- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Sources of law, law and morality, law and public opinion
Explain the six sources of law with examples, distinguish law from morality, and show how public opinion shapes law in a democracy.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain custom, religion, judicial decisions, equity, scientific commentaries and legislation as sources of law.
- Describe the jallikattu example of custom and law as the textbook presents it.
- Distinguish law from morality.
- Explain how public opinion is related to law in a democracy.
Laws do not drop from the sky. Some grew out of village customs, some from religious codes, some from judges' decisions and the writings of jurists, and most modern laws from legislatures. Knowing these sources helps explain why laws differ from place to place.
Six sources of law
Sources of law
-
Customs
- Oldest source
- English common law grew mainly from custom
-
Religion
- Shaped early law
- Codes of Manu, Shariat, Ten Commandments
-
Judicial decisions
- Courts interpret and declare law
- Higher court verdicts treated as law
-
Equity
- Common sense and fairness where law is unclear
- English Court of Chancery
-
Scientific commentaries
- Writings of learned jurists
- Coke, Blackstone, Story, Kent, Vijnaneswara
-
Legislature
- Main source in modern times
Customs. Many laws began as customs that the State later recognised; a State cannot ignore the customs of its country. The textbook's Tamil Nadu example is jallikattu, the bull-taming sport held with the Pongal festival, famously at Alanganallur in Madurai district. It says the custom led to a law on jallikattu in 2017, and it presents the issue as a tension between cultural rights, protected for groups under Article 29(1), and animal welfare: the textbook notes that a 2014 Supreme Court judgement said animals, as sentient beings, have a right to life under Article 21. These competing claims, the textbook says, led to several interpretations.
Religion. Religion practised by early communities shaped later law. The textbook traces Hindu law to the code of Manu, Islamic law to the Shariat, and notes that for Christians the Ten Commandments were the first law. Divine law is law believed to be revealed by God.
Judicial decisions. Courts interpret and declare the law, and in doing so they create new rules that the State later recognises; verdicts of the High Courts and the Supreme Court are sometimes treated as law.
Equity. Where laws are unclear or do not fit a case, judges decide by common sense and fairness. In English law, equity was the body of rules first enforced only by the Court of Chancery.
Scientific commentaries. Writings of learned jurists begin as arguments but may come to carry great authority. A. Appadurai gave examples: Coke and Blackstone in England, Story and Kent in America, and Vijnaneswara and Apararka in India.
Legislature. Most modern laws are made by legislatures, the most important source today. The textbook notes that the Indian Constitution itself drew on other sources, such as the Government of India Act 1935 and the constitutions of the United Kingdom and the United States.
Law and morality
Law and morality are complementary: ethics sets a code of conduct, and State law aims at the same goal. The textbook quotes Plato's view that the best State is the one nearest in virtue to the individual, and that when one part of the body politic suffers, the whole suffers; a good State has good citizens. Laws framed to remove evils such as drunkenness, gambling, theft, dacoity and murder are moral laws, and laws based on morality tend to last.
| Point | Law | Morality |
|---|---|---|
| Duties | Legal duties | Moral duties |
| Enforcement | Enforced by the State; disobedience is punished | Not enforced by the State; the severest penalty is social boycott |
| Scope | Only external actions | Both inner thoughts and external actions |
Law and public opinion
In a democracy people do not make laws directly; they elect representatives who are expected to express the public will. Laws, the textbook says, are framed with the support of public opinion, the opinion people hold about the common welfare. People express their views or resentment through peaceful demonstrations, and common welfare and social progress are the main concerns of public opinion. The textbook quotes Martin Luther King Jr.'s warning that law and order exist to establish justice, and when they fail they become dams that block social progress.
Law governs outward actions and is enforced by the State; morality governs both thought and action and is enforced only by society.
Worked example 1: identify the source
Name the source: (a) a court, finding no clear rule for a new kind of dispute, decides by what is fair and reasonable; (b) a rule of inheritance followed in a community for centuries is later written into law; (c) the Supreme Court's interpretation of a right is followed by all lower courts. Reasoning: (a) uses fairness where law is unclear, equity; (b) began as a custom; (c) is a judicial decision treated as law. Answer: (a) equity, (b) custom, (c) judicial decisions.
Worked example 2: law or morality?
(a) Rahul privately wishes harm on a rival but does nothing; (b) Rahul refuses to help an elderly neighbour carry groceries; (c) Rahul steals the rival's bicycle. Which can the State punish? Reasoning: law deals only with external actions that break a legal duty. (a) is only a thought, judged by morality alone; (b) is an outward action but breaks only a moral duty, so at most society disapproves; (c) is an external action that breaks the law against theft. Answer: only (c).
Key takeaways: law comes from customs, religion, judicial decisions, equity, scientific commentaries and, above all today, legislatures. Jallikattu shows custom meeting law and rights in tension. Law and morality are complementary but differ in duty, enforcement and scope. In a democracy, laws rest on public opinion expressed through representatives and peaceful means.
Check your understanding
-
1. When laws are unclear and cases are decided by common sense and fairness, the source of law used is:
- Custom
- Equity
- Legislation
- Religion
Show answer
Answer: B. Equity applies fairness and common sense where law is ambiguous; in English law it was first enforced by the Court of Chancery.
-
2. Which is the most important source of law in modern times, according to the textbook?
- Religion
- Scientific commentaries
- Customs
- The legislature
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says most laws in modern times are framed by legislatures, the most important source today.
-
3. The textbook presents the jallikattu issue as a tension between:
- Cultural rights and animal welfare
- Tax law and trade law
- Federal and international law
- Ordinances and statutes
Show answer
Answer: A. It describes a tussle between cultural rights (Article 29(1)) and the view, in a 2014 Supreme Court judgement, that animals have a right to life under Article 21.
-
4. Which statement correctly distinguishes law from morality?
- Morality is enforced by the State with prison
- Law deals with inner thoughts; morality only with actions
- Law is concerned only with external actions; morality with both inner and outer life
- Law and morality have nothing to do with each other
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says morality concerns both internal and external affairs, while law punishes only external actions. Morality's severest penalty is social boycott.
-
5. Coke and Blackstone in England, and Vijnaneswara in India, are examples of which source of law?
- Judicial decisions
- Scientific commentaries
- Religion
- Custom
Show answer
Answer: B. A. Appadurai cites these learned writers as examples of scientific commentaries whose opinions came to be accepted as law.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.