- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Rights: meaning, kinds, Fundamental Rights and new rights
Explain the meaning and features of rights, classify natural, moral, legal, contractual and human rights, compare the US Bill of Rights with India's Fundamental Rights, and describe constitutional remedies and new rights.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define rights and state their features, including the link between rights and duties.
- Classify rights as natural, moral, legal, contractual and human, with the three kinds of legal rights.
- Outline the US Bill of Rights and India's Fundamental Rights in Part III.
- Explain constitutional remedies and the new rights to information, privacy and transgender recognition.
If every human being has rights simply because they are human, the textbook observes, then every human has an equal moral standing that cuts across class, caste, race and religion. That powerful idea explains why rights now appear in constitutions and international declarations everywhere.
Meaning and features
Rights are the common claims of people that every civilised society recognises as essential for their development, and which are therefore enforced by the State. T. H. Green described rights as powers needed to fulfil a person's vocation as a moral being. Their features, according to the textbook:
- They are important for the development of society.
- They are available to all, without bias of caste, creed, race or gender.
- Rights and duties are interrelated: no duties, no rights.
- They are justiciable: they can be enforced in a court.
- It is the duty of the State to protect them.
Kinds of rights
| Kind | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Natural rights | Part of human nature and reason; basic rights that government cannot deny |
| Moral rights | Based on rules of good conduct, courtesy and moral behaviour; aim at moral perfection |
| Legal rights | Accepted and enforced by the State, equally for all; created by legislation or lawful decree |
| Contractual rights | Arise from promise-keeping; apply to the particular people to whom promises were made |
| Human rights | Rights of the highest order, protected by national and international laws and treaties; Human Rights Day is 10 December |
Three kinds of legal rights
-
Civil rights
- Life, liberty and equality
- Allow a civilised social life
-
Political rights
- Vote, stand for election, hold public office
- Share in the political process
-
Economic rights
- Provide economic security
Bill of Rights and Fundamental Rights
The United States Bill of Rights, proposed by James Madison, came into force on 15 December 1791; it guarantees individual rights and limits federal and state governments. The textbook traces its roots to the Magna Carta (1215), the English Bill of Rights (1689) and George Mason's Virginia Declaration of Rights (1776). In India, Part III of the Constitution contains the Fundamental Rights:
| Right | Main content |
|---|---|
| Right to Equality | Equality before law for all regardless of caste, creed, gender or race |
| Right to Freedom | Speech and expression, peaceful assembly without arms, forming associations, moving freely throughout India; life and personal liberty: an arrested person must be told the grounds, may consult a lawyer, and must be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours |
| Right against Exploitation | Bans trafficking in human beings and forced labour such as begar (unpaid compulsory work); no child below 14 to work in factories, mines or hazardous jobs |
| Right to Freedom of Religion | Freedom to choose one's religion; Article 26 allows religious and charitable institutions and the owning of property under law |
| Cultural and Educational Rights | Protect minorities' culture; no denial of admission to State or State-aided institutions by caste, creed or gender |
| Right to Constitutional Remedies | Article 32 (Supreme Court) and Article 226 (High Courts): writs of habeas corpus, mandamus, certiorari, quo warranto and prohibition |
The textbook also explains preventive detention: if the State believes a person may threaten law and order or national security, it may detain that person in advance, as a check on wrongdoing.
New rights
- Right to Information Act, 2005: lets citizens ask questions about the working of government, to bring transparency and accountability.
- Right to privacy: part of human dignity, protected as an intrinsic part of the right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 and the freedoms of Part III.
- Rights of transgender persons: recognised as the third gender; the Supreme Court directed the Union and State governments to give legal recognition to their gender identity.
No duties, no rights: a right is a claim society recognises and the State enforces, and it carries a matching duty.
Worked example 1: which kind of right?
Classify: (a) Meena's employer promised her a bonus in her written appointment letter; (b) Meena's right to vote; (c) Meena's expectation that guests will be treated courteously. Reasoning: (a) arises from a promise made to a particular person, a contractual right; (b) is a share in the political process enforced by law, a political (legal) right; (c) rests on good conduct and courtesy, a moral right not enforced by the State. Answer: (a) contractual, (b) legal, political, (c) moral.
Worked example 2: which right is affected?
Name the Fundamental Right involved: (a) a woman is refused entry to a public art gallery because of her sex; (b) a minority community sets up a school of its choice; (c) a person is held by police for three days without being produced before a magistrate. Reasoning: (a) is discrimination on the ground of sex, so the Right to Equality is violated; (b) is supported by the Cultural and Educational Rights; (c) breaks the safeguards for personal liberty (production within 24 hours). Answer: (a) equality violated, (b) cultural and educational rights supported, (c) right to life and personal liberty violated, for which a writ of habeas corpus can be sought.
Key takeaways: rights are claims recognised by society and enforced by the State, tied to duties and justiciable. They are natural, moral, legal (civil, political, economic), contractual or human. The US Bill of Rights (1791) and India's Part III protect individuals against government; Articles 32 and 226 provide writs. New rights include information, privacy and transgender recognition.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which thinker described rights as powers necessary for the fulfilment of a person's vocation as a moral being?
- T. H. Green
- James Madison
- T. H. Marshall
- John Austin
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook quotes T. H. Green. Madison proposed the US Bill of Rights, Marshall analysed citizenship, and Austin defined law as command.
-
2. The rights to life, liberty and equality are classed in the textbook as:
- Political rights
- Economic rights
- Contractual rights
- Civil rights
Show answer
Answer: D. Among legal rights, civil rights are those that allow a civilised social life, such as life, liberty and equality.
-
3. Which Article provides constitutional remedies to citizens at the Supreme Court?
- Article 21
- Article 226
- Article 32
- Article 26
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 32 provides remedies at the Supreme Court; Article 226 gives High Courts the power to issue writs.
-
4. The detention of a person in advance to protect law and order and national security is called:
- Habeas corpus
- Preventive detention
- Mandamus
- Prohibition
Show answer
Answer: B. Preventive detention lets the State detain a person it believes may threaten law and order or security. Habeas corpus, mandamus and prohibition are writs.
-
5. Which feature of rights does the phrase 'no duties, no rights' express?
- Rights and duties are interrelated
- Rights are enforced only abroad
- Rights belong only to the rich
- Rights cannot be enforced in court
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook lists the interrelation of rights and duties as a feature: a right in one person implies duties in others and in the right-holder.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.