- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Equality: meaning, importance, dimensions and types
Explain what equality means and why it matters, distinguish natural from social inequality, state the views of Laski and Barker, and describe social, civil, political, economic and educational equality.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the meaning of equality and its link with fair distribution and justice.
- Explain why equality became a powerful political ideal.
- State the negative and positive aspects of equality and the views of Laski and Barker.
- Distinguish natural from social inequality and describe five types of equality.
Laws in many countries promise that everyone is equal. Yet in the same city we can see slums beside luxury flats, and schools without toilets beside schools with swimming pools. The textbook asks students to think about this gap between what law promises and what we see, because that gap is what the idea of equality is about.
Meaning of equality
Equality means the state of being equal. The word comes from the Latin aequalis, linked with fairness. It signifies having the same rights, privileges, treatment, status and opportunities. The textbook treats equality as a distributive principle: it decides how rights, treatment and opportunities are shared out among people, fairly. Fairness does not mean treating everyone identically in every situation; it can mean unequal treatment for those who are unequal. So equality is tied to justice. Distributive justice may require unequal distribution to achieve equality; for example, the State should not tax the poor and the rich at the same level.
Why equality matters
As a political ideal, equality holds that all human beings have equal worth regardless of colour, gender, race or nationality, and deserve equal respect because of their common humanity. This belief led to the declaration of universal human rights. In the modern period equality became a slogan against States and institutions that upheld inequalities of rank, wealth, status or privilege. In the eighteenth century the French revolutionaries used the slogan Liberty, Equality and Fraternity against the feudal aristocracy and monarchy; the demand for equality was raised in the anti-colonial struggles of Asia and Africa in the twentieth century; and the textbook notes it is still raised by groups such as women and Dalits who feel marginalised.
Dimensions of equality
No society treats all its members the same way in all circumstances, because people differ in wants, capacities and needs. The textbook stresses that injustice comes as much from treating unequals equally as from treating equals unequally. It also observes that as one inequality is removed another often appears, so each generation must reinforce and reinterpret equality. Like liberty, equality has two aspects: negative, the end of special privileges, and positive, the availability of opportunities.
Laski and Barker on equality
-
Laski
- Absence of special privileges; equal rights
- Adequate opportunities open to all
- Access to social benefits for all; inequality by birth is unreasonable
- Absence of economic and social exploitation
-
Barker
- Fundamental equality of all
- Equality of opportunity
- Equality of conditions of life
- Equality of outcome or results
Natural and social inequality. Natural inequalities arise from the different abilities and talents people are born with. Social inequalities are created by society, through unequal opportunity or the exploitation of some groups by others: unequal treatment by race, colour, gender or caste. Women were denied equal rights for centuries, and Black people were enslaved until slavery was challenged. The textbook adds that technology now lets people with disabilities contribute fully, citing the physicist Stephen Hawking.
Types of equality
| Type | Meaning | Key points |
|---|---|---|
| Social | No discrimination in rights, privileges and opportunities on the basis of birth, caste, religion, race, colour, gender or status | Removing status-based discrimination, ending special privileges, equal access to education; the UN declaration of 10 December 1948 stressed it |
| Civil | Equal civil rights and liberties for every citizen (civil from Latin civis, citizen) | Civil laws treat all alike, with no superior and inferior; linked to the rule of law |
| Political | Equal right of all citizens to take part in the affairs of the State | Universal adult franchise; rights to vote, contest elections, hold public office, petition and criticise policy |
| Economic | Reasonable opportunities for all to develop fully | Scope for employment, fair wages, leisure, a share in managing the economy |
| Of opportunity and education | Equal and similar chances for all citizens, especially to receive education | Remove discrimination by race, caste, religion, language, wealth or gender |
The textbook calls political equality the test of democracy, but adds that it is not enough by itself: socio-economic equality is also needed. It quotes Laski's view that political equality is never real without economic liberty, because political power otherwise serves economic power, and states its own judgement that economic equality is ideologically possible in socialism rather than capitalism. It also recalls the civil rights movement led by Martin Luther King Jr. in the United States in the 1950s and 1960s, and Dr. B. R. Ambedkar's movement for the liberation of Dalits in India, as historic struggles for equality.
Equality is not identical treatment. Treating unequals equally can be as unjust as treating equals unequally.
Worked example 1: is unequal treatment fair?
A made-up State charges no income tax on earnings up to ₹3 lakh and 20% on income above that. Rani earns ₹2 lakh; Arun earns ₹10 lakh. Rani pays ₹0. Arun pays 20% of (₹10 lakh − ₹3 lakh) = 20% of ₹7 lakh = ₹1.4 lakh. Does this violate equality? Reasoning: they are treated differently because their capacity to pay differs. The textbook says distributive justice may require unequal distribution, and the State should not tax rich and poor equally. Answer: No; this is equality in the sense of fair distribution.
Worked example 2: natural or social inequality?
(a) Two sprinters differ in speed because of natural build; (b) a village bars a group from a common well because of caste. Reasoning: (a) comes from abilities people are born with; (b) is created by society through discrimination. Answer: (a) natural inequality; (b) social inequality, which social and civil equality seek to remove.
Key takeaways: equality means the same rights, status and opportunities, distributed fairly, which can require unequal treatment. It rests on equal human worth and drove the French Revolution and anti-colonial struggles. It has negative (no privilege) and positive (opportunity) aspects. Social inequalities are made by society; the types of equality are social, civil, political, economic, and of opportunity and education.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement best describes equality as the textbook explains it?
- Treating every person identically in every situation
- Giving the same tax rate to rich and poor
- A distributive principle that shares rights and opportunities fairly, which may need unequal treatment of unequals
- Removing all natural differences between people
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says equality is a distributive principle; fairness does not mean identical treatment, and distributive justice may need unequal distribution, such as not taxing rich and poor equally.
-
2. The slogan Liberty, Equality and Fraternity is associated with:
- The French revolutionaries of the eighteenth century
- The Glorious Revolution of 1688
- The American civil rights movement
- The Treaty of Westphalia
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says the French revolutionaries used this slogan against the feudal aristocracy and monarchy.
-
3. Which of the following is a social inequality rather than a natural one?
- Differences in height
- Differences in musical talent people are born with
- Differences in natural speed
- Unequal treatment based on caste or gender
Show answer
Answer: D. Social inequalities are created by society, such as discrimination by race, colour, gender or caste. The others arise from abilities people are born with.
-
4. Which is part of Barker's account of equality but not of Laski's list in the textbook?
- Absence of special privileges
- Equality of outcome or results
- Absence of exploitation
- Access to social benefits for all
Show answer
Answer: B. Barker lists fundamental equality, equality of opportunity, equality of conditions and equality of outcome. The other three are on Laski's list.
-
5. The rights to vote, contest elections and hold public office belong to which type of equality?
- Political equality
- Civil equality
- Economic equality
- Natural equality
Show answer
Answer: A. Political equality is the equal right of citizens to take part in State affairs, ensured by universal adult franchise and these rights.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.