• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Government: meaning, organs and ways of classifying it

Define government, name its three organs, describe the four approaches to studying it, and explain the classifications of Montesquieu and Aristotle.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define government, trace the origin of the word and name its three organs.
  • Describe the comparative-historical, legal-institutional, political economy and political sociology approaches.
  • Explain Montesquieu's three-fold division and Aristotle's six-fold classification of governments.

From the birth certificate issued when we are born to the death certificate at the end, the state touches almost every stage of our lives, and it does so through its government. Unit 6 of the Tamil Nadu textbook asks what government is, how thinkers have sorted governments into types, and how we can judge whether a government is doing its job. This first lesson lays the foundation.

What government is

The textbook calls government the main agency of the state. It is made up of people in two wings: the political wing (elected representatives such as ministers) and the administrative wing (appointed officials or bureaucrats). Through it the state's policies are delegated and carried out for the welfare of the people. Government formulates, expresses and realises the will of the state, and it exercises legislative, executive and judicial powers on the basis of the constitution and the laws.

In a narrow sense, government refers to the executive functions of the state: a body with authority to make and enforce laws for civil, corporate, religious, academic and other groups. The word comes from an old French word, which in turn comes from the Latin gubernare, meaning to direct, rule, guide or govern.

The three organs of government

  • Legislature
    • Makes laws
    • Example: Parliament
  • Executive
    • Carries out laws and policies
    • Ministers and civil servants
  • Judiciary
    • Interprets laws and settles disputes
    • Courts

The textbook then classifies governments as unitary or federal (by how power is shared between the centre and the regions) and parliamentary or presidential (by how the executive relates to the legislature). Later lessons take these up one by one.

Four approaches to studying government

Approaches to the study of government, as described in the textbook
ApproachWhat it looks atThinkers named
Comparative-historicalDescribes and compares political institutions from ancient to modern timesAristotle (who studied 158 constitutions before writing *Politics*), Montesquieu, Locke
Legal-institutionalThe formal legal structure of institutions and the link between government and lawBentham (legal reformer), Austin (sovereignty as indivisible, inalienable and absolute), Dicey
Political economyEconomic aspects of government: the market, the mode of production and the delivery of goods; divided into liberal and Marxist political economyLiberal and Marxist schools
Political sociology (systems approach)Treats the political system as a sub-system of a larger social system and studies how they interactDraws on sociology and anthropology

The textbook notes that Montesquieu, after studying the British constitution, concluded that its stability came from following the principle of separation of powers. Keep this idea in mind: it returns when we compare parliamentary and presidential systems.

Montesquieu's three-fold division

  • Republican government: the people hold sovereign power.
  • Monarchical government: rule by one person, but according to fixed and established laws.
  • Despotic government: rule by one person with no fixed rules; everything depends on the ruler's will.

For Montesquieu, a government survives as long as the society keeps alive the particular spirit that belongs to that form.

Aristotle's classification

Aristotle combined two criteria: how many people hold power (one, few or many) and in whose interest they rule (the general interest or their own). This gives three good forms and three perverted forms.

Aristotle's six forms of government
Number holding powerRules in the general interestRules in personal interest (perverted form)
OneMonarchyTyranny
FewAristocracyOligarchy
ManyPolityDemocracy (mob rule, sometimes called mobocracy)

Aristotle's test has two questions: how many rule, and for whose good? A good form becomes its perverted twin when rulers serve themselves instead of everyone.

— Rule to remember, in our own words

Notice that for Aristotle the word 'democracy' named a perverted form, the rule of the many in their own interest. Its meaning has changed greatly since then.

Worked example 1: placing a ruler in Aristotle's table

A made-up city is ruled by a council of five wealthy merchants who pass laws lowering their own taxes and raising everyone else's. Step 1, number: five people is 'the few'. Step 2, interest: the laws serve the rulers, not the city. Step 3, read the table: few + personal interest = oligarchy. If the same five ruled for the good of all, the form would be aristocracy.

Worked example 2: identifying the approach

A student researches how a country's courts and statutes define the powers of each branch of government. Reasoning: the focus is the formal legal structure and the link between law and government, not history, economics or society. Answer: the legal-institutional approach of Bentham, Austin and Dicey.

Key takeaways: government is the main agency of the state, made up of political and administrative wings and working through the legislature, executive and judiciary. It can be studied through four approaches. Montesquieu divided governments into republican, monarchical and despotic; Aristotle used number and interest to produce six forms.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The word 'government' is traced in the textbook to a Latin word meaning to direct, rule or guide. Which word is it?

    1. Polis
    2. Gubernare
    3. Civitas
    4. Status
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook traces 'government' through an old French word to the Latin gubernare, meaning to direct, rule, guide or govern.

  2. 2. Which approach treats the political system as a sub-system of a larger social system?

    1. Legal-institutional approach
    2. Comparative-historical approach
    3. Political sociology (systems) approach
    4. Political economy approach
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The political sociology approach, drawing on sociology and anthropology, sees government as a sub-system of the wider social system and studies their interaction.

  3. 3. In Aristotle's classification, rule by many in the general interest is called:

    1. Polity
    2. Democracy
    3. Aristocracy
    4. Oligarchy
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Many + general interest = polity. Its perverted form, many ruling in their own interest, Aristotle called democracy.

  4. 4. According to Montesquieu, rule by one person with no fixed laws, where everything depends on the ruler's will, is:

    1. Republican government
    2. Monarchical government
    3. Constitutional government
    4. Despotic government
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Monarchy is one-person rule under fixed laws; despotism is one-person rule with no fixed rules at all.

  5. 5. Which pair of thinkers is linked with the legal-institutional approach in the textbook?

    1. Aristotle and Locke
    2. Austin and Dicey
    3. Marx and Engels
    4. Montesquieu and Aristotle
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Bentham, Austin and Dicey are named for the legal-institutional approach. Aristotle, Montesquieu and Locke are linked with the comparative-historical approach.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery