• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Liberty and equality, ideologies of equality, and equality in the Indian Constitution

Explain how liberty and equality are related, the methods of promoting equality, how major ideologies view equality, and the equality provisions of the Indian Constitution.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the debate on liberty and equality, including laissez faire and the rise of socialism, as the textbook presents it.
  • List three methods of promoting equality.
  • Summarise how different ideologies view equality, following Andrew Heywood.
  • State the equality provisions of Articles 14 to 18 and the link with Article 21.

Is freedom worth much to a person who has no food, no job and no schooling? This question links the two great values of modern politics, liberty and equality. Some thinkers saw them as rivals; the textbook presents the view that they need each other.

Liberty and equality

The textbook opens with the claim that liberty has no value without equality, and notes that thinkers such as Lord Acton, Alexis de Tocqueville and Harold J. Laski saw the relation differently; Acton and Tocqueville were ardent advocates of liberty. Laski remarked that wherever there are rich and poor, educated and uneducated, we find a relation of master and servant.

The textbook then tells the story of laissez faire, an economic system in which dealings between private parties are free from government intervention such as regulation, privileges, tariffs and subsidies. Adam Smith supported this view, and individualists wanted free competition and no government role in the economy; demand and supply was expected to solve economic problems. According to the textbook, the result in Europe was harsh: capitalists exploited the opportunity, the gap between rich and poor widened, workers suffered most, and the reaction against individualism gave rise to socialism. The textbook's conclusion is that liberty is meaningless without economic equality, that economic equality is essential for political freedom, and, in its words, that liberty and equality go together in a socialistic democracy. It cites Pollard: the only solution to the problem of liberty lies in equality, so the two are complementary.

The textbook's account of laissez faire and its reaction

  1. Laissez faire No government role; free competition; demand and supply.
  2. Exploitation Gap between rich and poor widened; workers worst affected.
  3. Reaction Socialism rose against individualism.
  4. Lesson drawn Liberty needs economic equality; the two are complementary.

How equality can be promoted

  1. Establishing formal equality: the same laws and rights for everyone.
  2. Equality through differential treatment: sometimes people must be treated differently so that they can enjoy equal rights.
  3. Affirmative action: policies to overcome barriers to equality; the textbook notes that India follows the principle of reservation while other countries use affirmative action.

Ideologies and equality (after Andrew Heywood)

How ideologies view equality, as summarised in the textbook
IdeologyView of equality
LiberalsPeople are born of equal moral worth; support formal (legal and political) equality and equality of opportunity, but fear social equality costs freedom and penalises talent
ConservativesSee society as naturally hierarchical; dismiss equality as abstract and unachievable
SocialistsEquality is a fundamental value, especially social equality, seen as essential for cohesion, justice and positive freedom
AnarchistsStress political equality as an equal right to personal autonomy; anarcho-communists seek absolute social equality through collective ownership
FascistsBelieve humankind is marked by racial inequality, yet treat members of the nation or race as equal in core identity
FeministsEquality means sexual equality: equal rights and opportunities, or equal social and economic power, regardless of gender
EcologistsBiocentric equality: all life forms have an equal right to live and flourish

Equality in the Indian Constitution

The Preamble seeks equality of status and of opportunity. The Right to Equality (Articles 14-18) gives it legal form:

Right to Equality
ArticleProvision
14Equality before law and equal protection of laws for all persons
15Prohibition of discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth
16Equality of opportunity in matters of public employment
17Abolition of untouchability
18Abolition of titles

Article 14 is a statement of formal equality: the laws apply to all equally, without discrimination on grounds such as birth, caste, colour, gender, language, race or religion, and Article 15 reinforces it. The textbook adds that Article 21, which says no person shall be deprived of life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law, strengthens equality before law: the procedure must be reasonable, fair and just, with no arbitrariness or unequal treatment.

Formal equality treats all alike in law (Article 14); differential treatment and affirmative action help those held back reach real equality.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: identifying the method

A made-up State gives students from very poor families free coaching and extra scholarship marks for professional courses, while keeping the same examination for everyone. Which methods of promoting equality are used? Reasoning: the same examination for all is formal equality; the extra support for disadvantaged students treats them differently so they can enjoy equal opportunity. Answer: formal equality combined with equality through differential treatment (a form of affirmative action).

Worked example 2: which Article?

Match each: (a) a recruitment rule for government jobs that would exclude applicants of one religion; (b) a person who claims to be above the law because of wealth; (c) a law conferring a hereditary title on a family. Reasoning: (a) concerns public employment, Article 16 (and Article 15's ban on religious discrimination); (b) concerns equality before law, Article 14; (c) concerns titles, Article 18. Answer: (a) Article 16, (b) Article 14, (c) Article 18.

Key takeaways: the textbook holds that liberty and equality are complementary, drawing on the experience of laissez faire and the rise of socialism. Equality is promoted by formal equality, differential treatment and affirmative action. Ideologies differ sharply on equality. The Indian Constitution guarantees equality in Articles 14-18, supported by Article 21.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Laissez faire refers to:

    1. A system of State ownership of all industry
    2. An economic system in which private dealings are free from government intervention
    3. A method of affirmative action
    4. A kind of sovereignty
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook defines laissez faire as a system in which transactions between private parties are free from government regulation, privileges, tariffs and subsidies.

  2. 2. Which Article of the Indian Constitution provides for equality before law and equal protection of laws?

    1. Article 17
    2. Article 18
    3. Article 14
    4. Article 16
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 14 provides equality before law and equal protection of laws. Article 16 is equal opportunity in public employment, 17 abolishes untouchability, and 18 abolishes titles.

  3. 3. According to the textbook's summary of Heywood, which ideology regards society as naturally hierarchical and dismisses equality as unachievable?

    1. Socialism
    2. Anarchism
    3. Feminism
    4. Conservatism
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Conservatives have traditionally seen society as naturally hierarchical and dismissed equality as abstract and unachievable.

  4. 4. Which pairing of article and provision is correct?

    1. Article 17: abolition of untouchability
    2. Article 15: abolition of titles
    3. Article 18: equal opportunity in public employment
    4. Article 16: equality before law
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 17 abolishes untouchability. Article 15 prohibits discrimination, 16 covers public employment, and 18 abolishes titles.

  5. 5. The idea of biocentric equality, that all life forms have an equal right to live and flourish, belongs to:

    1. Liberals
    2. Ecologists
    3. Fascists
    4. Conservatives
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook, following Heywood, says ecologists advance biocentric equality.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery