• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Theories of democracy II: elitist, pluralist and deliberative

Explain the elitist theory of Pareto, Mosca and Michels, the pluralist theory including Dahl's polyarchy, and the deliberative theory with its link to Panchayati Raj.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the elitist theory, Pareto's classification of elites and Michels's iron law of oligarchy.
  • Explain the pluralist theory, competitive equilibrium and Robert Dahl's polyarchy.
  • Explain deliberative democracy and its connection with grassroots institutions.

Even in a democracy, a few people seem to make most decisions. Is that a failure of democracy, or its normal working? The elitist, pluralist and deliberative theories give three different answers.

Elitist theory

The elitist theory holds that the role of elites is unavoidable: in every age a few leaders control key resources and take the major decisions. In agrarian and industrial societies, ownership of property and control of production mattered most, so elites emerged as feudal landlords and owners of industry and then took on political roles. The leading elitist thinkers are Vilfredo Pareto (1848-1923), Gaetano Mosca (1857-1941) and Robert Michels (1876-1936). The textbook notes that elitism developed as a critique of egalitarian ideas such as democracy and socialism.

Pareto's view of elites

  • Governing elite
    • The ruling, power elite
    • Power from education, status, bureaucratic position, political connections, wealth
  • Non-governing elite
    • Elites outside government
  • Masses
    • The ruled majority
  • Two psychological types
    • Foxes: rule by cunning and manipulating consent
    • Lions: rule by domination, coercion and force

Robert Michels observed that even organisations that aim to be democratic end up controlled by a small group of dominant figures who organise and decide instead of deliberating with ordinary members. He called this the iron law of oligarchy.

Pluralist theory

The pluralist theory addresses the interests, rights and representation of minorities, which the textbook calls the core of liberal democracy. It favours institutions such as bicameralism (a two-house legislature) and federalism to represent many groups. Political power is distributed and shared among many groups with diverse interests, each defending its interests through government, creating a competitive equilibrium that benefits large sections of society in the long run. It requires regular elections and competition among parties, groups and individuals. The textbook names James Madison, John Stuart Mill and Tocqueville among those who saw elections as expressing the preferences of competing groups rather than simply the wishes of one majority.

Robert Dahl argued that the essence of democracy is realised in polyarchy, rule by the many: a large number of groups, associations and organisations each enjoy relative autonomy and bargain, with none dominating. Dahl later revised his view, describing American democracy as a deformed polyarchy.

Deliberative theory

Deliberative democracy emphasises deliberation, discourse and debate to define the public interest. Deliberation and participation are its two critical aspects, and they are usually strongest at the grassroots; the textbook gives India's Panchayati Raj institutions and civil society as examples. James Miller describes it as a system in which decisions reflect discussion among participants, who are willing to listen, consider others' interests and modify their own opinions. Public interest and public opinion are its key components. It fits with both representative and direct democracy. John Rawls and Jürgen Habermas held that a political choice is legitimate only if it results from deliberation among free, equal and rational people.

Three theories of how democracy works

  • Elitist
    • A few always rule
    • Foxes and lions (Pareto)
    • Iron law of oligarchy (Michels)
  • Pluralist
    • Power shared among many groups
    • Competitive equilibrium
    • Polyarchy (Dahl)
  • Deliberative
    • Decisions through reasoned discussion
    • Listen and revise opinions
    • Strong at the grassroots

Elitist: the few rule. Pluralist: many groups compete. Deliberative: people reason together.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: fox or lion?

Ruler A keeps power by clever speeches, promises and managing public opinion; ruler B keeps power by using police and the army to crush opposition. Classify them in Pareto's terms. Reasoning: Pareto's foxes rule by cunning and manipulating consent; lions rule by domination, coercion and violence. Answer: A is a fox; B is a lion.

Worked example 2: which theory explains it?

A made-up students' union has a constitution giving every member a vote, yet within three years the same small group of office-bearers makes all decisions and rarely consults members. Which idea explains this? Reasoning: an organisation meant to be democratic is run by a small dominant group that decides without deliberating with the rank and file. Answer: Michels's iron law of oligarchy, part of the elitist theory.

Key takeaways: elitists (Pareto, Mosca, Michels) hold that a few always rule; Pareto divides elites into governing and non-governing and into foxes and lions; Michels states the iron law of oligarchy. Pluralists see power shared among competing groups in a competitive equilibrium, with Dahl's polyarchy. Deliberative democracy legitimises decisions through reasoned debate, as Rawls and Habermas argue, and is strong in grassroots bodies like Panchayati Raj.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which three thinkers are the leading theorists of elitist democracy named in the textbook?

    1. Locke, Bentham and Mill
    2. Rawls, Habermas and Miller
    3. Pareto, Mosca and Michels
    4. Madison, Dahl and Tocqueville
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook names Vilfredo Pareto, Gaetano Mosca and Robert Michels as the leading elitist thinkers.

  2. 2. In Pareto's theory, elites who rule by cunning and by manipulating the consent of the masses are called:

    1. Foxes
    2. Lions
    3. Wolves
    4. Shepherds
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Pareto's foxes rule by cunning and manipulating consent; lions achieve power through domination, coercion and violence.

  3. 3. The 'iron law of oligarchy' was put forward by:

    1. Robert Dahl
    2. Gaetano Mosca
    3. John Rawls
    4. Robert Michels
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Michels argued that even democratic organisations end up controlled by a small dominant group, which he called the iron law of oligarchy.

  4. 4. According to the pluralist theory, groups defending their interests through government create:

    1. Social equilibrium
    2. Competitive equilibrium
    3. Economic equilibrium
    4. Total obligation
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says pluralism leads groups to defend their interests through government, creating a competitive equilibrium that benefits large sections of society.

  5. 5. Robert Dahl described the essence of democracy as:

    1. Polyarchy, rule by many groups enjoying relative autonomy
    2. Oligarchy
    3. Monarchy
    4. Totalitarian democracy
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Dahl's polyarchy accommodates many groups and organisations with relative autonomy; later he spoke of a deformed polyarchy in the USA.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery