- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Unitary government and the unitary features of the Indian Constitution
Define a unitary government with Dicey, Garner and Strong, weigh its merits and demerits, and list the ten unitary features of the Indian Constitution.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define a unitary government and give the textbook's examples.
- State the merits and demerits of the unitary form.
- List and explain the unitary features found in the Indian Constitution.
When all the threads of power lead back to one centre, we have a unitary state. India is usually described as a federation, yet the Tamil Nadu textbook shows that its Constitution also has strong unitary features. Understanding both sides helps explain how India's government works.
Meaning and definitions
A unitary state is governed as a single entity. The central government is supreme, and the administrative divisions (provinces, districts and so on) exercise only those powers the centre has delegated to them. All authority is vested in a single centre. The textbook's examples are England, France, Japan and Sri Lanka.
| Thinker | What the definition stresses |
|---|---|
| A. V. Dicey | The habitual exercise of supreme legislative authority by one central power |
| Garner | The constitution gives the whole power of government to a single central organ |
| C. F. Strong | Two qualities: the supremacy of the central government and the absence of subsidiary sovereign bodies |
Merits and demerits
Unitary government: strengths and weaknesses
-
Merits
- Suits small countries
- No conflict of authority and responsibility
- Prompt decisions, speedy action
- Less expensive
- Constitution easy to amend
- Uniform law, policy and administration
-
Demerits
- Not suitable for big countries
- Centre overloaded, causing administrative delay
- Neglects local problems and local initiative
- Concentrated power may lead to despotism
Notice how each merit has a matching risk. Concentration makes quick decisions possible, but the same concentration can overload the centre and, at worst, open the way to despotism.
Unitary features of the Indian Constitution
- Strong Centre: the division of powers favours the Union. The Union List has more subjects than the State List, the more important subjects are in the Union List, and the Centre has overriding authority over the Concurrent List.
- Centre's control over state territory: Parliament can, by its own action, change the area, boundaries or name of any state.
- Single Constitution: one Constitution covers both the Union and the states.
- Flexibility: most of the Constitution can be amended by Parliament alone, by simple or special majority.
- Unequal representation of states in the Rajya Sabha, unlike federations that give states equal seats in the upper house.
- Emergency provisions: during an emergency the Centre becomes all-powerful and the federal structure turns unitary without a formal amendment.
- Single citizenship: only Indian citizenship, with the same rights across the country; the textbook contrasts this with the dual citizenship of the USA, Switzerland and Australia.
- Single integrated judiciary: all courts form one hierarchy up to the Supreme Court.
- All India Services: these promote a uniform administrative system across India.
- Appointment of the Governor: the Governor is appointed by the President, not elected, and holds office during the President's pleasure.
Unitary: one centre holds all power and lends some to the regions. India's Constitution keeps a strong centre through the lists, emergency powers, single citizenship, an integrated judiciary, All India Services and appointed Governors.
Worked example 1: is it unitary?
In a made-up country, the national parliament creates five provinces by an ordinary law and can abolish them by another ordinary law. Step 1: where do the provinces' powers come from? From the centre, by delegation. Step 2: are there subsidiary sovereign bodies? No, the provinces can be abolished. Step 3: apply Strong's two qualities: supremacy of the centre and no subsidiary sovereign bodies are both present. Answer: a unitary government.
Worked example 2: spotting the feature
Statement: 'A person born in Tamil Nadu who moves to Assam keeps exactly the same rights as a citizen.' Reasoning: this follows from there being only one Indian citizenship and no separate state citizenship. Answer: the unitary feature of single citizenship.
Key takeaways: in a unitary state the central government is supreme and regions have only delegated powers. It is quick, cheap and uniform but suits small countries better and risks over-centralisation. India's Constitution contains ten unitary features that give the Centre a strong position.
Check your understanding
-
1. C. F. Strong named two qualities of a unitary government. They are:
- Written constitution and independent judiciary
- Dual citizenship and bicameral legislature
- Supremacy of the central government and absence of subsidiary sovereign bodies
- Separation of powers and fixed tenure
Show answer
Answer: C. Strong's two qualities are the supremacy of the centre and the absence of subsidiary sovereign bodies. The other options describe federal or presidential features.
-
2. Which of the following is a merit of the unitary form according to the textbook?
- It is less expensive
- It suits very large countries
- It encourages strong local initiative
- It makes the constitution hard to amend
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook lists low cost among the merits. It says the unitary form does not suit big countries, neglects local initiative, and has an easily amended constitution.
-
3. Which unitary feature lets the Indian Parliament alter the name or boundaries of a state by its own action?
- Single integrated judiciary
- All India Services
- Emergency provisions
- Central government's control over state territory
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook lists the Centre's control over state territory: Parliament can unilaterally change the area, boundaries or name of any state.
-
4. Assertion (A): India's states are not equally represented in the Rajya Sabha. Reason (R): Equal representation of states in the upper house is the usual federal practice.
- Both A and R are true, and R explains why A is counted as a unitary feature
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are false
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. Because federations usually give states equal upper-house seats, India's unequal representation is counted among its unitary features, which is what R explains.
-
5. Which of these countries does the textbook give as an example of a unitary government?
- Switzerland
- Japan
- Australia
- Brazil
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook's unitary examples are England, France, Japan and Sri Lanka. Switzerland, Australia and Brazil appear in its list of federations.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.