• Practice
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Nationalism: theories, Indian nationalism and present-day challenges

Define nationalism, explain its main theories (primordial, socio-biological, post-ideological, communication and Marxist), the factors behind Indian nationalism, and the challenges nationalism faces.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define nationalism and trace how it spread.
  • Explain the five theories of nationalism in the textbook, grouped as perennial and modernisation theories.
  • Analyse the internal and external factors behind Indian nationalism and the challenges nationalism faces today.

Why do millions of people who will never meet feel they belong together? Nationalism is the ideology that answers, and it has shaped modern history from the French Revolution to India's freedom struggle. The textbook defines it as loyalty, affection and devotion to a nation, binding people to a common homeland, language, ideals, values and traditions, and placing loyalty to the nation above group interests. Ernest Gellner (Nations and Nationalism) defined it as a political principle that the political unit and the national unit should coincide.

Emergence and spread

Nationalism is a modern idea. It appeared first in England, spread to France and Germany, helped by the French Revolution, took a new form when the North American colonies broke from Europe, and later appeared as post-colonial nationalism in Asia and Africa through anti-colonial struggles. The textbook lists capitalism, the French Revolution, industrialisation, the World Wars and colonialism among the factors behind its spread.

Theories of nationalism

Theories of nationalism, as grouped in the textbook

  • Perennial theories
    • Primordial: ancient shared language, region, religion or race create strong ethnic bonds
    • Socio-biological: the nation as an extended family of common descent
  • Modernisation theories
    • Post-ideological (Giddens, Brass, Mann): the modern state creates nationalism
    • Communication (Deutsch, Anderson): communication and print create the nation
    • Marxist: nationalism is a creation of capitalism
  • Primordial: primordial means existing from the beginning. People sharing a language, region, religion or race over centuries develop strong affinity and ethnic identity; this is the basis of ethnic nationalism.
  • Socio-biological: the nation is 'the family writ large'. Nationalism is rooted in the past but acts in the present, and can show ethnocentrism towards one's own group and xenophobia towards others.
  • Post-ideological: Anthony Giddens, Paul Brass and Michael Mann see the modern state as the key. Giddens linked nationalism's growth in Europe to the French Revolution; Mann named four sources of social power (ideological, economic, military, political) that produced nationalism in different phases.
  • Communication: Karl Deutsch defined a nation as people who communicate more effectively with each other than with outsiders. Benedict Anderson called the nation an imagined community: members never meet most others, yet feel a bond. He traced this to print capitalism, as printed books in languages such as English, French and German gave millions the same ideas.
  • Marxist: nationalism is created by the capitalist class to protect its order and dull workers' class feeling; Marx said the proletariat has no fatherland and favoured internationalism.

Indian nationalism

Indian nationalism emerged in the second half of the nineteenth century, when Indians began to feel a common identity across religion, region, language and ethnicity. Internally, India's long tradition of pluralism and peaceful co-existence (unity in diversity) prepared the ground. Externally, colonial rule produced these forces:

  1. Unification: the British joined a subcontinent of hundreds of territories into one political, administrative and economic unit, and built railways, telegraphs and a uniform postal system.
  2. Western education: Indians learnt ideas such as liberty, equality and sovereignty and wanted them for their own country.
  3. English as a link language among nationalists in a land of many languages.
  4. Socio-religious reform movements such as the Brahmo Samaj of Raja Ram Mohan Roy and the Prarthana Samaj, which fought evils such as sati and untouchability and revived pride in India's civilisation.
  5. Racial arrogance of the rulers and the idea of the 'White Man's Burden', which Indian leaders rejected.
  6. Lord Lytton's rule: restrictions on the vernacular press, trade policies favouring British goods, little relief during famine, and a costly war in Afghanistan.
  7. The Ilbert Bill controversy under Lord Ripon: a proposal to let Indian judges try Europeans was withdrawn after protests by Europeans, which taught Indians the value of organised political agitation.

Challenges before nationalism

From within, nationalism faces secessionism and sub-national movements; the textbook's examples include separatism in Quebec (Canada), Catalonia (Spain) and Scotland (UK), fed by religious fundamentalism, resistance to over-centralisation, regional imbalance and loss of faith in democratic solutions. From outside come globalisation and its agents: multinational corporations, the World Trade Organization (from 1995, pressing for barrier-free trade), migration of skilled people, regional bodies such as the European Union with its 'pooled sovereignty', the growing role of the United Nations, radical transnational ideologies, global environmental problems, and information technology that makes the world a 'global village'. Yet the textbook concludes that nationalism remains strong: states keep their sovereignty, and decisions such as Britain's exit from the EU (Brexit) show national interest still decides.

A nation is an imagined community: its members will never meet most of their fellow members, yet each holds an image of their communion.

— Benedict Anderson's idea, in our own words

Worked example 1: which theory?

During a cricket World Cup final, lakhs of people in a stadium and crores watching on television feel joy or grief together for a team, although they do not know one another. Reasoning: people feel a bond with strangers whom they only imagine as their own. Answer: Anderson's imagined community, part of the communication theory. The textbook also gives the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier as an example.

Worked example 2: internal or external factor?

Sort these causes of Indian nationalism: (i) a tradition of unity in diversity; (ii) railways and telegraphs; (iii) the Ilbert Bill controversy. Reasoning: (i) comes from India's own history, so it is internal. (ii) and (iii) arose from colonial rule, so they are external. Answer: (i) internal; (ii) and (iii) external.

Key takeaways: nationalism binds people to a nation above other loyalties. Perennial theories (primordial, socio-biological) see it as ancient; modernisation theories (post-ideological, communication, Marxist) see it as modern. Indian nationalism grew from pluralism and from the effects of colonial rule. Secessionism and globalisation challenge nationalism, but it remains strong.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who described the nation as an 'imagined community'?

    1. Karl Deutsch
    2. Ernest Gellner
    3. Michael Mann
    4. Benedict Anderson
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Benedict Anderson, in Imagined Communities, argued that the nation exists in people's imagination and grew through print capitalism.

  2. 2. Which two theories does the textbook group as 'perennial theories'?

    1. Primordial and socio-biological
    2. Communication and Marxist
    3. Post-ideological and communication
    4. Marxist and primordial
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The primordial and socio-biological theories are perennial; the post-ideological, communication and Marxist theories are modernisation theories.

  3. 3. Michael Mann's four sources of social power are:

    1. Land, labour, capital and enterprise
    2. Ideological, economic, military and political
    3. Language, religion, region and race
    4. Press, parliament, police and party
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Mann named ideological, economic, military and political power, which in combination produced nationalism in different periods.

  4. 4. Which of the following is an EXTERNAL factor behind Indian nationalism according to the textbook?

    1. Unity in diversity
    2. A culture of peaceful co-existence
    3. Western education introduced under colonial rule
    4. Shared ancient history
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Western education came with colonialism, an external factor. Unity in diversity, peaceful co-existence and shared history are internal factors.

  5. 5. 'Pooled sovereignty', which the textbook sees as a challenge to nationalism, is associated with:

    1. the World Trade Organization
    2. the European Union
    3. the League of Nations
    4. the Planning Commission
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The European Union's member states share decision-making powers, which the textbook calls pooled sovereignty.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery