• Practice
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Parliamentary and presidential forms of government

Explain the features, merits and demerits of parliamentary government, why India adopted it, the features of the American presidential system, and the differences between the two.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the features, merits and demerits of the parliamentary form.
  • Give the reasons the framers of the Indian Constitution chose it.
  • Explain the presidential form, using the USA, and compare the two systems.

Who can remove the head of the government, and how? The answer separates the two main forms of modern democratic government. The Tamil Nadu textbook classifies them by the relations between the executive and the legislature.

Parliamentary government

In a parliamentary system the executive is responsible to the legislature for its policies and acts. It is also called cabinet government (Ivor Jennings's term, because the cabinet is the nucleus of power), responsible government (because the cabinet stays in office only while it keeps Parliament's confidence) and the Westminster model (after the seat of the British Parliament, where it began). The textbook's examples are Britain, Japan, Canada and India. British writers once called the Prime Minister primus inter pares, first among equals, though the textbook notes the office has since become dominant.

Features

  • Nominal and real executives: the President is the nominal (de jure, titular) executive and head of State; the Prime Minister is the real (de facto) executive and head of government.
  • Majority party rule: the party winning a majority in the Lok Sabha forms the government; its leader is appointed Prime Minister, and other ministers are appointed on the Prime Minister's advice. If no party has a majority, a coalition may be invited.
  • Collective responsibility: the bedrock principle; ministers are collectively responsible to Parliament.
  • Double membership: ministers belong to both the legislature and the executive.
  • Leadership of the Prime Minister: leader of the council of ministers, of Parliament and of the ruling party.

Parliamentary government: merits and demerits

  • Merits
    • Harmony between legislature and executive
    • Responsible government: question hour, debates, adjournment and no-confidence motions
    • Prevents despotism: power with a council, removable by no-confidence
    • Wide representation of sections and regions
  • Demerits
    • Unstable government: defections, coalitions, no-confidence
    • No continuity of policies
    • Dictatorship of the cabinet when the majority is huge
    • Goes against separation of powers

On the 'dictatorship of the cabinet', the textbook cites Harold J. Laski, who said the system gives the executive an opportunity for tyranny, and Ramsay Muir, who complained of cabinet dictatorship. (Muir was a British historian and writer on government.)

Why India chose it

  1. Familiarity with the system from the colonial period.
  2. Preference for more responsibility over more stability.
  3. Need to avoid legislature-executive conflicts.
  4. The nature of Indian society: one of the most diverse and plural societies, which a system with wide representation of sections, interests and regions suits well.

Presidential government

The presidential form is also called the non-responsible, non-parliamentary or fixed executive system. It is built on the separation of powers, and the textbook's examples include the USA, Brazil, Russia and Sri Lanka. In the USA, the President is both head of State and head of government, is elected by an electoral college for a fixed four-year term, and can be removed by Congress only by impeachment. The President governs with a cabinet (or a smaller 'kitchen cabinet') of non-elected secretaries who are chosen by, answerable to and removable by the President. They are not members of Congress, and the President cannot dissolve the House of Representatives. The branches also check and balance one another: the President can veto bills, Congress can override the veto and must approve treaties and key appointments, and the Supreme Court can declare acts unconstitutional.

Presidential and parliamentary forms compared
PointPresidential (USA)Parliamentary (India, UK)
Head of governmentThe President, elected separately from the legislatureThe Prime Minister, leader of the majority in the lower house
Head of StateThe PresidentA nominal head: President (India) or monarch (UK)
PowersSeparation of powers; independent branchesExecutive and legislature fused, with overlapping functions
LeadershipIndividualCollective
AccountabilityPresident not accountable to the legislatureCollective and individual responsibility to the legislature
TenureFixed; removal only by impeachmentLasts while the government keeps the House's confidence

Parliamentary: the executive comes from the legislature and is responsible to it. Presidential: the executive is separately chosen, serves a fixed term and is not responsible to the legislature.

— Key distinction

Worked example 1: which system?

In a made-up country, the head of government loses a vote of no confidence and resigns the same day. Reasoning: removal by a vote of the legislature shows the executive is responsible to it. A presidential head of government could be removed only by impeachment for a grave act. Answer: parliamentary system.

Worked example 2: trade-off

Why might a parliamentary country face frequent changes of government while a presidential one does not? Step 1: in a parliamentary system ministers depend on a legislative majority, which defections or coalition break-ups can destroy. Step 2: a presidential executive has a fixed term regardless of votes in the legislature. Conclusion: the parliamentary system trades stability for responsibility, which is exactly the preference the textbook says India's framers made.

Key takeaways: a parliamentary government has nominal and real executives, majority-party rule, collective responsibility, double membership and Prime Ministerial leadership; it is responsible but can be unstable. India chose it for familiarity, responsibility, harmony and diversity. A presidential government separates powers, gives a fixed term and is not responsible to the legislature.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who called the parliamentary system the 'cabinet system' because the cabinet is the nucleus of power?

    1. Harold J. Laski
    2. Albert Venn Dicey
    3. Ivor Jennings
    4. Montesquieu
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook credits Ivor Jennings with the term cabinet system. Laski is cited for the danger of executive tyranny.

  2. 2. Which principle does the textbook call the bedrock of parliamentary government?

    1. Collective responsibility
    2. Separation of powers
    3. Fixed tenure
    4. Judicial review
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Collective responsibility of ministers to Parliament is the bedrock principle. Separation of powers and fixed tenure belong to the presidential form.

  3. 3. Which of these was NOT among the reasons the framers of the Indian Constitution preferred the parliamentary system?

    1. Familiarity with the system
    2. Need to avoid legislature-executive conflicts
    3. The heterogeneous nature of Indian society
    4. Strict separation of powers
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The parliamentary system goes against strict separation of powers, so that cannot be a reason for choosing it. The other three are the textbook's reasons, along with a preference for more responsibility.

  4. 4. In the American presidential system, the President can be removed by Congress:

    1. by a simple no-confidence motion
    2. only by impeachment for a grave unconstitutional act
    3. whenever the cabinet resigns
    4. by dissolving the House of Representatives
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The President has a fixed term and can be removed only by impeachment. No-confidence motions belong to parliamentary systems, and the President cannot dissolve the House.

  5. 5. Case: in a country, ministers sit in the legislature, answer its questions every day, and resign if it passes a no-confidence motion. Which feature is NOT shown here?

    1. Double membership
    2. Responsible government
    3. Fixed executive tenure
    4. Collective responsibility
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Ministers sitting in the legislature shows double membership; answering questions and resigning on a no-confidence vote shows responsible government and collective responsibility. A fixed tenure is the opposite of what is described.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery