• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Kinds of sovereignty, monism and pluralism

Distinguish nominal and real, legal, political, popular, de facto and de jure sovereignty; compare Austin's monistic theory with pluralism; and see where sovereignty lies under the Indian Constitution.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain nominal and real, legal, political and popular sovereignty.
  • Distinguish de facto from de jure sovereignty with historical examples.
  • Compare the monistic theory of John Austin with the pluralist theory and its criticisms.
  • Explain where sovereignty lies under the Indian Constitution.

To say a State is sovereign does not tell us who actually holds that supreme power. Is it the king, the parliament, the voters, or whoever controls the army? The kinds of sovereignty answer this question in different ways.

Types of sovereignty

Kinds of sovereignty (summarised from the textbook)
KindMeaningExample or note
Nominal and realNominal sovereign holds the title; real sovereign holds actual powerAncient kings were real sovereigns; after changes begun by the French Revolution, in parliamentary systems the council of ministers became the real sovereign and the king nominal
LegalThe authority with legal power to issue and enforce final commands (laws)Always definite and determinate; its authority is absolute and supreme in law
PoliticalIn a representative democracy, the mass of the people: the electorate or public opinionThe influence behind the legal sovereign
PopularThe people as supremeHistorically used as a weapon against the absolutism of monarchs

Dr. Garner cautioned that popular sovereignty can mean no more than the power of the majority of the electorate, where nearly universal suffrage exists, acting through legally established channels to express and enforce its will.

De facto and de jure sovereignty

De jure and de facto

  • De jure sovereign
    • Has a legal claim to sovereignty
    • May not actually hold power
    • De jure = according to law
  • De facto sovereign
    • Has no legal claim
    • Actually holds power and uses force to make and enforce laws
    • De facto = in fact

The textbook's historical examples: Napoleon became de facto sovereign after overthrowing the Directory in France. Mussolini, after the Blackshirts' march on Rome in October 1922, became prime minister in a legal manner and ruled through parliament: parliament remained the legal sovereign, but he was the actual, de facto sovereign. Hitler did the same in Germany, controlling the legal sovereign. The textbook also mentions Franco in Spain as a de facto sovereign who displaced the legal authority.

Monism and pluralism

The monistic theory holds that sovereignty is one, supreme and unlimited, located in a single determinate authority. Its greatest exponent is the English jurist John Austin (1780-1859), who set out the legal theory of sovereignty in his Lectures on Jurisprudence (1832).

Pluralism is a powerful protest against this monistic view. Its exponents, as the textbook lists them, are Harold J. Laski, J. N. Figgis, Ernest Barker, G. D. H. Cole and MacIver. The textbook explains its rise: with the welfare State, the State's functions grew so fast that no area of life was left untouched, and the supreme State met revolt and reaction. Pluralists stress the importance of associations (such as trade unions, churches and professional bodies) and claim more autonomy for them; the State, in this view, should settle disputes between groups in a way that serves everyone's interests, rather than stand above them all.

Pluralism and its critics
Pluralist claimCriticism in the textbook
Associations are important and deserve autonomyIt is the sovereign State that brings unity and regulates all associations
Sovereignty should be shared among groupsDividing sovereignty destroys it, and without sovereignty anarchy follows
Groups, not only the State, shape rulesLaws are framed by the State, not by associations
The all-powerful State threatens freedomThe State is needed to protect people from the excesses of associations

Sovereignty and the Indian Constitution

The textbook notes that in Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975) the Supreme Court treated India as a sovereign democratic republic as one of the essential elements of the basic structure of the Constitution. The Preamble makes the people sovereign. Put simply, sovereignty lies in the Constitution, and the people are the ultimate source of the Constitution.

Legal sovereign makes the law; political sovereign (the electorate) influences it; de facto sovereign holds power in fact; de jure sovereign holds it by law.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: naming the kind

In a made-up parliamentary democracy, the President signs all laws, the Cabinet decides policy, Parliament passes the laws and the voters choose Parliament. Identify the nominal, real, legal and political sovereign. Reasoning: the President holds the title but acts on advice, so is nominal; the Cabinet exercises real power; Parliament, with the law-making authority, is the legal sovereign; the electorate, whose opinion shapes Parliament, is the political sovereign. Answer: nominal: President; real: Cabinet; legal: Parliament; political: the electorate.

Worked example 2: de facto or de jure?

In a made-up country an army general seizes the capital and issues orders that everyone obeys, while the lawfully elected government flees abroad and still claims to rule. Reasoning: the general has no legal claim but actually holds power and enforces orders, so he is de facto sovereign. The government in exile has the legal claim but no actual power, so it is de jure sovereign. Answer: general: de facto; exiled government: de jure.

Key takeaways: sovereignty may be nominal or real, legal, political or popular, de facto or de jure. Austin's monistic theory places one supreme sovereign; pluralists such as Laski, Figgis, Barker, Cole and MacIver defend the autonomy of associations, and critics reply that dividing sovereignty leads to anarchy. Under the Indian Constitution the people are sovereign, and the sovereign democratic republic is part of the basic structure.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who is regarded as the greatest exponent of the monistic theory of sovereignty?

    1. Harold J. Laski
    2. John Austin
    3. J. N. Figgis
    4. MacIver
    Show answer

    Answer: B. John Austin, the English jurist, set out the legal (monistic) theory in Lectures on Jurisprudence (1832). Laski, Figgis and MacIver are pluralists.

  2. 2. One who has a legal claim to sovereignty but does not actually possess power is the:

    1. De facto sovereign
    2. Political sovereign
    3. Real sovereign
    4. De jure sovereign
    Show answer

    Answer: D. De jure means according to law: the de jure sovereign has the legal claim but may lack power. The de facto sovereign holds power in fact.

  3. 3. In a representative democracy, political sovereignty is understood as:

    1. The whole mass of the people: the electorate or public opinion
    2. The king alone
    3. The judiciary
    4. The army
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says political sovereignty in a representative democracy is the electorate or public opinion, which influences the legal sovereign.

  4. 4. According to the textbook, what gave rise to pluralism?

    1. The decline of associations
    2. The rapid growth of State functions under the welfare State, which met revolt and reaction
    3. The French Revolution's abolition of parliaments
    4. Austin's lectures of 1832
    Show answer

    Answer: B. With the welfare State the State interfered in every sphere of life, and the reaction against the supreme State led to pluralism.

  5. 5. Mussolini became prime minister legally and ruled through parliament, which stayed the legal sovereign. In the textbook's terms, Mussolini was the:

    1. Nominal sovereign
    2. Popular sovereign
    3. De facto sovereign
    4. De jure sovereign only
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Parliament remained the legal sovereign, but Mussolini held actual power, so the textbook calls him the actual or de facto sovereign.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery