Revision notes

Unit 6 Forms of Government: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Government: meaning, organs and ways of classifying it

The three organs of government

  • Legislature
    • Makes laws
    • Example: Parliament
  • Executive
    • Carries out laws and policies
    • Ministers and civil servants
  • Judiciary
    • Interprets laws and settles disputes
    • Courts
Approaches to the study of government, as described in the textbook
ApproachWhat it looks atThinkers named
Comparative-historicalDescribes and compares political institutions from ancient to modern timesAristotle (who studied 158 constitutions before writing *Politics*), Montesquieu, Locke
Legal-institutionalThe formal legal structure of institutions and the link between government and lawBentham (legal reformer), Austin (sovereignty as indivisible, inalienable and absolute), Dicey
Political economyEconomic aspects of government: the market, the mode of production and the delivery of goods; divided into liberal and Marxist political economyLiberal and Marxist schools
Political sociology (systems approach)Treats the political system as a sub-system of a larger social system and studies how they interactDraws on sociology and anthropology
Aristotle's six forms of government
Number holding powerRules in the general interestRules in personal interest (perverted form)
OneMonarchyTyranny
FewAristocracyOligarchy
ManyPolityDemocracy (mob rule, sometimes called mobocracy)

Aristotle's test has two questions: how many rule, and for whose good? A good form becomes its perverted twin when rulers serve themselves instead of everyone.

— Rule to remember, in our own words

Key takeaways: government is the main agency of the state, made up of political and administrative wings and working through the legislature, executive and judiciary. It can be studied through four approaches. Montesquieu divided governments into republican, monarchical and despotic; Aristotle used number and interest to produce six forms.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Unitary government and the unitary features of the Indian Constitution

Definitions of unitary government given in the textbook
ThinkerWhat the definition stresses
A. V. DiceyThe habitual exercise of supreme legislative authority by one central power
GarnerThe constitution gives the whole power of government to a single central organ
C. F. StrongTwo qualities: the supremacy of the central government and the absence of subsidiary sovereign bodies

Unitary government: strengths and weaknesses

  • Merits
    • Suits small countries
    • No conflict of authority and responsibility
    • Prompt decisions, speedy action
    • Less expensive
    • Constitution easy to amend
    • Uniform law, policy and administration
  • Demerits
    • Not suitable for big countries
    • Centre overloaded, causing administrative delay
    • Neglects local problems and local initiative
    • Concentrated power may lead to despotism

Unitary: one centre holds all power and lends some to the regions. India's Constitution keeps a strong centre through the lists, emergency powers, single citizenship, an integrated judiciary, All India Services and appointed Governors.

— Summary to remember

Key takeaways: in a unitary state the central government is supreme and regions have only delegated powers. It is quick, cheap and uniform but suits small countries better and risks over-centralisation. India's Constitution contains ten unitary features that give the Centre a strong position.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Federal government and how it differs from unitary government

Federal features of the Indian Constitution

  • Dual government
    • Union at the centre, states at the periphery
    • Each has powers in its own field
  • Written and supreme Constitution
    • Laws of the Centre and states must conform to it
  • Division of powers
    • Union, State and Concurrent Lists
    • Seventh Schedule
  • Rigid Constitution
    • Amendment needs a two-thirds majority in each House
  • Independent judiciary
    • Original, appellate and judicial review functions
  • Bicameralism
    • Upper and lower houses
    • Lower house has powers over financial legislation

Federal government: strengths and weaknesses

  • Merits
    • Reconciles local autonomy with national unity
    • Division of work improves administrative efficiency
    • Makes large states possible
    • Checks despotism of the centre
    • Suits bigger countries
    • Helps economic and cultural progress
  • Demerits
    • Weaker than a unitary government
    • More expensive
    • Provincial tendencies are common
    • Lack of uniform administration; threat to unity
    • Division of powers leads to conflict
    • Double citizenship; rigid constitution; states may hinder foreign policy
Differences drawn in the textbook, with confederation added from its glossary
PointUnitaryFederalConfederal
Levels of governmentOne level (sub-units only by delegation)Two levelsA league of independent states with a weak centre
CitizenshipMostly singleDual (India is an exception with single citizenship)Citizens belong to the member states
Division of powerNoneDivided by the ConstitutionMembers keep essentially sovereign powers
TendencyCentralisationDecentralisationCentre has only limited powers over the states

Federal: the Constitution itself divides power between two levels of government, each independent in its own field. Unitary: one centre, regions with delegated power. Confederal: sovereign states, a weak centre.

— Comparison to remember

Key takeaways: in a federation the Constitution divides power between national and regional governments. India's Constitution has dual government, a written and supreme Constitution, three lists, rigidity in key parts, an independent judiciary and bicameralism. Federalism balances unity with autonomy but is costlier and prone to conflict.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Parliamentary and presidential forms of government

Parliamentary government: merits and demerits

  • Merits
    • Harmony between legislature and executive
    • Responsible government: question hour, debates, adjournment and no-confidence motions
    • Prevents despotism: power with a council, removable by no-confidence
    • Wide representation of sections and regions
  • Demerits
    • Unstable government: defections, coalitions, no-confidence
    • No continuity of policies
    • Dictatorship of the cabinet when the majority is huge
    • Goes against separation of powers
Presidential and parliamentary forms compared
PointPresidential (USA)Parliamentary (India, UK)
Head of governmentThe President, elected separately from the legislatureThe Prime Minister, leader of the majority in the lower house
Head of StateThe PresidentA nominal head: President (India) or monarch (UK)
PowersSeparation of powers; independent branchesExecutive and legislature fused, with overlapping functions
LeadershipIndividualCollective
AccountabilityPresident not accountable to the legislatureCollective and individual responsibility to the legislature
TenureFixed; removal only by impeachmentLasts while the government keeps the House's confidence

Parliamentary: the executive comes from the legislature and is responsible to it. Presidential: the executive is separately chosen, serves a fixed term and is not responsible to the legislature.

— Key distinction

Key takeaways: a parliamentary government has nominal and real executives, majority-party rule, collective responsibility, double membership and Prime Ministerial leadership; it is responsible but can be unstable. India chose it for familiarity, responsibility, harmony and diversity. A presidential government separates powers, gives a fixed term and is not responsible to the legislature.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

From government to governance: good governance and judging performance

The nine characteristics, in brief
CharacteristicMeaning
ParticipationEveryone has a voice in decisions, directly or through legitimate representatives, built on freedom of association and speech
Rule of lawFair legal frameworks enforced impartially, especially human rights laws
TransparencyFree flow of information; processes and information open to those concerned
ResponsivenessInstitutions try to serve all stakeholders
Consensus orientationDiffering interests are mediated towards a broad consensus
EquityAll have opportunities to improve or maintain their well-being
Effectiveness and efficiencyResults that meet needs while making the best use of resources
AccountabilityDecision-makers in government, business and civil society answer to the public and stakeholders
Strategic visionA broad, long-term view of governance and human development, aware of history, culture and society

Factors for evaluating a government

  • Socio-cultural
    • Gender Parity Index
    • Religious freedom
    • Equality regardless of caste
    • Minority rights
    • Gender budgeting
  • Political
    • Working democracy
    • Free and fair elections
    • Corruption-free, transparent administration
    • Independent press and judiciary
    • Human rights
  • Economic
    • Human Development Index
    • GDP and purchasing power parity
    • Growth versus development
    • Equal distribution of wealth
  • Environmental
    • Sustainable Development Goals
    • National Action Plan on Climate Change
    • Green budget
    • Disaster management

Government is the set of institutions; governance is how power is used through them. Good governance is participatory, lawful, transparent, responsive, consensus-oriented, equitable, effective, accountable and far-sighted.

— Summary to remember

Key takeaways: the World Bank's 1997 report called for an effective, facilitating state with five core tasks. Governance is how decisions are made and carried out, and civil society shares in it. Good governance has nine characteristics, and a government must be judged on socio-cultural, political, economic and environmental factors together.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery