- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
The essential elements of the State: population, territory, government, sovereignty
Explain the four elements of the State, the 1933 Montevideo Convention, the debate on the ideal population, the meaning of territory, and the nature of sovereignty.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why the Constitution acts as a limit on the State's authority.
- State the requirements of a State under the Montevideo Convention of 1933.
- Explain each of the four elements: population, territory, government and sovereignty.
- Check Plato's ideal number of 5040 and list the characteristics of sovereignty.
A chemist identifies a compound by its elements. A political scientist identifies a State the same way: if one of its four elements is missing, the body in front of you is not a State, however powerful it seems.
The State and its Constitution
The textbook describes the State as a set of institutions with unquestionable authority over people. For this reason every modern State has a Constitution that balances the freedoms and privileges of citizens against the coercive power of the State. The Constitution is therefore seen as a limiting agent on the State's otherwise overwhelming authority.
The Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States (1933) gave a basic test: a State must have a permanent population, a defined territory, and a government able to control the territory and its people and to conduct relations with other States. Because of this last point, recognition by other States is crucial for a State's legitimacy from an external point of view.
Essential elements of the State
-
Population
- People make the State
- No fixed ideal size
-
Territory
- Land, water and air space
- Needed for citizenship
-
Government
- Working agency of the State
- Forms, expresses and carries out its will
-
Sovereignty
- Supreme and final legal authority
- Distinguishes the State from other associations
Population
It is people who make the State. How many people a State should have has been debated since ancient times. Plato put the ideal number at 5040; Aristotle said the population should be neither too large nor too small, large enough to be self-sufficient and small enough to be well governed; Rousseau, according to the textbook, set 10,000 as ideal. These thinkers had small city-states like Athens and Sparta in mind. Modern States vary greatly; the textbook gives India's population as 121.02 crore according to the 2011 Census.
Territory
People need territory to live and to organise themselves socially and politically. A State's territory includes its land, water and air space, and territory is necessary for citizenship. As with population, no fixed size can be laid down: there are small and large States. Prof. Elliott described territorial sovereignty, the State's superiority over everything within its boundaries and its complete freedom from outside control, as a fundamental principle of modern State life. The textbook gives India's area as about 32,87,263 sq km, about 2.4% of the world's area, and notes that the first article of the Indian Constitution deals with the territory of India.
Government
Government is the working agency of the State, its political organisation. The Indian political scientist Prof. A. Appadurai defined it as the agency through which the will of the State is formulated, expressed and realised. C. F. Strong noted that to make and enforce laws the State must have a supreme authority. The textbook describes government as a fixed structure through which the State acts.
Sovereignty
Sovereignty means supreme and final legal authority; no legal power exists above it. The word comes from the Latin superanus, meaning supreme, and the idea developed with the rise of the modern State. Traditionally, sovereignty has six characteristics: absoluteness, permanence, universality, indivisibility, exclusiveness and inalienability. The French thinker Jean Bodin (1530-1597) is called the father of the modern theory of sovereignty. Harold J. Laski said it is the possession of sovereignty that distinguishes the State from all other human associations, such as the family, society or voluntary organisations.
Population + territory + government + sovereignty = State. Remove any one and it is not a State.
Worked example 1: checking Plato's number
The textbook explains Plato's choice of 5040 by its divisibility. Check it. 5040 = 1 × 2 × 3 × 4 × 5 × 6 × 7. Step by step: 1 × 2 = 2; 2 × 3 = 6; 6 × 4 = 24; 24 × 5 = 120; 120 × 6 = 720; 720 × 7 = 5040. So 5040 divides exactly by 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7. It also divides by 8 (5040 ÷ 8 = 630), 9 (5040 ÷ 9 = 560), 10 (504), and 12 (420). For 11: 11 × 458 = 5038, so 5040 ÷ 11 = 458 remainder 2. Answer: 5040 divides exactly by every number from 1 to 12 except 11, which leaves remainder 2, just as the textbook says. The textbook's reason: in an emergency the citizens could be split into many equal groups for instructions.
Worked example 2: is it a State?
Decide for each: (a) a large company with 2 lakh employees, offices and a board whose orders staff obey; (b) a community with a territory and a government, recognised by other States, whose government's decisions are final within its borders. Reasoning: (a) has people and an organisation, but no territory of its own and no sovereignty: the law of the State is above it, and staff can leave. (b) has all four elements, including supreme legal authority. Answer: (a) is an association, not a State; (b) is a State.
Key takeaways: the Constitution limits the State's authority. The Montevideo Convention of 1933 lists population, territory and a capable government, and recognition matters externally. Plato, Aristotle and Rousseau differed on population size; territory includes land, water and air; government carries out the State's will; sovereignty, from superanus, is supreme legal authority, and Bodin is the father of its modern theory.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of the following is regarded as the limiting agent on the authority of the State?
- Religion
- The Constitution
- Public opinion polls
- The army
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says every modern State has a Constitution that balances citizens' freedoms against the State's coercive power, so the Constitution limits the State's authority.
-
2. The word sovereignty comes from the Latin word superanus, which means:
- Status
- City
- Supreme
- People
Show answer
Answer: C. Superanus means supreme. Sovereignty is the supreme and final legal authority of the State.
-
3. Who is called the father of the modern theory of sovereignty?
- Harold Laski
- Hugo Grotius
- Prof. Elliott
- Jean Bodin
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook names the French thinker Jean Bodin (1530-1597). Laski explained that sovereignty distinguishes the State from other associations.
-
4. 5040 is divisible exactly by every whole number from 1 to 12 except one. Which one, and what is the remainder?
- 11, remainder 2
- 9, remainder 1
- 12, remainder 4
- 7, remainder 3
Show answer
Answer: A. 11 × 458 = 5038, and 5040 - 5038 = 2. The others divide exactly: 5040 ÷ 9 = 560, 5040 ÷ 12 = 420, 5040 ÷ 7 = 720.
-
5. Which element of the State does the textbook link most directly with citizenship, and include land, water and air space in?
- Territory
- Government
- Sovereignty
- Population
Show answer
Answer: A. Territory includes land, water and air space, and the textbook says territory is necessary for citizenship.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.