• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Communism after Marx: Lenin, Stalin, Mao and later Marxists

Explain Lenin's vanguard party, democratic centralism and theory of imperialism, Stalin's socialism in one country, Mao's adaptation of Marxism, and the ideas of Gramsci, the Frankfurt School, Miliband and Althusser.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain Lenin's ideas of the vanguard party, democratic centralism and imperialism.
  • Compare Stalin's socialism in one country with Trotsky's permanent revolution, and describe Mao's changes to Marxism.
  • Explain Gramsci's hegemony and the Neo-Marxist, instrumental and structural schools.

Marx (Unit 7) predicted a workers' revolution in industrial Europe. The thinkers in this lesson tried to turn his ideas into practice in places and times he had not foreseen, and in doing so changed the theory. The textbook presents them in order.

Vladimir Lenin

Lenin organised the October Revolution of 1917 in Russia and was the architect of the USSR, a union of fifteen republics. His contributions:

  • The Communist Party as vanguard (What Is to Be Done?): a small group of dedicated workers trained in revolutionary Marxism, formed in every factory, who lead and mobilise the workers. The party is the front line of the proletarian revolution.
  • Democratic centralism: lower units elect the higher units (village and town to district, district to state, state to central unit), but the decisions of higher units bind the lower ones.
  • Imperialism (Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism): capitalism had not destroyed itself as Marx predicted because it survived on wealth taken from colonies in Asia and Africa. So two struggles were needed: colonies against imperialism, and workers in the West against capitalism.

Democratic centralism: two directions

  • Democracy (upwards)
    • Village and town units elect district units
    • District units elect state units
    • State units elect the central unit
  • Centralism (downwards)
    • Central decisions bind state units
    • State decisions bind district units
    • District decisions bind village units

Stalin and Trotsky

Marx favoured internationalism: workers, he said, have no country, and the Communist Manifesto ends by calling on the workers of the world to unite. Joseph Stalin, general secretary and Premier of the USSR after Lenin until 1953, changed this with socialism in one country (an idea first suggested by Nikolai Bukharin): socialism could be built in Russia alone, which must be strengthened against capitalist encirclement, postponing world revolution. Leon Trotsky criticised this and repeated the call for permanent revolution, exporting revolution abroad, warning that otherwise communism in the USSR itself would collapse.

Mao Zedong

Mao, a founder of the Communist Party of China, led the revolution that established the People's Republic of China in 1949. Adapting Marxism to Chinese conditions is called the Sinification of Marxism (the textbook prints it as 'Signification'). Its elements:

Mao's changes to Marxism, as described in the textbook
IdeaWhat it meant
Peasant-led revolutionMarx expected industrial workers to lead and saw peasants as conservative; Mao organised China's peasants and made them the revolutionary force, a model for agrarian Asia and Africa
Mass lineThe masses are not separate from the party: 'from the masses to the masses'
People's war and guerrilla warSurround the cities by capturing the countryside; guerrilla war in three stages: win people by propaganda, attack military targets, then fight as a regular army
Hundred Flowers (1956-57)'Let a hundred flowers bloom, let a hundred schools of thought contend': criticism was invited, but the campaign was reversed when it threatened the party
Great Leap Forward (1958-62) and Cultural Revolution (from 1966)Forced industrialisation and collectivisation led to a great famine that killed millions; the Cultural Revolution used Red Guards against the 'Four Olds' and alleged class enemies
New DemocracyAn alliance of peasants, workers, petty bourgeoisie and national bourgeoisie under a 'people's democratic dictatorship', unlike Marx's view of workers and capitalists as enemies

After 1978, the textbook notes, Deng Xiaoping opened China's economy to liberalisation and globalisation, while the Communist Party kept its monopoly of political power.

Later Marxists

  • Antonio Gramsci (Italy): hegemony, meaning intellectual and moral leadership. The capitalist state manufactures people's consent through ideas and propaganda, using force only when consent fails. Revolution needs organic intellectuals and the party. He wrote his Prison Notebooks after being jailed by the Fascist government.
  • Neo-Marxism or Critical Theory (Frankfurt School): Herbert Marcuse, Jürgen Habermas and Theodor Adorno studied hidden forms of domination and questioned cultural practices that keep the masses dominated.
  • Instrumental Marxism (Ralph Miliband): officials come from the same background as the ruling class, so the state is their instrument.
  • Structural Marxism (Louis Althusser, Nicos Poulantzas): officials' class origin does not matter; the state serves capitalism because of its position in the economic structure. Althusser divided state power into Repressive State Apparatuses (police, army, courts) and Ideological State Apparatuses (family, schools, media, trade unions).

Lenin: the party leads. Stalin: socialism in one country. Mao: peasants lead. Gramsci: the state rules through consent (hegemony). Althusser: repressive and ideological apparatuses.

— Summary to remember

Worked example 1: repressive or ideological?

Classify, in Althusser's terms: (i) a police force; (ii) a school textbook teaching obedience to authority; (iii) a court that jails strikers; (iv) a newspaper. Reasoning: apparatuses that punish disobedience are repressive; those that win support through ideas are ideological. Answer: (i) and (iii) repressive; (ii) and (iv) ideological.

Worked example 2: Marx versus Mao

Why could Mao's revolution not follow Marx's plan exactly? Step 1: Marx expected revolution where industrial workers were numerous and organised. Step 2: China in the 1940s was agrarian and industrially backward, with few factory workers. Step 3: Mao therefore relied on the peasants, whom Marx had thought conservative. Conclusion: this peasant-led revolution is the clearest example of Sinification.

Key takeaways: Lenin added the vanguard party, democratic centralism and the theory of imperialism; Stalin's socialism in one country clashed with Trotsky's permanent revolution; Mao built a peasant-based Marxism; Gramsci, the Frankfurt School, Miliband and Althusser explained how capitalist states keep power through consent, class ties and structure.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The view that the Communist Party must be the vanguard of the revolution was put forward by:

    1. Lenin
    2. Stalin
    3. Mao
    4. Gramsci
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Lenin, in What Is to Be Done?, argued that the party of trained revolutionaries must lead, as the vanguard, the proletarian revolution.

  2. 2. Under democratic centralism, which statement is correct?

    1. Lower units obey nobody
    2. Higher units are appointed by an outside power
    3. Lower units elect higher units, and higher units' decisions bind lower units
    4. All decisions are taken by a referendum of every member
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Democracy runs upward through elections; centralism runs downward through binding decisions.

  3. 3. Who criticised 'socialism in one country' and called for permanent revolution?

    1. Nikolai Bukharin
    2. Leon Trotsky
    3. Deng Xiaoping
    4. Ralph Miliband
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Trotsky called for exporting revolution worldwide. Bukharin first suggested the seed of socialism in one country, which Stalin adopted.

  4. 4. Gramsci's concept of hegemony means:

    1. military conquest of colonies
    2. rule by a single party
    3. the withering away of the state
    4. intellectual and moral leadership by which the state wins people's consent
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Hegemony is intellectual and moral leadership; the state manufactures consent through ideas and uses force only when consent fails.

  5. 5. In Althusser's scheme, schools, the family and the media are:

    1. Ideological State Apparatuses
    2. Repressive State Apparatuses
    3. organic intellectuals
    4. guilds
    Show answer

    Answer: A. They win consent through ideas without violence, so they are Ideological State Apparatuses. Police, army and courts are Repressive State Apparatuses.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery