- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Citizenship: meaning, Marshall's analysis, India and global citizenship
Explain citizenship in political theory, distinguish natural and naturalised citizens, describe citizenship in the city-state and Marshall's three parts, and outline citizenship in India and global citizenship.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain what citizenship means in political theory and distinguish natural from naturalised citizens.
- Describe citizenship in the Greek and Roman city-states and Aristotle's definition.
- Explain T. H. Marshall's civil, political and social elements of citizenship.
- State how citizenship can be acquired in India and contrast national and global citizenship.
Your passport, your voter ID and your right to a government school seat all depend on one status: citizenship. But political theory sees citizenship as more than a legal label; it is about being a full and equal member of a political community.
Meaning
In political theory, citizenship refers not only to a legal status; it also means that the ruled are full and equal participants in the political process. The textbook says democracy and citizenship go hand in hand, and that citizens' rights differ from country to country. Natural citizens are citizens by virtue of birth; naturalised citizens are those who acquire citizenship later.
Citizenship in the city-state
Citizenship was an important theme in the Greek and Roman republics, disappeared under feudalism, and was revived during the Renaissance as part of civic humanism. In ancient Athens citizenship was seen mainly as participation in duties; Greek citizens governed themselves and enjoyed wide freedom of public speech. Aristotle linked citizenship to birthplace, family lineage and culture, and defined a citizen as one who has the power to take part in the deliberative or judicial administration of a State.
Marshall's analysis
The British sociologist T. H. Marshall, whom the textbook describes as a liberal social democrat, linked citizenship to social class under capitalism. He divided citizenship into three elements:
Marshall's three elements of citizenship
-
Civil
- Rights needed for individual freedom
- Speech, property, equality before law
-
Political
- Right to take part in political decision-making
- Voting and holding office
-
Social
- Right to a decent standard of living
- Share in the fruits of society through social services
The textbook notes that Marshall placed special stress on social services, since citizens have the right to a reasonable standard of living and to enjoy its fruits.
Citizenship in India
The Indian Constitution tried to give full citizenship to all, whatever group they belong to. Provisions on citizenship are in Part II of the Constitution and in later laws passed by Parliament. Citizenship can be acquired in five ways:
- By birth
- By descent
- By registration
- By naturalisation
- By incorporation of territory
The Constitution also forbids the State to discriminate against citizens on grounds such as race, caste, sex or place of birth, and protects the rights of religious and linguistic minorities.
National and global citizenship
National and global citizenship
-
National citizenship
- Assumes our own State can give the protection and rights we need
- Rights guaranteed by the State for people's safety
-
Global citizenship
- Citizenship across national boundaries
- Needs cooperation of peoples and governments of many States
- Reminds us that States are interconnected
The textbook suggests that citizenship for all can help resolve socio-economic inequalities, and that global citizenship asks us to strengthen links between interconnected States.
Marshall's citizenship = civil rights (freedom) + political rights (participation) + social rights (a decent standard of living).
Worked example 1: Marshall's elements
Classify each right under Marshall's scheme: (a) the right to vote in a local body election; (b) free public health care for the poor; (c) freedom to buy and own property. Reasoning: (a) is participation in decision-making, political; (b) secures a decent standard of living through social services, social; (c) is an individual freedom, civil. Answer: (a) political, (b) social, (c) civil.
Worked example 2: mode of acquiring citizenship
Name the mode for each made-up case: (a) Priya is born in Chennai to Indian parents; (b) a foreign national lives in India for many years, meets the legal conditions and is granted citizenship; (c) a territory becomes part of India and its people become Indian citizens. Reasoning: (a) birth, she is a natural citizen; (b) acquired later after residence, naturalisation; (c) incorporation of territory. Answer: (a) birth, (b) naturalisation, (c) incorporation of territory.
Key takeaways: citizenship is both a legal status and full, equal participation. Natural citizens are born to it; naturalised citizens acquire it. Aristotle linked it to taking part in deliberation and judging; Marshall divided it into civil, political and social elements. In India, Part II and Parliament's laws govern it, with five modes of acquisition. Global citizenship looks beyond borders.
Check your understanding
-
1. Citizens who acquire citizenship later, rather than by birth, are called:
- Natural citizens
- Naturalised citizens
- Global citizens
- Political sovereigns
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says natural citizens are citizens by birth, while naturalised citizens acquire citizenship.
-
2. Aristotle defined a citizen as one who:
- Owns land in the city
- Pays taxes to the king
- Has the power to take part in the deliberative or judicial administration of a State
- Was born outside the State
Show answer
Answer: C. Aristotle's definition stresses participation: the power to take part in deliberative or judicial administration.
-
3. Which are T. H. Marshall's three elements of citizenship?
- Natural, moral and legal
- Birth, descent and registration
- National, global and local
- Civil, political and social
Show answer
Answer: D. Marshall divided citizenship into civil, political and social elements, and stressed social services.
-
4. In which Part of the Indian Constitution are the provisions on citizenship found?
- Part II
- Part III
- Part IV
- Part I
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says citizenship provisions are in Part II and in later laws passed by Parliament.
-
5. Which is NOT one of the ways of acquiring Indian citizenship listed in the textbook?
- Registration
- Descent
- Payment of a fixed fee alone
- Incorporation of territory
Show answer
Answer: C. The five ways are birth, descent, registration, naturalisation and incorporation of territory. Simply paying a fee is not a mode.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.