Revision notes

Unit 2 State: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Meaning and definitions of the State, and the social contract thinkers

Why the State exists

  1. Basic needs of life Security, order, the means to live together.
  2. The State comes into being A natural institution for social beings.
  3. The good life The State continues so that people can live well and realise their aims.
Definitions of the State (paraphrased)
ThinkerDefinition in briefWhat it stresses
AristotleA union of families and villages aiming at a perfect, self-sufficient life, meaning a happy and honourable lifeThe purpose of the State: the good life
HollandA large body of people, usually on a certain territory, among whom the will of the majority or of a class is made to prevail over those who oppose itWill and force: someone's will is enforced
BurgessA particular portion of mankind seen as an organised unitOrganisation
GarnerA community of people occupying a definite territory, free of external control, with an organised government that people habitually obeyThe elements: people, territory, government, independence

Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau as the textbook summarises them

  • Hobbes
    • Human nature: man is a wolf to his fellow man
    • State of nature: a state of war
    • Contract creates the Leviathan, an all-powerful sovereign
  • Locke
    • Human nature: man has perfect freedom
    • State of nature: property is not secure
    • Contract creates a commonwealth to protect rights
  • Rousseau
    • Human nature: free but, in the textbook's words, without morality
    • State of nature: no security or morality
    • Contract creates a State guided by the general will

Hobbes - war - Leviathan; Locke - insecure property - commonwealth; Rousseau - no security or morality - general will.

— Memory chain

Key takeaways: the word state comes from status, and Machiavelli first used it; the State is natural and necessary, existing for life and continuing for the good life. Definitions differ: Aristotle stresses purpose, Holland will, Burgess organisation, Garner the four elements. Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau all agree the State must control people but differ on how much.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

The essential elements of the State: population, territory, government, sovereignty

Essential elements of the State

  • Population
    • People make the State
    • No fixed ideal size
  • Territory
    • Land, water and air space
    • Needed for citizenship
  • Government
    • Working agency of the State
    • Forms, expresses and carries out its will
  • Sovereignty
    • Supreme and final legal authority
    • Distinguishes the State from other associations

Population + territory + government + sovereignty = State. Remove any one and it is not a State.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: the Constitution limits the State's authority. The Montevideo Convention of 1933 lists population, territory and a capable government, and recognition matters externally. Plato, Aristotle and Rousseau differed on population size; territory includes land, water and air; government carries out the State's will; sovereignty, from superanus, is supreme legal authority, and Bodin is the father of its modern theory.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Society, State and Government: how they are linked and how they differ

Stages of social organisation

  1. Individual Has emotional and material needs.
  2. Family Meets emotional needs.
  3. Community Families join for security.
  4. Society A higher organisation of communities.
  5. State Central coercive authority to protect people from one another.
State and society compared
PointStateSociety
OriginCame after societyPrior to the State
ScopeLimitedMuch wider
TerritoryFixed territoryNo fixed territory
NaturePolitical organisationSocial organisation
MethodCoercion; can enforce lawsPersuasion; cannot enforce laws
PurposeOne great purposeMany purposes
State and government compared
PointStateGovernment
CompositionPopulation, territory, government and sovereigntyOne part of the State
PowersOriginal powersPowers derived from the State
PermanencePermanent, continuesTemporary; can be changed by the people's will
NatureAbstract and invisibleConcrete and visible

Governments come and go; the State continues. Government is the visible agent; the State is the abstract whole that gives it power.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: individuals formed families, communities and society; the State arose as a central coercive authority to protect people. In a democracy the legislature makes laws, the executive enforces them and the judiciary judges them. The State differs from society in scope, territory, nature and method, and from government in composition, power, permanence and visibility.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

The modern State, its functions and the welfare State

How the modern State took shape

  1. Modernity Questioning tradition; individualism, freedom, equality, scientific temper.
  2. Treaty of Westphalia, 1648 Often taken as the rational foundation of the modern State.
  3. Spread by colonisation Exported worldwide in the nineteenth century.
  4. Post-colonial States New States after the Second World War, including those of South Asia.
Three main functions of the modern State
FunctionWhat it includes
Security and defenceSecurity seen from many angles, including human security that puts citizens first; inspired by Immanuel Kant's idea of perpetual peace, States formed the League of Nations and later the United Nations to promote peace
Economic functionsIntervening in the economy to help people realise their potential: protecting consumers and weaker sections, and investing where there is no profit
Provision of essential servicesCare 'from cradle to grave': food, clean drinking water, education, health care and social security

Welfare State = equality of opportunity + fair distribution of wealth + public care for those who cannot provide for themselves.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: modernity questioned tradition and valued individualism, freedom, equality and science; the Treaty of Westphalia (1648) is often seen as the base of the modern State, which colonisation spread. The modern State's functions are security and defence, economic functions and essential services. The welfare State arose in post-war Western Europe; India's Directive Principles in Part IV reflect it.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Soft State, over-developed State and post-colonial State

Features of a soft State (Myrdal)

  • Social indiscipline
    • Rules widely ignored
  • Corruption
    • Public power used for private gain
  • Weak law enforcement
    • Laws exist but are not applied

How an over-developed State arises (Alavi's argument)

  1. Colonial rule Over-centralised State with unquestionable power, built to extract wealth.
  2. Bureaucracy as instrument Administration carries out colonial control.
  3. Independence Political liberation, but the same administrative structure continues.
  4. Mismatch Modernised State machinery, lagging society and economy.
  5. Rule by a few Decisions by an influential few, such as a military-bureaucratic oligarchy.
Three concepts compared
ConceptScholarCore idea
Soft StateGunnar MyrdalSocial indiscipline, corruption and weak law enforcement
Over-developed StateHamza AlaviA colonial, over-centralised administrative structure continues after independence and outgrows society
Post-colonial StateGeneral concept in the textbookNew States after decolonisation, with colonial institutions given new developmental goals

Soft State: rules are not enforced. Over-developed State: the State apparatus is too strong for its society. Post-colonial State: old colonial institutions with new goals.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: Myrdal's soft State is marked by social indiscipline, corruption and weak law enforcement. Alavi's over-developed State arises when an over-centralised colonial administration continues after independence and outgrows society. Post-colonial States, born of decolonisation after the Second World War, keep colonial institutions with new developmental aims and often face poverty, instability and governance crises.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery