• Practice
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Liberalism: negative, positive and libertarian

Explain what an ideology is, then trace liberalism through its three phases (negative liberalism, positive liberalism and libertarianism) and the debates on the end of ideology and the end of history.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define ideology and explain why ideologies matter in political science.
  • Compare negative liberalism, positive liberalism and libertarianism, with their thinkers and their view of the state.
  • Explain the 'end of ideology' and 'end of history' arguments and the replies to them.

The Tamil Nadu textbook defines an ideology as a set of inter-related ideas about politics, society and economy, and calls ideologies the heart and soul of political science. They answer questions about where the state comes from, how it relates to society, what form government should take and how far the state should act. Unit 8 begins with the ideology the textbook calls the most important of modern political theory: liberalism.

Origins and three phases

Liberalism emerged in the seventeenth century. The word comes from the Latin liber, free, and was made popular in the nineteenth century by supporters of the Spanish Constitution who called themselves liberals. The textbook describes three phases:

The three phases of liberalism, as given in the textbook

  1. Negative liberalism Up to about 1930: the laissez-faire state
  2. Positive liberalism From the Great Depression to the 1970s: the social welfare state
  3. Libertarianism Roughly the last four decades: the minimal state again

Negative (classical or laissez-faire) liberalism

Its political principles were set out by John Locke in his Two Treatises of Government; Thomas Paine, Montesquieu and Jeremy Bentham were other supporters, and Adam Smith gave it its economics in The Wealth of Nations. Its key ideas:

  • The individual: rational, capable and free; everyone knows and can pursue their own interests. Society is just a collection of individuals.
  • The state is a necessary evil: necessary for law and order, but a threat to liberty by its very existence.
  • Laissez-faire: French for 'leave alone'. The state's only jobs are law and order and enforcing contracts. Like a cricket umpire, it watches that rules are kept but does not play.
  • Free market: the economy is left to demand and supply.
  • Natural rights: life, liberty and property, which the state must never erode; the right to property is treated as unlimited.

Positive liberalism

Negative liberalism created great wealth, but also glaring inequality, city slums and exploited workers, against which humanists such as Ruskin protested. Two forces pushed it to change: the spread of democracy (voters demanded change) and the rise of Marxism (which urged workers to overthrow the system). During the Great Depression, US President Franklin D. Roosevelt launched the New Deal, shaped by the ideas of the economist J. M. Keynes. Thinkers such as T. H. Green, Harold Laski and L. T. Hobhouse developed positive liberalism.

  • The social welfare state: a positive instrument that builds hospitals, schools, industries, roads, railways and ports; also called the social democratic state.
  • Rights and duties are linked: rights can be modified for social welfare.
  • Freedom through the state, not freedom from the state.
  • A regulated economy: to avoid boom and slump, with progressive taxation, minimum wages, bank nationalisation and a public sector.

Libertarianism

From the 1970s critics argued that state intervention had caused industrial sickness, inefficiency, low productivity, corruption, stagnation and loss of liberty. Libertarianism, a re-application of classical liberalism, followed. Its thinkers include F. A. Hayek, Michael Oakeshott, Karl Popper, Milton Friedman, Robert Nozick and Albert Jay Nock; among leaders the textbook names US President Ronald Reagan (1981-1989), British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, and Mikhail Gorbachev, whose perestroika (restructuring) and glasnost (openness) moved the Soviet Union in this direction. Libertarians stress personal autonomy, limit the state to law and order (Nozick defended the minimal state), and warn that expanding the state leads to collectivism and loss of liberty.

India: the textbook links the New Economic Reforms of 1991 (liberalisation, privatisation, globalisation) with libertarian ideas: the state withdrew from many activities, encouraged private initiative through disinvestment, moved to indicative planning and later replaced the Planning Commission with the NITI Aayog.

The three phases compared
PointNegative liberalismPositive liberalismLibertarianism
View of the stateNecessary evil; laissez-faireInstrument of social welfareMinimal state
FunctionsLaw and order, contractsWelfare services, regulation, public sectorLaw and order
FreedomFreedom from the stateFreedom through the statePersonal autonomy
Key namesLocke, Adam Smith, BenthamGreen, Laski, Hobhouse, KeynesHayek, Nozick, Friedman

End of ideology and end of history

  • End of Ideology (1950s): Daniel Bell, with Seymour Martin Lipset, argued that the search for the ideal system had ended with the liberal democratic welfare state (mixed economy, decentralised power, competitive parties). The New Left rejected this, and others demanded an end to materialism instead.
  • End of History (1992): Francis Fukuyama argued that with the end of the Cold War liberalism had defeated communism and humanity's search for the ideal system was over. Jacques Derrida replied that liberal democracy had not ended violence, inequality and oppression, and Samuel Huntington proposed a clash of civilisations in which new rivalries between civilisations would shape politics.

Negative liberalism: freedom from the state. Positive liberalism: freedom through the state. Libertarianism: back to a minimal state.

— Summary to remember

Worked example 1: which phase?

A made-up government opens fair-price shops, builds public hospitals and taxes higher incomes at higher rates to pay for them. Reasoning: the state is acting as an instrument of welfare and regulating the economy, with progressive taxation. Answer: positive liberalism. If it instead sold its factories and limited itself to police and courts, that would be libertarianism.

Worked example 2: the umpire analogy

Why does negative liberalism compare the state to a cricket umpire? Step 1: an umpire does not bat or bowl; the players play. Step 2: the umpire only checks that the rules are kept. Step 3: in the same way the state should not take part in economic activity, which the market decides, but should only enforce law and contracts. The analogy captures the laissez-faire idea exactly.

Key takeaways: liberalism, from liber (free), passed through negative liberalism (laissez-faire, natural rights), positive liberalism (welfare state, freedom through the state) and libertarianism (minimal state, personal autonomy). Bell and Fukuyama claimed liberal democracy had won; the New Left, Derrida and Huntington disagreed.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which ideology regards the state as a necessary evil?

    1. Positive liberalism
    2. Negative liberalism
    3. Marxism
    4. Fascism
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Negative liberalism sees the state as necessary for law and order but an evil because its existence threatens liberty.

  2. 2. The two factors that, according to the textbook, changed negative liberalism into positive liberalism were:

    1. Fascism and Nazism
    2. Colonialism and nationalism
    3. Democracy and Marxism
    4. Globalisation and the WTO
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The spread of democracy (voters demanding change) and the rise of Marxism (calling for revolution) pressured negative liberalism into becoming positive liberalism.

  3. 3. Who argued for a 'minimal state' as the libertarian ideal?

    1. T. H. Green
    2. Harold Laski
    3. John Maynard Keynes
    4. Robert Nozick
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Nozick defended the minimal state and called further state functions unjustified. Green, Laski and Keynes are associated with positive liberalism.

  4. 4. Francis Fukuyama's 'End of History' thesis argued that:

    1. liberalism's victory over communism ended humanity's search for the ideal system
    2. civilisations would clash after the Cold War
    3. the welfare state had failed
    4. history would end with a world government
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Fukuyama argued that the end of the Cold War and liberalism's victory marked the end of the ideological search. The clash of civilisations was Huntington's counter-thesis.

  5. 5. 'Freedom through the state, not from the state' is the theme of:

    1. Laissez-faire liberalism
    2. Libertarianism
    3. Positive liberalism
    4. Classical liberalism
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Positive liberalism sees freedom as realised through the welfare activities of the state, while negative (classical, laissez-faire) liberalism sees freedom as freedom from the state.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery