Why the State exists
- Basic needs of life Security, order, the means to live together.
- The State comes into being A natural institution for social beings.
- The good life The State continues so that people can live well and realise their aims.
| Thinker | Definition in brief | What it stresses |
|---|---|---|
| Aristotle | A union of families and villages aiming at a perfect, self-sufficient life, meaning a happy and honourable life | The purpose of the State: the good life |
| Holland | A large body of people, usually on a certain territory, among whom the will of the majority or of a class is made to prevail over those who oppose it | Will and force: someone's will is enforced |
| Burgess | A particular portion of mankind seen as an organised unit | Organisation |
| Garner | A community of people occupying a definite territory, free of external control, with an organised government that people habitually obey | The elements: people, territory, government, independence |
Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau as the textbook summarises them
-
Hobbes
- Human nature: man is a wolf to his fellow man
- State of nature: a state of war
- Contract creates the Leviathan, an all-powerful sovereign
-
Locke
- Human nature: man has perfect freedom
- State of nature: property is not secure
- Contract creates a commonwealth to protect rights
-
Rousseau
- Human nature: free but, in the textbook's words, without morality
- State of nature: no security or morality
- Contract creates a State guided by the general will
Hobbes - war - Leviathan; Locke - insecure property - commonwealth; Rousseau - no security or morality - general will.
Key takeaways: the word state comes from status, and Machiavelli first used it; the State is natural and necessary, existing for life and continuing for the good life. Definitions differ: Aristotle stresses purpose, Holland will, Burgess organisation, Garner the four elements. Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau all agree the State must control people but differ on how much.