- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Federal government and how it differs from unitary government
Define federal government, list the federal features of the Indian Constitution, weigh the merits and demerits of federalism, and compare unitary, federal and confederal systems.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define a federal government and name the textbook's examples.
- Explain the federal features of the Indian Constitution.
- List the merits and demerits of federalism and compare it with unitary and confederal systems.
A country as large and varied as India needs both national unity and room for regional differences. Federalism is the arrangement that tries to give both. The Tamil Nadu textbook explains what makes a government federal and why India's Constitution has federal features alongside the unitary ones of the last lesson.
Meaning
The unitary/federal classification is based on the relations between the national government and the regional governments. In a federal government, powers are divided between the two by the Constitution itself, and each works independently in its own field. The national government may be called the federal, central or Union government; the regional ones are state or provincial governments. The textbook's examples are the USA, Switzerland, Australia, Canada, Russia, Brazil and Argentina.
Federal features of the Indian Constitution
Federal features of the Indian Constitution
-
Dual government
- Union at the centre, states at the periphery
- Each has powers in its own field
-
Written and supreme Constitution
- Laws of the Centre and states must conform to it
-
Division of powers
- Union, State and Concurrent Lists
- Seventh Schedule
-
Rigid Constitution
- Amendment needs a two-thirds majority in each House
-
Independent judiciary
- Original, appellate and judicial review functions
-
Bicameralism
- Upper and lower houses
- Lower house has powers over financial legislation
You may notice a tension: the last lesson called the Constitution flexible (a unitary feature), while this one calls it rigid (a federal feature). Both are true for different parts. Most provisions can be amended by Parliament alone, but amending some, especially those on the federal structure, needs special procedures. The textbook's summary describes India's Constitution as partly rigid and partly flexible.
Merits and demerits
Federal government: strengths and weaknesses
-
Merits
- Reconciles local autonomy with national unity
- Division of work improves administrative efficiency
- Makes large states possible
- Checks despotism of the centre
- Suits bigger countries
- Helps economic and cultural progress
-
Demerits
- Weaker than a unitary government
- More expensive
- Provincial tendencies are common
- Lack of uniform administration; threat to unity
- Division of powers leads to conflict
- Double citizenship; rigid constitution; states may hinder foreign policy
Unitary, federal and confederal compared
| Point | Unitary | Federal | Confederal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Levels of government | One level (sub-units only by delegation) | Two levels | A league of independent states with a weak centre |
| Citizenship | Mostly single | Dual (India is an exception with single citizenship) | Citizens belong to the member states |
| Division of power | None | Divided by the Constitution | Members keep essentially sovereign powers |
| Tendency | Centralisation | Decentralisation | Centre has only limited powers over the states |
Federal: the Constitution itself divides power between two levels of government, each independent in its own field. Unitary: one centre, regions with delegated power. Confederal: sovereign states, a weak centre.
Worked example 1: classifying a feature
Classify each of these Indian features as federal or unitary: (i) the Seventh Schedule's three lists; (ii) the President appointing Governors; (iii) the Supreme Court's power of judicial review. Reasoning: (i) divides powers between two levels, so federal. (ii) gives the Centre a hand in every state's executive, so unitary. (iii) protects the Constitution's division of powers through an independent judiciary, so federal. Answer: federal, unitary, federal.
Worked example 2: choosing a system
A made-up island nation of 3 lakh people with one language wants quick decisions and low cost. Step 1: small size and uniformity remove the main reason for federalism. Step 2: the merits it wants (speed, low cost, uniformity) are those of the unitary form. Answer: a unitary system would suit it better, while a large, diverse country would gain more from federalism's balance of autonomy and unity.
Key takeaways: in a federation the Constitution divides power between national and regional governments. India's Constitution has dual government, a written and supreme Constitution, three lists, rigidity in key parts, an independent judiciary and bicameralism. Federalism balances unity with autonomy but is costlier and prone to conflict.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of the following is NOT a federal feature of the Indian Constitution listed in the textbook?
- Division of powers
- Independent judiciary
- Single citizenship
- Supremacy of the Constitution
Show answer
Answer: C. Single citizenship is listed among India's unitary features. Division of powers, an independent judiciary and constitutional supremacy are federal features.
-
2. In which part of the Indian Constitution are the Union, State and Concurrent Lists found?
- The Preamble
- The Seventh Schedule
- The First Schedule
- Part III
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook states that powers are divided between the Centre and the states through the three lists in the Seventh Schedule.
-
3. Which is listed in the textbook as a demerit of federal government?
- It checks despotism of the central government
- It suits bigger countries
- It reconciles local autonomy with national unity
- It is more expensive
Show answer
Answer: D. Higher cost is a demerit. The other three options are merits of federalism listed in the textbook.
-
4. A league of independent states, each keeping essentially sovereign powers, with a central body having only limited powers, is a:
- Confederal system
- Unitary system
- Federal system
- Presidential system
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook's glossary defines a confederal system in exactly these terms. A federation's units are not fully sovereign, and a unitary state's regions have only delegated powers.
-
5. The basis for classifying governments as unitary or federal is:
- the relation between the executive and the legislature
- the number of people who rule
- the relations between the national government and the regional governments
- the role of religion in the state
Show answer
Answer: C. Unitary versus federal depends on how power is shared between the national and regional governments. The executive-legislature relation is the basis of the parliamentary/presidential classification.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.