• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Theories of democracy I: classical, protective and Marxist

Trace the history of democratic theory, and explain the classical (Athenian), protective (Locke and the utilitarians) and Marxist theories of democracy.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Outline how democratic theory developed from Greece to the American and French Revolutions.
  • Explain classical democracy, its preconditions and its principles.
  • Explain protective democracy and the contributions of Locke, Bentham, James Mill and J. S. Mill.
  • Explain the Marxist theory of democracy and its criticism of liberal democracy.

Different ages have asked different things of democracy. Athenians wanted citizens to decide together; seventeenth-century English thinkers wanted protection from rulers; nineteenth-century socialists wanted an end to class domination. Each answer became a theory of democracy.

How democratic theory developed

Development of democracy (as the textbook outlines it)

  1. Greek city-states Direct election, debate on policy and decision by the people.
  2. Larger states As states grew, representation by elected members gained importance.
  3. Middle Ages and Enlightenment Representative democracy emerged as the dominant form.
  4. American (1775-1783) and French (1789-1799) Revolutions Mass popular demand for democracy.
  5. Today A near-universal form of government across many cultures.

Classical democracy

Classical democracy was the direct democracy of ancient Greece, and Athens was the first city to introduce it. (The textbook dates its emergence to the period 800-500 BCE; historians usually date Athenian democracy from the reforms of Cleisthenes around 508 BCE.) All citizens were members of the assembly, gathered in the city square, debated freely and voted directly on laws and decisions. It had two preconditions: the community had to be small enough for citizens to attend debates and vote, and the economy had to be strong enough to allow citizens time for politics. Its principles were equality, liberty and respect for law and justice; equality before law and equal treatment by law; and free, open political life. Its main aim was the participation of all citizens and equality in rights and privileges.

Protective democracy

Protective democracy sees democracy as a means individuals use to safeguard their rights and liberties. This rights-based view emerged in the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. John Locke (1632-1704) is regarded as its great advocate: he argued that citizens' freedom and right to vote rest on natural rights to life, liberty and property. The English utilitarians, Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832), James Mill (1773-1836) and John Stuart Mill (1806-1873), also argued powerfully for it.

  • It believes in popular sovereignty; both popular sovereignty and representative government are legitimate.
  • The State's primary duty is to protect citizens' rights and liberties.
  • Authority is accountable to the people, ensured by regular elections.
  • Separation of legislature, executive and judiciary is the main means of protecting rights.
  • It brought in constitutionalism: ruler and ruled are both governed by the constitution, the source of power and guarantor of rights.

Marxist theory of democracy

The Marxist theory views democracy through class analysis in the era of the industrial revolution. Society was divided into the bourgeoisie (capitalists, owners of property) and the proletariat (the working class). The theory challenges capitalist dominance and the exploitation of workers. According to the textbook, it did not stress electoral rights but strongly supported economic rights and a socialist democracy; it favoured the collapse of capitalism through the revolutionary transformation of society, and holds that real political power is possible only with equal distribution of economic power. It treats the economic factor, ownership and control of the means of production, as the key to class division. It criticises liberal democracies as bourgeois or capitalist democracies controlled by the ruling class. The textbook adds that socialists believed people could govern themselves through universal education, and lists demands of democratic Marxists: replacing the standing army with a citizens' militia, electing all officials subject to recall, removing the political role of police, and ending monarchy.

Three theories compared
TheoryPurpose of democracyKey thinkers
ClassicalDirect participation of all citizens in decisionsAthenian practice
ProtectiveProtect individual rights and liberties from rulersLocke; Bentham, James Mill, J. S. Mill
MarxistEnd class domination; achieve economic equality through socialist democracyKarl Marx and his followers

Classical: participate. Protective: protect rights. Marxist: end class rule.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: will classical democracy work here?

A made-up country has 30 crore adult citizens spread over a large territory, most of them working long hours. Could it run on classical democracy? Reasoning: the first precondition, a community small enough for all citizens to attend debates and vote, fails because tens of crores of people cannot gather to deliberate; the second, an economy that gives citizens time for politics, also fails. Answer: No; this is why large modern States rely on representative democracy.

Worked example 2: identifying the theory

Statement: 'Elections in a capitalist society only let workers choose which members of the owning class will rule them; real democracy needs common control of the means of production.' Reasoning: the statement uses class analysis, calls liberal democracy a rule of the owning class, and makes economic equality the condition of democracy. Answer: the Marxist theory.

Key takeaways: democracy developed from Greek direct democracy to representative forms, with mass demand in the American and French Revolutions. Classical democracy needed a small community and a sufficient economy. Protective democracy (Locke and the utilitarians) uses democracy to protect rights and brought constitutionalism. The Marxist theory uses class analysis, criticises bourgeois democracy and seeks socialist democracy.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which city was the first to introduce classical (direct) democracy?

    1. Sparta
    2. Athens
    3. Rome
    4. London
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says Athens was the first city to introduce direct democracy, in which all citizens were members of the assembly.

  2. 2. Which is a precondition for the success of classical democracy?

    1. A large population spread over a wide area
    2. A powerful hereditary monarch
    3. A community small enough for citizens to attend debates and vote
    4. A ban on public debate
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Classical democracy needs a small community, so citizens can attend and vote, and an economy sufficient to let them engage in politics.

  3. 3. Protective democracy is based mainly on:

    1. Rights
    2. Class struggle
    3. Divine authority
    4. Rule by elites
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Protective democracy is a rights-based democracy: an instrument to protect the rights and liberties of individuals.

  4. 4. The Marxist theory views democracy in the social context of:

    1. Community
    2. Social groups
    3. The capitalist class alone
    4. Class analysis
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook says the Marxist theory views democracy through class analysis, dividing society into bourgeoisie and proletariat.

  5. 5. Which group of thinkers belongs to the utilitarian school that advocated protective democracy?

    1. Pareto, Mosca and Michels
    2. Bentham, James Mill and J. S. Mill
    3. Rawls and Habermas
    4. Marx and Engels
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook names Bentham, James Mill and J. S. Mill of the utilitarian school. Pareto, Mosca and Michels are elitists; Rawls and Habermas are linked to deliberative democracy.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery