• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Liberty: meaning, kinds, law and safeguards

Trace the historical struggle for liberty, explain its meaning and its positive and negative sides, describe its kinds, show how law protects it, and list its safeguards.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Outline the historical struggle for liberty in England, France and the colonies.
  • Explain the meaning of liberty and the views of Laski, Gettel, Cole and Gandhi.
  • Distinguish positive and negative liberty and describe the kinds of liberty.
  • Explain how law protects liberty and list the safeguards of liberty.

Liberty is one of the most fought-for ideas in history. The textbook shows that it was not handed down by rulers but won in long struggles, and that, perhaps surprisingly, it depends on law rather than on the absence of law.

The struggle for liberty

Milestones in the struggle for liberty (as the textbook outlines it)

  1. Medieval England Revolt against absolute monarchy; King John forced to guarantee freedoms (Magna Carta, 1215).
  2. Civil war Continued absolutism under later rulers led to civil war and the execution of King Charles I.
  3. Glorious Revolution, 1688 Absolute monarchy contained in England.
  4. French Revolution, 1789 Did not bring lasting liberty at once; France passed through several republics to the Fifth Republic (1958).
  5. Colonial freedom struggles Italy in the nineteenth century and India in the twentieth made great sacrifices for national liberty.

Meaning of liberty

The word liberty comes from the Latin liber, meaning free, the absence of all restraints. Taken literally this would mean doing whatever one likes. But political thinkers define liberty more carefully, usually as freedom from arbitrary or undue external restraint. Laski described liberty as the eager maintenance of an atmosphere in which people have the opportunity to be their best selves, and held that there can be no liberty without rights. Gettel called it the positive power of doing and enjoying things worth doing; G. D. H. Cole, the freedom of the individual to express his personality without external hindrance; and Mahatma Gandhi held that liberty lies not in the absence of restraint but in the development of personality.

Two sides of liberty

  • Negative liberty
    • Associated in the textbook with J. S. Mill
    • No restraint on a person's actions
    • No hindrance in a person's path
  • Positive liberty
    • Freedom to do something
    • The individual has rights and opportunities
    • Aims at developing personality

Kinds of liberty

Kinds of liberty
KindMeaning
NaturalAbsence of all restraint, unrestrained freedom to do whatever one likes
CivilEnjoying rights within the limits of law; reflects the rule of law and is guaranteed by the State's laws
PoliticalTaking part in political life: voting, contesting elections, holding public views, criticising government, petitioning
PersonalActing without arbitrary restraint in personal matters such as dress, food, way of life, marriage and children's education
EconomicLiberty to earn one's daily bread by fair means, regardless of caste, colour, creed or gender
FiscalNo taxation without representation: people decide how their money is spent
DomesticEqual rights for women and children; protection from cruelty and exploitation; right to education
NationalLiberty of the country: the nation is independent and sovereign
InternationalPeace, international cooperation and a world federation of states

Liberty, sovereignty and law

Liberty exists only in a State where there is order. The sovereign State acts through laws, so liberty, sovereignty and law are closely related. John Locke put it as: where there is no law, there is no freedom. Law protects liberty in three ways: it punishes criminals and defends individuals' rights; it guarantees the enjoyment of rights and punishes those who harm others; and the Constitution, as custodian of liberty, limits the State's authority and protects fundamental rights.

Safeguards of liberty

  1. Democracy: liberty is safer in a democracy than in any other form of government, and opponents are respected.
  2. Constitution: the State's authority rests in it; the textbook calls the Preamble the soul of the Indian Constitution, a standard to judge laws and government actions.
  3. Fundamental Rights: they limit the State; in India, equality (14-18), freedom (19-22), against exploitation (23-24), freedom of religion (25-28), cultural and educational rights (29-30), and constitutional remedies (32).
  4. Decentralisation of power: dividing power among central, provincial and local governments.
  5. Independent judiciary: free from executive control; in India, impartial appointment, high qualifications, and fixed retirement ages (65 for Supreme Court judges, 62 for High Court judges).
  6. Economic security: without it, rich and poor stand as master and servant (Laski).
  7. Rule of law: no distinction of caste, creed, colour or race; all equal before law.
  8. Political education and eternal vigilance: educated citizens know their rights and resist when government oversteps.

Liberty is not the absence of all restraint, but freedom from arbitrary restraint. Where there is no law, there is no freedom (Locke).

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: naming the kind of liberty

Classify: (a) a citizen writes a letter in a newspaper criticising a government policy; (b) a woman chooses her own career and what to wear; (c) traders refuse to pay a new tax imposed by a body in which they have no representatives. Reasoning: (a) is participation in public affairs, political liberty; (b) is personal matters free from arbitrary restraint, personal liberty; (c) is the principle of no taxation without representation, fiscal liberty. Answer: (a) political, (b) personal, (c) fiscal.

Worked example 2: does law reduce liberty?

Someone argues that traffic laws reduce liberty because drivers must stop at red lights. Reasoning: natural liberty, doing whatever one likes, would let every driver go at once, and nobody could cross safely. Traffic law restrains everyone equally and in a reasoned way, so that all can travel; this is civil liberty, rights enjoyed within the limits of law. As Locke said, where there is no law there is no freedom. Answer: reasonable law protects liberty; only arbitrary restraint destroys it.

Key takeaways: liberty was won through long struggles, from medieval England to the freedom movements. Liberty comes from liber; politically it means freedom from arbitrary restraint. Mill's negative liberty means no restraint; positive liberty means rights and opportunities to develop. There are many kinds of liberty. Law protects liberty, and it is safeguarded by democracy, the Constitution, Fundamental Rights, decentralisation, an independent judiciary, economic security, the rule of law and vigilance.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The word liberty is derived from the Latin word:

    1. Superanus
    2. Aequalis
    3. Civis
    4. Liber
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Liberty comes from liber, meaning free. Superanus gives sovereignty, aequalis equality and civis civil.

  2. 2. The textbook associates negative liberty, meaning no restraint on a person's actions, with:

    1. J. S. Mill
    2. G. D. H. Cole
    3. Mahatma Gandhi
    4. Gettel
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says that for J. S. Mill liberty means negative liberty: no restraint should be imposed on a person and his actions.

  3. 3. 'No taxation without representation' is the principle of which kind of liberty?

    1. Domestic liberty
    2. National liberty
    3. Fiscal liberty
    4. Natural liberty
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Fiscal liberty means people should decide how and on whom their money is spent, so there should be no taxation without representation.

  4. 4. Who said, in substance, that where there is no law there is no freedom?

    1. Jean Bodin
    2. John Locke
    3. John Austin
    4. Lord Acton
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook quotes John Locke. The idea is that law creates the order within which liberty can exist.

  5. 5. Which of these is NOT listed in the textbook as a safeguard of liberty?

    1. Independent judiciary
    2. Decentralisation of power
    3. Rule of law
    4. Concentration of all power in the executive
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Safeguards include democracy, the Constitution, Fundamental Rights, decentralisation, an independent judiciary, economic security, rule of law and vigilance. Concentrating power in the executive endangers liberty.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery