- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Types of democracy: direct and representative, social, economic, radical and more
Describe political, social, industrial, economic, totalitarian, radical and plebiscitary democracy, and explain representative and participatory democracy.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish direct democracy (initiative and referendum) from representative democracy.
- Explain social, industrial, economic, totalitarian, radical and plebiscitary democracy.
- Describe how representative democracy works, including parties, manifestos and its key principles.
- Explain participatory democracy and its aims.
Democracy is not one fixed model. It can describe how a government is chosen, how a factory is run, or how wealth is shared. The textbook lists seven types by function, and then two forms of modern democracy.
Political democracy
Political democracy is popular participation of citizens in government: they elect representatives who are accountable to them. It works in two ways. In direct democracy citizens take part in law-making themselves: through the popular initiative, citizens propose a law that legislators then introduce; through the popular referendum, a law framed by the legislators is approved by a popular vote. In representative democracy, representatives elected for a term of office decide public policy on the people's behalf. The textbook says representative democracy is the dominant form worldwide, while direct democracy is practised in Switzerland.
Direct and representative democracy
-
Direct democracy
- Citizens decide laws themselves
- Initiative: citizens propose a law
- Referendum: citizens approve a law by vote
- Example in the textbook: Switzerland
-
Representative democracy
- Citizens elect representatives for a term
- Representatives make policy
- Dominant form worldwide
Other types by function
| Type | Main idea |
|---|---|
| Social democracy | Combines social, economic and political ideas to promote social equality and justice in gender, status, beliefs and customs; believes strongly in equality of opportunity and equality in freedom |
| Industrial democracy | Democratic principles in industry: labour rights and responsibilities at work, and workers sharing decisions with management as partners |
| Economic democracy | Democratic conditions of production: narrowing the rich-poor gap and creating greater equality among classes |
| Totalitarian democracy | Also called populist or mass democracy: after elections citizens have no voice; ruler and party dominate, power won by democratic means is used like a dictatorship, with terror, speech curbs and control of the economy |
| Radical democracy | Proposed by the Indian thinker M. N. Roy: real rule by the people throughout the term, direct accountability of legislators and executive to the people, who are the real masters |
| Plebiscitary democracy | Direct voting by the people on a candidate, party, public issue, a new constitution or national self-determination; also petitions to propose laws and to recall representatives |
Representative democracy in practice
In a representative democracy all qualified citizens elect representatives from constituencies. People choose through political parties according to ideology, principles and programmes. At election time parties announce their programmes in a manifesto; individuals may also contest as independent candidates. Parties keep people informed through public meetings, supporting or opposing government policies, and so mould public opinion. The textbook links representative democracy with liberal democracy, which began in the USA and Western Europe and may be presidential or parliamentary. Its principles:
- Regular, free and fair elections by universal suffrage and secret ballot, supervised by an independent Election Commission
- Competing political parties offering a choice
- Electoral laws supervised by an independent judiciary
- Freedom of speech and association
- Freedom to stand as a candidate
Participatory democracy
Participatory democracy seeks wider involvement of citizens in the direction and working of the political system than traditional representative democracy allows. A civil-society-based idea, it tries to give every member of a group a real chance to contribute to decisions. Its aim is to interest people in the political, legal and economic processes of the State and make them more responsible for decisions; people take part directly, without delegating power. The textbook links it with political equality, the redress of inequality, and local bodies such as the Grama Sabha, where villagers meet to discuss their needs.
Initiative: the people propose a law. Referendum: the people approve a law. Recall: the people remove a representative.
Worked example 1: name the device
In a made-up republic: (a) 50,000 citizens sign a petition and their draft law is put before the legislature; (b) a law already passed by the legislature is submitted to the whole electorate for approval; (c) voters in a constituency petition and vote to remove their member before the term ends. Reasoning: (a) citizens start the law, initiative; (b) citizens approve a legislature's law, referendum; (c) removing a representative, recall, a plebiscitary device. Answer: (a) initiative, (b) referendum, (c) recall.
Worked example 2: which type?
A made-up factory has a joint council of elected workers and managers that decides shift timings and safety rules. Which type of democracy is this? Reasoning: democratic principles applied in the workplace, with workers sharing decisions with management and their labour rights protected. Answer: industrial democracy.
Key takeaways: political democracy may be direct (initiative, referendum, as in Switzerland) or representative (dominant worldwide). Other types are social, industrial, economic, totalitarian, radical (M. N. Roy) and plebiscitary. Representative democracy works through parties, manifestos, free elections and an independent Election Commission; participatory democracy widens direct citizen involvement, as in the Grama Sabha.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the textbook, direct democracy is practised in:
- The United States of America
- The Federal Republic of Switzerland
- China
- Russia
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says direct democracy is practised in Switzerland, while representative democracy is the dominant form elsewhere.
-
2. When a law framed by the legislators is approved by a popular vote of the citizens, it is called:
- Popular initiative
- Recall
- Popular referendum
- Manifesto
Show answer
Answer: C. In a referendum citizens vote to approve a law framed by legislators. In an initiative citizens propose the law themselves.
-
3. The leading Indian thinker who proposed radical democracy was:
- Jawaharlal Nehru
- Dr. B. R. Ambedkar
- Mahatma Gandhi
- M. N. Roy
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook names M. N. Roy, who stressed real rule by the people and direct accountability of legislators throughout their term.
-
4. Which type of democracy captures power through democratic means but runs as a dictatorship, according to the textbook?
- Totalitarian democracy
- Social democracy
- Industrial democracy
- Participatory democracy
Show answer
Answer: A. Totalitarian (populist or mass) democracy elevates ruler and party over citizens, uses terror and speech restrictions, and controls the economy.
-
5. Social democracy, according to the textbook, believes strongly in:
- Rule by a few elites
- No elections at all
- Equality of opportunity and equality in freedom
- Recall of judges
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says social democracy believes strongly in equality of opportunity and equality in freedom as the basis of human rights.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.