Revision notes

Unit 5 Democracy: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Democracy: meaning, definitions and characteristics

How thinkers and leaders described democracy (paraphrased)
ThinkerView
Socrates (in Plato's dialogues)A pleasant but disorderly form of government that gives a kind of equality to equals and unequals alike
PlatoFreedom is the glory of a democracy, the only State where freedom truly lives
AristotleThe foundation of a democratic constitution is liberty
Abraham LincolnGovernment of the people, by the people, for the people
Mahatma GandhiUnder democracy the weakest should have the same opportunity as the strongest, which is possible only through non-violence
Karl MarxDemocracy is the road to socialism
G. D. H. ColeDemocracy is a living reality in every sphere of social, economic and political activity

Features of modern democracies

  • Written constitution
    • Followed in daily life by politicians and officials
  • Guaranteed rights
    • Human and fundamental rights for all
    • Especially minorities and the underprivileged
  • Separation of powers
    • Executive (government)
    • Legislative (parliament)
    • Judicial (courts)
  • Freedoms
    • Opinion, speech, press and media
    • Religious liberty
  • Universal adult suffrage
    • One person, one vote

Democracy = demos (people) + kratos (rule). Majority rule is necessary but not sufficient: rights, free elections and the rule of law complete it.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: democracy means rule by the people (demos + kratos); its ancient form arose in Greece and its modern form in Britain. Thinkers from Socrates to Gandhi saw it differently. Its characteristics include majority rule with minority rights, responsive government, protected rights, and free, fair elections. Modern democracies have written constitutions, guaranteed rights, separation of powers, free media and universal adult suffrage.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Types of democracy: direct and representative, social, economic, radical and more

Direct and representative democracy

  • Direct democracy
    • Citizens decide laws themselves
    • Initiative: citizens propose a law
    • Referendum: citizens approve a law by vote
    • Example in the textbook: Switzerland
  • Representative democracy
    • Citizens elect representatives for a term
    • Representatives make policy
    • Dominant form worldwide
Six more types of democracy
TypeMain idea
Social democracyCombines social, economic and political ideas to promote social equality and justice in gender, status, beliefs and customs; believes strongly in equality of opportunity and equality in freedom
Industrial democracyDemocratic principles in industry: labour rights and responsibilities at work, and workers sharing decisions with management as partners
Economic democracyDemocratic conditions of production: narrowing the rich-poor gap and creating greater equality among classes
Totalitarian democracyAlso called populist or mass democracy: after elections citizens have no voice; ruler and party dominate, power won by democratic means is used like a dictatorship, with terror, speech curbs and control of the economy
Radical democracyProposed by the Indian thinker M. N. Roy: real rule by the people throughout the term, direct accountability of legislators and executive to the people, who are the real masters
Plebiscitary democracyDirect voting by the people on a candidate, party, public issue, a new constitution or national self-determination; also petitions to propose laws and to recall representatives

Initiative: the people propose a law. Referendum: the people approve a law. Recall: the people remove a representative.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: political democracy may be direct (initiative, referendum, as in Switzerland) or representative (dominant worldwide). Other types are social, industrial, economic, totalitarian, radical (M. N. Roy) and plebiscitary. Representative democracy works through parties, manifestos, free elections and an independent Election Commission; participatory democracy widens direct citizen involvement, as in the Grama Sabha.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Theories of democracy I: classical, protective and Marxist

Development of democracy (as the textbook outlines it)

  1. Greek city-states Direct election, debate on policy and decision by the people.
  2. Larger states As states grew, representation by elected members gained importance.
  3. Middle Ages and Enlightenment Representative democracy emerged as the dominant form.
  4. American (1775-1783) and French (1789-1799) Revolutions Mass popular demand for democracy.
  5. Today A near-universal form of government across many cultures.
Three theories compared
TheoryPurpose of democracyKey thinkers
ClassicalDirect participation of all citizens in decisionsAthenian practice
ProtectiveProtect individual rights and liberties from rulersLocke; Bentham, James Mill, J. S. Mill
MarxistEnd class domination; achieve economic equality through socialist democracyKarl Marx and his followers

Classical: participate. Protective: protect rights. Marxist: end class rule.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: democracy developed from Greek direct democracy to representative forms, with mass demand in the American and French Revolutions. Classical democracy needed a small community and a sufficient economy. Protective democracy (Locke and the utilitarians) uses democracy to protect rights and brought constitutionalism. The Marxist theory uses class analysis, criticises bourgeois democracy and seeks socialist democracy.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Theories of democracy II: elitist, pluralist and deliberative

Pareto's view of elites

  • Governing elite
    • The ruling, power elite
    • Power from education, status, bureaucratic position, political connections, wealth
  • Non-governing elite
    • Elites outside government
  • Masses
    • The ruled majority
  • Two psychological types
    • Foxes: rule by cunning and manipulating consent
    • Lions: rule by domination, coercion and force

Three theories of how democracy works

  • Elitist
    • A few always rule
    • Foxes and lions (Pareto)
    • Iron law of oligarchy (Michels)
  • Pluralist
    • Power shared among many groups
    • Competitive equilibrium
    • Polyarchy (Dahl)
  • Deliberative
    • Decisions through reasoned discussion
    • Listen and revise opinions
    • Strong at the grassroots

Elitist: the few rule. Pluralist: many groups compete. Deliberative: people reason together.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: elitists (Pareto, Mosca, Michels) hold that a few always rule; Pareto divides elites into governing and non-governing and into foxes and lions; Michels states the iron law of oligarchy. Pluralists see power shared among competing groups in a competitive equilibrium, with Dahl's polyarchy. Deliberative democracy legitimises decisions through reasoned debate, as Rawls and Habermas argue, and is strong in grassroots bodies like Panchayati Raj.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Measuring democracy, and the achievements and challenges of Indian democracy

Criteria for evaluating democracy (grouped from the textbook's list)
GroupCriteria
Self-governmentSovereignty (free from outside interference); authority of the central government throughout the territory; elected government
ElectionsUniversal adult suffrage; turnout; regular elections on schedule; free and fair elections; equal access to media and campaigning
Checks on powerRule of law; legislative control of the executive; role of opposition parties; independent judiciary; judicial review
PartiesParty strength and inclusiveness; clear party ideology; party system (number of parties in the legislature)
FreedomsFreedom of the press; independence of civil society; civil liberty; property rights; religious freedom
EqualityEqual access to resources; equal access to natural and common property; gender equality; political equality and representation for underprivileged groups

Challenges named in the textbook

  • Social
    • Illiteracy
    • Casteism
    • Communalism and religious fundamentalism
    • Gender discrimination and violence against women
  • Economic
    • Poverty
    • Regional disparity
    • Sustainable development
    • Growing economic offences
  • Political and administrative
    • Corruption
    • Political violence and criminalisation of politics
    • Inadequate judicial and administrative reform
    • Panchayat elections not held for years in some villages
  • Future tasks
    • Greater transparency and accountability
    • Independence within checks and balances
    • Stronger civil society participation

One person, one vote, one value: political equality must be matched by social and economic equality (the substance of Ambedkar's warning).

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: Ambedkar warned that political equality must be matched by social and economic equality. Democracy is measured qualitatively (participation, social change) and quantitatively (indicators such as HDI), using criteria on self-government, elections, checks on power, parties, freedoms and equality. The textbook lists achievements on political, social and economic fronts, and challenges such as illiteracy, poverty, corruption, casteism, communalism, gender discrimination and criminalisation of politics.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery