composition, power, permanence and visibility.
In everyday talk people say 'the government', 'the State' and 'society' as if they were the same thing. Political Science insists they are different, and the differences explain a great deal, such as why a government can be voted out while the State goes on.
From family to society to State
When humans moved from hunting and gathering to settled life, they began to produce goods. Individuals lived in families to meet their emotional needs; families came together as a community for greater security; and communities formed a still higher organisation, society. When a society breaks down, the textbook says, the harm spreads to its communities, its families and every individual. So humans, guided by reason, felt the need for the State: without a central, coercive authority people could not be protected from one another.
Stages of social organisation
- Individual Has emotional and material needs.
- Family Meets emotional needs.
- Community Families join for security.
- Society A higher organisation of communities.
- State Central coercive authority to protect people from one another.
In modern States this control is exercised legally, through rules. In a democracy the legislature makes the rules, the executive enforces them, and the judiciary judges laws and their implementation for their legality and fairness. Making, implementing and interpreting laws together form the function of government.
State and society
Society contains many individuals, families, groups and institutions. Early thinkers treated State and society as one, but the textbook says the State is a part of society, not a form of it. Their membership is the same, but they differ in purpose: the State exists for one great purpose, while society exists for many purposes, large and small. The State is a single legal organisation; society contains many organisations. The State controls people by coercion and demands obedience; society works through voluntary action and persuasion, and its many associations let members leave one and join another. A State without coercive authority, or a society without persuasion, the textbook warns, would fall apart.
| Point | State | Society |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Came after society | Prior to the State |
| Scope | Limited | Much wider |
| Territory | Fixed territory | No fixed territory |
| Nature | Political organisation | Social organisation |
| Method | Coercion; can enforce laws | Persuasion; cannot enforce laws |
| Purpose | One great purpose | Many purposes |
State and government
Government is often used as a synonym for the State, but they are different entities.
| Point | State | Government |
|---|---|---|
| Composition | Population, territory, government and sovereignty | One part of the State |
| Powers | Original powers | Powers derived from the State |
| Permanence | Permanent, continues | Temporary; can be changed by the people's will |
| Nature | Abstract and invisible | Concrete and visible |
Governments come and go; the State continues. Government is the visible agent; the State is the abstract whole that gives it power.
Worked example 1: which one changed?
After a general election in a democracy, a new set of ministers takes office in a country. Has the State changed? Reasoning: the population, territory and sovereignty are unchanged; only the people running the government have changed. Government is temporary and replaceable by the people's will; the State is permanent. Answer: the government changed; the State did not.
Worked example 2: State or society?
A neighbourhood cultural club drops a member who breaks its rules; the member simply joins another club. In the same town, a person who refuses to pay a tax is fined by a court. Reasoning: the club is one of many associations in society; it works by persuasion and members can leave. The tax is enforced by law through the courts, which only the State can do by coercion. Answer: the club shows society's method; the fine shows the State's method.
Key takeaways: individuals formed families, communities and society; the State arose as a central coercive authority to protect people. In a democracy the legislature makes laws, the executive enforces them and the judiciary judges them. The State differs from society in scope, territory, nature and method, and from government in composition, power, permanence and visibility.
Check your understanding
-
1. In a democracy, which organ judges laws and their implementation on the basis of legality and fairness?
- The legislature
- The executive
- The judiciary
- Society
Show answer
Answer: C. The legislature makes laws, the executive enforces them, and the judiciary adjudicates on their legality and judiciousness.
-
2. Which statement correctly contrasts the State and society?
- Society has a fixed territory; the State does not
- The State came before society
- Society can enforce laws by coercion
- The State has one great purpose; society has many purposes
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says the State exists for one great purpose while society has many. Society came first, has no fixed territory and cannot enforce laws.
-
3. Which of these is a feature of government rather than of the State?
- It is temporary and can be replaced by the people's will
- It possesses original powers
- It is abstract and invisible
- It includes population and territory
Show answer
Answer: A. Government is temporary, concrete and visible, and its powers come from the State. Original powers, abstractness and the four elements belong to the State.
-
4. According to the textbook, why did humans, guided by reason, feel the need for the State?
- To produce more goods for trade
- Because without a central coercive authority people could not be saved from one another
- To replace families entirely
- To end all voluntary associations
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says the State came into existence because, without a centralised coercive authority, humans could not be protected from each other.
-
5. The textbook says the membership of the State and of society is the same. How then do they mainly differ?
- In the number of people they include
- In their purpose, organisation and method of control
- In the language they use
- They do not differ at all
Show answer
Answer: B. With the same members, they differ in purpose (one versus many), organisation (single legal body versus many organisations) and method (coercion versus persuasion).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.