• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Political obligation and property

Explain political obligation, its features and kinds, the theories that justify it and the reasons people obey the State; then explain the Lockean, utilitarian and feminist views of property and its place in the Indian Constitution.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain political obligation, its relation to political authority and its features.
  • Distinguish moral, legal, positive and negative obligations.
  • Explain the divine, consent, prescriptive, idealistic and Marxian theories and the reasons people obey the State.
  • Explain Lockean, utilitarian and feminist views of property and the status of the right to property in India.

Why should anyone obey the State? Most of us pay taxes, stop at red lights and stand for the national anthem without asking. Political theory asks the question openly, and the answers form the topic of political obligation.

Meaning and features

Political obligation binds a person to perform duties, such as those set out in the Constitution, for his own welfare and society's. When the State is responsible towards citizens, citizens must reciprocate. Where the State has political authority, it has the right to compel those who do not comply; for example, if taxation is within its authority, it can make non-payers pay. Yet even when the State does not enforce a law, the textbook says, citizens have a moral duty to comply. Political obligation involves three questions: to which identifiable authority it is owed, to what extent, and on what basis. Its features include a spirit of public service, honesty and integrity in public duty, political legitimacy and effectiveness, and citizens' responsibility to guard their guardians.

Kinds of political obligation

Four kinds of obligation
KindMeaningExample
MoralNot legally binding; no punishment for neglectHospitality to guests, helping the poor, caring for aged parents
LegalBinding by the State's law; the textbook links it to the welfare State, which provides roads, health centres and schoolsObeying laws that sustain these services
PositiveRules that require a person to do something and cannot be disobeyedPaying tax; serving in defence when required
NegativeNot doing what the State forbidsNot committing crimes

The textbook adds a caution: sometimes harmful laws are pushed through by a steamroller legislature, and it says citizens have a duty to resist such laws too. So political obligation includes obeying good laws and opposing bad ones.

Theories of political obligation

Theories and the textbook's criticisms
TheoryBasis of obligationCriticism in the textbook
DivineGod created the State; the king is God's representativePopular only in ancient and medieval times
ConsentThe State's authority rests on the people's consent (Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau)Treats the State as an artificial organisation
PrescriptiveInstitutions continuing from the past deserve respect (Edmund Burke)Over-emphasises established practices
IdealisticMan is political and rational, the State a self-sufficing community; rights come from the State, so no right can conflict with itToo abstract
MarxianThree stages: non-obligation before the revolution, total obligation during it, then a move to social development; the State as an instrument of the proletariat, eventually withering awayCalled illogical because it made the individual subservient to the State

Why people obey the State

Reasons for obedience

  • Fear of punishment
    • The State's coercive authority
  • Patriotism
    • Love of the nation
  • Fear of disorder and anarchy
    • People want peace and order
  • Habits and traditions
    • Obedience learnt as a good habit

Property

Property refers to legal relations between persons with respect to things, material or abstract. The textbook says it is considered a natural right needed for human dignity and freedom. John Locke held that government's main function is to protect individual rights and secure the peaceful enjoyment of property, which is a necessary means of life. Utilitarians argue that property rights are needed for people's happiness; to promote happiness, governments should encourage productivity by protecting property. Feminist scholars argue that women's subordination has rested on their lack of access to resources such as land, because of patterns of male ownership and control, which made women dependent on men; with the rise of women's empowerment in the 20th century, women have claimed equal rights to own property.

In India, the 44th Amendment (1978) removed the right to acquire, hold and dispose of property from the list of Fundamental Rights, and inserted Article 300A, which says no person shall be deprived of property save by authority of law. Property is therefore now a constitutional (legal) right, not a Fundamental Right.

Positive obligation: you must do it (pay tax). Negative obligation: you must not do it (commit a crime).

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: kind of obligation

Classify: (a) Karthik pays his property tax on time; (b) Karthik does not drive on the wrong side of the road; (c) Karthik looks after his elderly grandmother. Reasoning: (a) is something the law requires him to do, a positive obligation; (b) is refraining from what the law forbids, a negative obligation; (c) is a duty of conscience with no legal penalty, a moral obligation. Answer: (a) positive, (b) negative, (c) moral.

Worked example 2: matching the theory

Statement: 'We should respect our institutions because they have grown up over many generations, and their long survival proves their worth.' Reasoning: the basis is continuity from the past and respect for established practice, not God, consent or class. Answer: the prescriptive theory, associated with Edmund Burke; its critics say it over-emphasises established practices.

Key takeaways: political obligation binds citizens to duties, and authority lets the State compel compliance; obligations are moral, legal, positive or negative. Theories base obligation on God, consent, tradition, the ideal State or class; people obey from fear, patriotism, fear of anarchy and habit. Locke and the utilitarians defend property rights; feminists stress women's access to property. In India property is a legal right under Article 300A since 1978.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Paying taxes and serving in defence are given in the textbook as examples of which kind of obligation?

    1. Negative obligation
    2. Moral obligation
    3. Positive obligation
    4. Contractual obligation
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Positive obligations are rules that require a person to do something and cannot be disobeyed, such as paying tax and serving in defence.

  2. 2. Which theory of political obligation is associated with Edmund Burke?

    1. Prescriptive theory
    2. Consent theory
    3. Divine theory
    4. Marxian theory
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The prescriptive theory, supported by Burke, holds that institutions continuing from the past deserve respect.

  3. 3. Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau justified which theory of political obligation?

    1. Idealistic theory
    2. Prescriptive theory
    3. Divine theory
    4. Consent theory
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook says these thinkers based the State's authority on the people's consent.

  4. 4. Which amendment removed the right to property from the Fundamental Rights in India?

    1. The 42nd Amendment
    2. The 44th Amendment (1978)
    3. The 1st Amendment
    4. The 73rd Amendment
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The 44th Amendment (1978) removed it and inserted Article 300A, so property became a legal, not a fundamental, right.

  5. 5. According to feminist scholars as described in the textbook, an important condition of women's subordination has been:

    1. Too many property rights for women
    2. Denial of women's access to resources such as land, due to male ownership and control
    3. The divine theory of the State
    4. Universal adult franchise
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Feminist scholars argue that patterns of male ownership denied women access to income-producing resources like land, making them dependent on men.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery