Revision notes

Unit 4 Basic concepts of Political Science - Part II: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Law: meaning, views, purposes and kinds of law

Views on law
ThinkerView (paraphrased)Emphasis
Jean Bodin; John AustinLaw is the command of the sovereignThe source: a supreme authority
SalmondLaw is the collection of rules that the State recognises and applies in administering justiceThe use: justice through courts
AristotleWithout law humans would behave like beastsThe need for law
Classification of laws
KindMeaningExample
Private lawGoverns relations of citizens with one another; the State stands above the parties as an impartial arbiter (Holland)A dispute between two neighbours over a boundary wall
Public lawGoverns relations of citizens with the State; the State is both arbiter and an interested partyA case about a citizen's tax liability
Constitutional lawBasic laws by which government conducts itself; define and regulate its functionsElection of the President, powers of the Supreme Court, appointment of the Governor
Statute lawLaws framed by a legislative assembly or ParliamentAn Act passed by Parliament
OrdinanceTemporary law issued by the executive, in India by the President when Parliament is not in session, especially to meet an urgent needA rule issued between sessions
Common lawRests on customs but is enforced by courts like statute law; prominent in EnglandCustomary rules applied by English courts
Administrative lawGoverns the offices, duties and privileges of government servants; disputes with citizens are settled by administrative courts or tribunalsA citizen's complaint against an official's order
International lawRules governing the conduct of States in their relations with one another, backed by public opinion and international bodies such as the UNLaw of the sea; air law requiring permission for foreign aircraft

Law in Political Science

  • Between persons
    • Private law
  • Between person and State
    • Public law
    • Administrative law
  • Framework of government
    • Constitutional law
  • By source of making
    • Statute law (legislature)
    • Ordinance (executive)
    • Common law (custom and courts)
  • Between States
    • International law

Private law: State as umpire only. Public law: State as umpire and player.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: law comes from lag, meaning fixed or even; in Political Science it is the body of rules guiding human action, sanctioned by the sovereign. Bodin and Austin call it the sovereign's command; Salmond stresses its use in justice. Law protects rights, settles conflicts and keeps order. Its kinds are private, public, constitutional, statute, ordinance, common, administrative and international.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Sources of law, law and morality, law and public opinion

Sources of law

  • Customs
    • Oldest source
    • English common law grew mainly from custom
  • Religion
    • Shaped early law
    • Codes of Manu, Shariat, Ten Commandments
  • Judicial decisions
    • Courts interpret and declare law
    • Higher court verdicts treated as law
  • Equity
    • Common sense and fairness where law is unclear
    • English Court of Chancery
  • Scientific commentaries
    • Writings of learned jurists
    • Coke, Blackstone, Story, Kent, Vijnaneswara
  • Legislature
    • Main source in modern times
Law and morality compared
PointLawMorality
DutiesLegal dutiesMoral duties
EnforcementEnforced by the State; disobedience is punishedNot enforced by the State; the severest penalty is social boycott
ScopeOnly external actionsBoth inner thoughts and external actions

Law governs outward actions and is enforced by the State; morality governs both thought and action and is enforced only by society.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: law comes from customs, religion, judicial decisions, equity, scientific commentaries and, above all today, legislatures. Jallikattu shows custom meeting law and rights in tension. Law and morality are complementary but differ in duty, enforcement and scope. In a democracy, laws rest on public opinion expressed through representatives and peaceful means.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Citizenship: meaning, Marshall's analysis, India and global citizenship

Marshall's three elements of citizenship

  • Civil
    • Rights needed for individual freedom
    • Speech, property, equality before law
  • Political
    • Right to take part in political decision-making
    • Voting and holding office
  • Social
    • Right to a decent standard of living
    • Share in the fruits of society through social services

National and global citizenship

  • National citizenship
    • Assumes our own State can give the protection and rights we need
    • Rights guaranteed by the State for people's safety
  • Global citizenship
    • Citizenship across national boundaries
    • Needs cooperation of peoples and governments of many States
    • Reminds us that States are interconnected

Marshall's citizenship = civil rights (freedom) + political rights (participation) + social rights (a decent standard of living).

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: citizenship is both a legal status and full, equal participation. Natural citizens are born to it; naturalised citizens acquire it. Aristotle linked it to taking part in deliberation and judging; Marshall divided it into civil, political and social elements. In India, Part II and Parliament's laws govern it, with five modes of acquisition. Global citizenship looks beyond borders.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Rights: meaning, kinds, Fundamental Rights and new rights

Kinds of rights
KindMeaning
Natural rightsPart of human nature and reason; basic rights that government cannot deny
Moral rightsBased on rules of good conduct, courtesy and moral behaviour; aim at moral perfection
Legal rightsAccepted and enforced by the State, equally for all; created by legislation or lawful decree
Contractual rightsArise from promise-keeping; apply to the particular people to whom promises were made
Human rightsRights of the highest order, protected by national and international laws and treaties; Human Rights Day is 10 December

Three kinds of legal rights

  • Civil rights
    • Life, liberty and equality
    • Allow a civilised social life
  • Political rights
    • Vote, stand for election, hold public office
    • Share in the political process
  • Economic rights
    • Provide economic security
Fundamental Rights as the textbook describes them
RightMain content
Right to EqualityEquality before law for all regardless of caste, creed, gender or race
Right to FreedomSpeech and expression, peaceful assembly without arms, forming associations, moving freely throughout India; life and personal liberty: an arrested person must be told the grounds, may consult a lawyer, and must be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours
Right against ExploitationBans trafficking in human beings and forced labour such as begar (unpaid compulsory work); no child below 14 to work in factories, mines or hazardous jobs
Right to Freedom of ReligionFreedom to choose one's religion; Article 26 allows religious and charitable institutions and the owning of property under law
Cultural and Educational RightsProtect minorities' culture; no denial of admission to State or State-aided institutions by caste, creed or gender
Right to Constitutional RemediesArticle 32 (Supreme Court) and Article 226 (High Courts): writs of habeas corpus, mandamus, certiorari, quo warranto and prohibition

No duties, no rights: a right is a claim society recognises and the State enforces, and it carries a matching duty.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: rights are claims recognised by society and enforced by the State, tied to duties and justiciable. They are natural, moral, legal (civil, political, economic), contractual or human. The US Bill of Rights (1791) and India's Part III protect individuals against government; Articles 32 and 226 provide writs. New rights include information, privacy and transgender recognition.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Political obligation and property

Four kinds of obligation
KindMeaningExample
MoralNot legally binding; no punishment for neglectHospitality to guests, helping the poor, caring for aged parents
LegalBinding by the State's law; the textbook links it to the welfare State, which provides roads, health centres and schoolsObeying laws that sustain these services
PositiveRules that require a person to do something and cannot be disobeyedPaying tax; serving in defence when required
NegativeNot doing what the State forbidsNot committing crimes
Theories and the textbook's criticisms
TheoryBasis of obligationCriticism in the textbook
DivineGod created the State; the king is God's representativePopular only in ancient and medieval times
ConsentThe State's authority rests on the people's consent (Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau)Treats the State as an artificial organisation
PrescriptiveInstitutions continuing from the past deserve respect (Edmund Burke)Over-emphasises established practices
IdealisticMan is political and rational, the State a self-sufficing community; rights come from the State, so no right can conflict with itToo abstract
MarxianThree stages: non-obligation before the revolution, total obligation during it, then a move to social development; the State as an instrument of the proletariat, eventually withering awayCalled illogical because it made the individual subservient to the State

Reasons for obedience

  • Fear of punishment
    • The State's coercive authority
  • Patriotism
    • Love of the nation
  • Fear of disorder and anarchy
    • People want peace and order
  • Habits and traditions
    • Obedience learnt as a good habit

Positive obligation: you must do it (pay tax). Negative obligation: you must not do it (commit a crime).

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: political obligation binds citizens to duties, and authority lets the State compel compliance; obligations are moral, legal, positive or negative. Theories base obligation on God, consent, tradition, the ideal State or class; people obey from fear, patriotism, fear of anarchy and habit. Locke and the utilitarians defend property rights; feminists stress women's access to property. In India property is a legal right under Article 300A since 1978.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery