- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Measuring democracy, and the achievements and challenges of Indian democracy
Explain how democracy can be measured qualitatively and quantitatively, list key criteria, and outline the achievements and challenges of Indian democracy as the textbook presents them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain Dr. B. R. Ambedkar's warning about political and socio-economic equality.
- Distinguish qualitative and quantitative ways of measuring democracy and group the main criteria.
- Describe achievements of Indian democracy on the political, social and economic fronts as the textbook presents them.
- List the challenges the textbook identifies for Indian democracy.
Calling a country democratic is easy; judging how democratic it really is takes evidence. This lesson explains how political scientists measure democracy and then applies the idea to India, using the textbook's account.
Ambedkar's warning
The textbook opens this section with the words of Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, Chairman of the Drafting Committee of the Constitution. In substance he warned that India was entering a life of contradictions: in politics it would have equality, recognising one person one vote and one vote one value, while in social and economic life its structure would continue to deny the principle of one person one value. Measuring democracy means checking both sides of this gap.
Qualitative and quantitative measures
Democracy can be measured qualitatively, to understand the dynamics of social change, and quantitatively, to show the net results. Qualitative measures look at political participation, such as protest, demonstration, campaigning, opinion-making and freedom of expression, and at social change such as upward mobility across caste, religious, gender and cultural lines. Quantitative measures use indicators such as the Human Development Index and per capita income.
| Group | Criteria |
|---|---|
| Self-government | Sovereignty (free from outside interference); authority of the central government throughout the territory; elected government |
| Elections | Universal adult suffrage; turnout; regular elections on schedule; free and fair elections; equal access to media and campaigning |
| Checks on power | Rule of law; legislative control of the executive; role of opposition parties; independent judiciary; judicial review |
| Parties | Party strength and inclusiveness; clear party ideology; party system (number of parties in the legislature) |
| Freedoms | Freedom of the press; independence of civil society; civil liberty; property rights; religious freedom |
| Equality | Equal access to resources; equal access to natural and common property; gender equality; political equality and representation for underprivileged groups |
Achievements of Indian democracy (as the textbook presents them)
The textbook credits the founders with strong democratic foundations: the Preamble, Fundamental Rights and Duties, Directive Principles, the parliamentary system, amendment procedures, judicial review and the basic structure doctrine.
- Political front: voter turnout, according to the textbook, rose from 44.87% in the first general election (1951-52) to 66.4% in the 2014 general election; electronic voting machines have been used since 2004; the voting age was lowered to 18 from 1989; India uses the first-past-the-post system, in which the candidate with the most votes in a single-member constituency wins, even without a majority; the 73rd and 74th Amendments reserved seats for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and women in panchayats and municipalities; and the military has been kept out of political power.
- Social front: the textbook describes a widening of political power to backward classes, who won reservations in legislatures and services as had been given to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes; a free press and independent judiciary have upheld the rule of law; smallpox and polio have been eradicated; and, in the textbook's figures, literacy rose from 18.3% (1951) to 73% (2011) and life expectancy from 36 years (1951) to 66 years (2011).
- Economic front: the textbook describes a shift from centralised planning and a large public sector to the liberalised, market-oriented reforms of 1991, followed by greater private and foreign participation, a new professional middle class, and growth in income and food grain production.
Challenges to Indian democracy
Challenges named in the textbook
-
Social
- Illiteracy
- Casteism
- Communalism and religious fundamentalism
- Gender discrimination and violence against women
-
Economic
- Poverty
- Regional disparity
- Sustainable development
- Growing economic offences
-
Political and administrative
- Corruption
- Political violence and criminalisation of politics
- Inadequate judicial and administrative reform
- Panchayat elections not held for years in some villages
-
Future tasks
- Greater transparency and accountability
- Independence within checks and balances
- Stronger civil society participation
One person, one vote, one value: political equality must be matched by social and economic equality (the substance of Ambedkar's warning).
Worked example 1: reading turnout figures
Using the textbook's figures, by how many percentage points did turnout rise from 1951-52 to 2014, and what does it measure? Working: 66.4 − 44.87 = 21.53. Check: 44.87 + 21.53 = 66.40. Answer: a rise of about 21.5 percentage points. Turnout is one quantitative criterion: the share of voters who take part. On its own it does not show whether elections were free and fair; that needs other criteria from the list.
Worked example 2: first-past-the-post
In a made-up constituency of 1,00,000 votes, candidate P gets 38,000, Q gets 35,000 and R gets 27,000. Check the total: 38,000 + 35,000 + 27,000 = 1,00,000. Who wins under first-past-the-post, and with what share? Working: P has the most votes, so P wins. P's share = 38,000 ÷ 1,00,000 × 100 = 38%. Answer: P wins with 38%, a plurality but not a majority, exactly as the textbook explains: the candidate with the largest number of votes wins even if only a plurality.
Key takeaways: Ambedkar warned that political equality must be matched by social and economic equality. Democracy is measured qualitatively (participation, social change) and quantitatively (indicators such as HDI), using criteria on self-government, elections, checks on power, parties, freedoms and equality. The textbook lists achievements on political, social and economic fronts, and challenges such as illiteracy, poverty, corruption, casteism, communalism, gender discrimination and criminalisation of politics.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which is a quantitative measure of democracy according to the textbook?
- Freedom of expression
- Human Development Index
- Protest and demonstration
- Upward social mobility within the caste system
Show answer
Answer: B. Quantitative evaluation uses indicators such as the Human Development Index and per capita income; the others are qualitative measures.
-
2. Under India's first-past-the-post system, the winner in a constituency is the candidate who:
- Gets more than half of all votes
- Is chosen by the party leader
- Gets the largest number of votes, even if only a plurality
- Wins a second round of voting
Show answer
Answer: C. FPTP is a single-member, simple-plurality system: the candidate with the most votes wins even without a majority.
-
3. Since which year, according to the textbook, have citizens been able to vote at the age of 18?
- 1951
- 2004
- 1950
- 1989
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says that since 1989 citizens have elected their representatives from the age of 18.
-
4. The 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments are linked in the textbook with:
- Reservation for SCs, STs and women in panchayats and municipal bodies
- Electronic voting machines
- Removal of the right to property
- The first general election
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says these amendments gave reservation to Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and women in local self-governing bodies.
-
5. Which of these is a criterion for evaluating democracy that concerns checks on power?
- Turnout
- Gender equality
- Independent judiciary and judicial review
- Party ideology
Show answer
Answer: C. An independent judiciary and judicial review check the executive and legislature. Turnout is about elections, gender equality about equality, and party ideology about parties.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.