Revision notes

Unit 3 Basic concepts of Political Science - Part I: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Sovereignty: meaning, characteristics and its two aspects

Characteristics of sovereignty as listed in this unit
CharacteristicMeaning
PermanenceSovereignty lasts as long as the State lasts; the death of a king or the fall of a government does not end it (hence the English saying that the king is dead, long live the king)
ExclusivenessThere cannot be two sovereigns in one independent State; that would destroy its unity
All-comprehensivenessEvery individual and every association, however rich or powerful, is subject to the sovereign
InalienabilitySovereignty is the life and soul of the State and cannot be given away without destroying the State
Unity and everlastingnessIts spirit lies in its unity; it is not bound by time
IndivisibilityIt cannot be divided; the textbook calls this its lifeline
AbsolutenessIt is unconditional and unlimited
OriginalityIt holds power in its own right, not by anyone's grant

Internal and external sovereignty

  • Internal sovereignty
    • Absolute authority over all individuals inside the State
    • Also over every association within it
    • No person or group inside can override it
  • External sovereignty
    • In simple terms, national freedom
    • Freedom to decide foreign policy and join any group of powers
    • Every State independent of other States

Internal sovereignty: supreme over everyone inside. External sovereignty: independent of everyone outside.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: sovereignty comes from superanus, meaning supreme; Bodin brought the term into political science in 1576. It is the legal supremacy of the State; in the Indian Preamble, sovereign means the power to legislate on any subject within constitutional limits. Its characteristics are permanence, exclusiveness, all-comprehensiveness, inalienability, unity, indivisibility, absoluteness and originality. Internally it is supreme; externally it means independence.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Kinds of sovereignty, monism and pluralism

Kinds of sovereignty (summarised from the textbook)
KindMeaningExample or note
Nominal and realNominal sovereign holds the title; real sovereign holds actual powerAncient kings were real sovereigns; after changes begun by the French Revolution, in parliamentary systems the council of ministers became the real sovereign and the king nominal
LegalThe authority with legal power to issue and enforce final commands (laws)Always definite and determinate; its authority is absolute and supreme in law
PoliticalIn a representative democracy, the mass of the people: the electorate or public opinionThe influence behind the legal sovereign
PopularThe people as supremeHistorically used as a weapon against the absolutism of monarchs

De jure and de facto

  • De jure sovereign
    • Has a legal claim to sovereignty
    • May not actually hold power
    • De jure = according to law
  • De facto sovereign
    • Has no legal claim
    • Actually holds power and uses force to make and enforce laws
    • De facto = in fact
Pluralism and its critics
Pluralist claimCriticism in the textbook
Associations are important and deserve autonomyIt is the sovereign State that brings unity and regulates all associations
Sovereignty should be shared among groupsDividing sovereignty destroys it, and without sovereignty anarchy follows
Groups, not only the State, shape rulesLaws are framed by the State, not by associations
The all-powerful State threatens freedomThe State is needed to protect people from the excesses of associations

Legal sovereign makes the law; political sovereign (the electorate) influences it; de facto sovereign holds power in fact; de jure sovereign holds it by law.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: sovereignty may be nominal or real, legal, political or popular, de facto or de jure. Austin's monistic theory places one supreme sovereign; pluralists such as Laski, Figgis, Barker, Cole and MacIver defend the autonomy of associations, and critics reply that dividing sovereignty leads to anarchy. Under the Indian Constitution the people are sovereign, and the sovereign democratic republic is part of the basic structure.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Equality: meaning, importance, dimensions and types

Laski and Barker on equality

  • Laski
    • Absence of special privileges; equal rights
    • Adequate opportunities open to all
    • Access to social benefits for all; inequality by birth is unreasonable
    • Absence of economic and social exploitation
  • Barker
    • Fundamental equality of all
    • Equality of opportunity
    • Equality of conditions of life
    • Equality of outcome or results
Five types of equality
TypeMeaningKey points
SocialNo discrimination in rights, privileges and opportunities on the basis of birth, caste, religion, race, colour, gender or statusRemoving status-based discrimination, ending special privileges, equal access to education; the UN declaration of 10 December 1948 stressed it
CivilEqual civil rights and liberties for every citizen (civil from Latin civis, citizen)Civil laws treat all alike, with no superior and inferior; linked to the rule of law
PoliticalEqual right of all citizens to take part in the affairs of the StateUniversal adult franchise; rights to vote, contest elections, hold public office, petition and criticise policy
EconomicReasonable opportunities for all to develop fullyScope for employment, fair wages, leisure, a share in managing the economy
Of opportunity and educationEqual and similar chances for all citizens, especially to receive educationRemove discrimination by race, caste, religion, language, wealth or gender

Equality is not identical treatment. Treating unequals equally can be as unjust as treating equals unequally.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: equality means the same rights, status and opportunities, distributed fairly, which can require unequal treatment. It rests on equal human worth and drove the French Revolution and anti-colonial struggles. It has negative (no privilege) and positive (opportunity) aspects. Social inequalities are made by society; the types of equality are social, civil, political, economic, and of opportunity and education.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Liberty and equality, ideologies of equality, and equality in the Indian Constitution

The textbook's account of laissez faire and its reaction

  1. Laissez faire No government role; free competition; demand and supply.
  2. Exploitation Gap between rich and poor widened; workers worst affected.
  3. Reaction Socialism rose against individualism.
  4. Lesson drawn Liberty needs economic equality; the two are complementary.
How ideologies view equality, as summarised in the textbook
IdeologyView of equality
LiberalsPeople are born of equal moral worth; support formal (legal and political) equality and equality of opportunity, but fear social equality costs freedom and penalises talent
ConservativesSee society as naturally hierarchical; dismiss equality as abstract and unachievable
SocialistsEquality is a fundamental value, especially social equality, seen as essential for cohesion, justice and positive freedom
AnarchistsStress political equality as an equal right to personal autonomy; anarcho-communists seek absolute social equality through collective ownership
FascistsBelieve humankind is marked by racial inequality, yet treat members of the nation or race as equal in core identity
FeministsEquality means sexual equality: equal rights and opportunities, or equal social and economic power, regardless of gender
EcologistsBiocentric equality: all life forms have an equal right to live and flourish
Right to Equality
ArticleProvision
14Equality before law and equal protection of laws for all persons
15Prohibition of discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth
16Equality of opportunity in matters of public employment
17Abolition of untouchability
18Abolition of titles

Formal equality treats all alike in law (Article 14); differential treatment and affirmative action help those held back reach real equality.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: the textbook holds that liberty and equality are complementary, drawing on the experience of laissez faire and the rise of socialism. Equality is promoted by formal equality, differential treatment and affirmative action. Ideologies differ sharply on equality. The Indian Constitution guarantees equality in Articles 14-18, supported by Article 21.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Liberty: meaning, kinds, law and safeguards

Milestones in the struggle for liberty (as the textbook outlines it)

  1. Medieval England Revolt against absolute monarchy; King John forced to guarantee freedoms (Magna Carta, 1215).
  2. Civil war Continued absolutism under later rulers led to civil war and the execution of King Charles I.
  3. Glorious Revolution, 1688 Absolute monarchy contained in England.
  4. French Revolution, 1789 Did not bring lasting liberty at once; France passed through several republics to the Fifth Republic (1958).
  5. Colonial freedom struggles Italy in the nineteenth century and India in the twentieth made great sacrifices for national liberty.

Two sides of liberty

  • Negative liberty
    • Associated in the textbook with J. S. Mill
    • No restraint on a person's actions
    • No hindrance in a person's path
  • Positive liberty
    • Freedom to do something
    • The individual has rights and opportunities
    • Aims at developing personality
Kinds of liberty
KindMeaning
NaturalAbsence of all restraint, unrestrained freedom to do whatever one likes
CivilEnjoying rights within the limits of law; reflects the rule of law and is guaranteed by the State's laws
PoliticalTaking part in political life: voting, contesting elections, holding public views, criticising government, petitioning
PersonalActing without arbitrary restraint in personal matters such as dress, food, way of life, marriage and children's education
EconomicLiberty to earn one's daily bread by fair means, regardless of caste, colour, creed or gender
FiscalNo taxation without representation: people decide how their money is spent
DomesticEqual rights for women and children; protection from cruelty and exploitation; right to education
NationalLiberty of the country: the nation is independent and sovereign
InternationalPeace, international cooperation and a world federation of states

Liberty is not the absence of all restraint, but freedom from arbitrary restraint. Where there is no law, there is no freedom (Locke).

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: liberty was won through long struggles, from medieval England to the freedom movements. Liberty comes from liber; politically it means freedom from arbitrary restraint. Mill's negative liberty means no restraint; positive liberty means rights and opportunities to develop. There are many kinds of liberty. Law protects liberty, and it is safeguarded by democracy, the Constitution, Fundamental Rights, decentralisation, an independent judiciary, economic security, the rule of law and vigilance.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery